Anniversary Mafia Game Thread - The Final Day

[[M] D'Anna]

I demand you elaborate on that! Only because no one else is tallllkinnnng.

[[M] Harry - Dad's Dad]

That's because most others are at work or sleeping, deal with it

I want to go with the safe vote today because I want to see tonight's activity uninterrupted to make conclusions on Faris, Cid, and Wedge without doing a self vote or being completely inactive. Day 5 will be a lot more riskay. Unless someone raises a major red flad later on today, I stand by my vote.

[[M] D'Anna]

People who have yet to post today:

Luneth - 2 total posts, boring inactive, safe vote for anyone who doesn't want a fight (looking at you Leila).
Relm - Posts some, but pretty much a non-entity. Those make the most dangerous mafia .
Yuffie - Second highest poster, but suspiciously absent so far.
Cid - Not really that active, possibly poisoned so he needs to step up his game if he wants to help us.
Rikku - 6 total posts, only active on Day 1 when she was messing around with Al Bhed.
Penelo - 5 total posts, not done anything remotely useful.
Balthier - Participated throughout Day 2, would like his thoughts on how it ended.

[[M] D'Anna]

That's because most others are at work or sleeping, deal with it

There is no work or rest in mafia!!

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

Wedge - can you tell us who you investigated on N2/3? Who you sent the results to? You have given us a vague answer already today, but some specifics would have been nice.
I certainly hope that your inverstigation results come through today, since that's two investigations that just happened to lead to nothing. Unlucky, eh?

My guess is he is waiting for someone to come forward with a report so that he can determine if they are lying or not.

This. I am waiting to see what the person I sent the report to does with it.

[[M] Trevor - Gay Dad]

Well I keep going back and forth on Faris, but I think I'll trust my gut for the moment, Faris is going up on my suspect list, why? Reading back on her older posts after she roleclaimed tracker, she said she was tracking Galuf every night, and why would she do that? She said earlier,

Yeah, to be honest with you. I've been watching Galuf since day 1, or rather last night. He has been rather suspiciously silent ever since he showed up on day 1. I'm not sure what to actually think of him. I've had my watch on him since then.

You hear that old man? I've got my eyes on you!

So she can track people and see where they go? Tracks down an old man night one and saw he was at the house of someone who didn't die. So her next thought is...."Suspicious!!! I'll continue to watch him!!!!" Sorry sweety, but that just doesn't sit well with me.

It seems like a waste of an investigative role to be watching an old guy who you had no reason to. Honestly this smells super scummy to me. almost as if you knew Galuf would die last night or soon for one reason or another. While I sort of doubt the mafia would kill off one of their own, I can only conclude Faris is either mafia trying to establish themselves as a townie in a convoluted way, or just sucks as an investigative role.

I mean if you see person A goes to person B's house in the night and Person B isn't dead the next morning, the logical thought is that "Oh hey, person A didn't go there to kill person B, they must have done something else". And the list of what they could have done instead is rather extensive (investigate, protect, roleblock, etc).

It just strikes me as odd how you just so happened to track the same guy 3 days in a row when a more logical explanation was he was some sort of other power role (not necessarily town aligned, but not someone performing kills either). Something just isn't adding up.

As for Wedge, just tell us who you sent reports to, and who on for nights 2 and 3. Including who the dead person is. Your lack of sharing info is concerning me, it does no one good but mafia when you keep vital info hidden away for no good reason. I just can't think of a solid reason to hide this info of who at this stage, we know your trying to send reports out, but you never tell us to who, and about who, outside night 1.

[[M] Mike - Funny Dad]

So where did the whole only poison on odd days thing come from?

Are you sure the message behind that was directed at you?

It boots nothing to evade my snares, for they are ever beset with more snares.

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

There is nothing to report since I don't get the results of my own investigations. I am not going to say who I investigated on Night 2 yet because I am not sure if Kain was allowed to do his own night action before he died and I don't want someone to pop up and deceive the town and me by saying, "Oh, I got that report, Kain must have switched me with so and so and I must have been the true target." That would just muddle things up further. Plus, Serah said she never received the first report and she was obviously town aligned and wouldn't have any reason not to tell the town about a report on an already dead doctor, so this investigative ability is pretty bunk. Better for the real cop to do the investigating and find out who is for and against town.

[[M] Trevor - Gay Dad]

Ok I'll go with it for now Wedge, but before the end of the day if no one steps up I'll want to hear the results, as it means no one received it, or your not what you claim to be. And anyone trying to do a false claim about it after you tell us the results we could probably conclude is lying about it and claiming bus driver.

Though either way Night 3 shouldn't matter as the bus driver was dead night 2, so unless there's a second bus driver there shouldn't be much worry on thigns getting swapped as I know of no other night action switching roles beyond the Nexus.

[[M] Trevor - Gay Dad]

Also,

##Vote: Rikku

We need to have a little talk darlin'.

[[M] Greg - Hot Dad]

if you're town, why haven't the mafia killed you yet? If you're mafia, well smurf.
If you're not dead because the mafia can't kill you, then that just makes things confusing.

Oh there's been a little bit of fiddling in the night. La-da-de, la-da-da, I think they've tried to kill me twice now. You'd think they'd take the hint by now.

Anyway, I will mindlessly bandwagon with you all on Luneth if I have to, she's kind of dodgy, but I'd really prefer it if you helped me twat Blank. You can believe in me! I'm like fairies or magic!

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

They tried to kill you twice? Well, that seems ridiculous, more likely two killing factions tried to kill you and failed.

[[M] D'Anna]

Anyway, I will mindlessly bandwagon with you all on Luneth if I have to, she's kind of dodgy, but I'd really prefer it if you helped me twat Blank. You can believe in me! I'm like fairies or magic!

Why so intent to bandwagon an inactive when you yourself hate that strategy:

anyway can I just say all this "HEH HEH HEH INACTIVES" is a potato

because

IT IS YOU GUYS

"Oh ho hum I will vote for an inactive to make them come out and post!"

Do you really think I'm like sitting there going "doop de doop de doop not gonna post! OHHHH NO! Someone voted for me! My one weakness!"

We all know it's ridiculous and anyone who spouts this as a good sensible tactic is trying to make you think they're good. Easy target, no-one can defend the inactives!

Just stop. In every mafia game ever.

[[M] Greg - Hot Dad]

They tried to kill you twice? Well, that seems ridiculous, more likely two killing factions tried to kill you and failed.

Oh really...? Haha. Cool.

Well, whoever it is that keeps trying to do it, HA FREAKIN' HA! is what I say.

[[M] Walter - Smart Dad]

Well I keep going back and forth on Faris, but I think I'll trust my gut for the moment, Faris is going up on my suspect list, why? Reading back on her older posts after she roleclaimed tracker, she said she was tracking Galuf every night, and why would she do that? She said earlier,

Yeah, to be honest with you. I've been watching Galuf since day 1, or rather last night. He has been rather suspiciously silent ever since he showed up on day 1. I'm not sure what to actually think of him. I've had my watch on him since then.
You hear that old man? I've got my eyes on you!

So she can track people and see where they go? Tracks down an old man night one and saw he was at the house of someone who didn't die. So her next thought is...."Suspicious!!! I'll continue to watch him!!!!" Sorry sweety, but that just doesn't sit well with me.

I can't really see where they go. I can only see who they have targeted, but I do not know anything else. Sorry if my role is unhelpful at worst. Since Galuf is gone, my main target of choice is gone. I'll see what I can do in the future though, and I'm glaaad to have your vote of confidence, Refia.

I do want to add that I agree about Rikku, I had my vote on her because of her forcing us to vote without basis of fact to rely on. I might go place my vote on her today