Anniversary Mafia Game Thread - The Final Day

[[M] Al - Biker Dad]

I take too long to make my posts. xD

[[M] Mom – Host]

You guys are diptrouts. Seriously. Sometimes I worry about you, kupo.

IMPORTANT NOTES FOR DIPtroutS:

Yuffie died. She was not modkilled. Modkills have a special note saying "I KILLED x BECAUSE THEY'RE DICKS." Although in a mindsmurf I might think to leave that off. Maybe. But not this time.

Spy is town aligned. You.. you guys and your smurfing colours man. I seriously. I MADE IT NON-RED SO YOU WOULD UNDERSTAND. Spy is an investigative type role. MAFIA SPY would be red and have Mafia in front of it so you poor saps can figure it out.

I seriously man.


Here:
[M] Wedge (2) - Penelo, Faris
[M] Setzer (1) - Rydia, Penelo
[M] Penelo (1) - Wakka
[M] Leila (1) - Balthier
[M] Relm (1) - Biggs
[M] Wakka (0) - Biggs


You can get your own damn time count, smurfing hell :mog:

[[M] Mom – Host]

Diptrouts is the best term.

[[M] Al - Biker Dad]

Alright then. Sheesh, touchy much?

Will need to rethink everything regarding Refia then.

[[M] Mom – Host]

You need to lighten up Setzer. Come have a drink and relax. It's all a big joke, ya know? Oh god I'm actually Wakka the whole time. IT IS ALL A SET UP.

Seriously though, I am just manic tired because you guys are all crazy crazy and making me sleep weird. Hang ten and that. I dunno.

You've got 9.5 hours to go~

[[M] Al - Biker Dad]

I knew it. Vote Stiltz, everyone! It's cool though, thanks for all your hard work an trout.

Right then. Refia, confirmed town with some kind of investigative role. She has been trying to call Rikku out for a while now (there was a vote cast on Day4, which seemed to come out of nowhere). Investigation into Rikku, perhaps, led to the scum accusation in Refia's list? There is no other reason I can think of that would explain Rikku being scum despite posting about as much as Penelo and Luneth.

With that, I think

##Vote: Rikku

However, this also means we have to carefully consider everyone Refia called out as mafia - 3/4 of them could be the result of investigations.

[[M] Colette]

Hello everyone. I'm really sorry that I haven't been active enough as I've been really busy with school... I hope to change that. I am also sorry if I delayed any night actions. I will try to contribute some thoughts:

I think I will believe Leila's claim for the time being, though I don't know why she would claim. I do not know why Biggs would claim Vengeful Townie, either. He was not being pressured or questioned at any point. The only thing this claim does is make people not want to lynch Biggs, similar to a bomb or beloved princess claim. The interesting difference is that Leila is copping heat for her claim and nobody has said much about Biggs. Why is that?

Does anybody not just think that Wedge's reports... kill... people? I don't know how many coincidences with victims dying I am willing to believe. I think he's either an inadvertent murderer or an intentional one who is lying. I think this situation is not going to resolve itself unless we know what Wedge actually is - it is going to keep rearing its head every day.

What has Wedge actually said apart from his reports? I know I am not one to point fingers about this, but to explain, Wedge has contributed more posts than me but has not actually said very much in them. He has used this reports thing as a crutch and I do not even know why he claimed in the first place.

[[M] Colette]

Oh yeah I'm pretty happy to stick a vote down on Wedge

##vote: Wedge

In mafia, there is no such thing as a coincidence!

[[M] D'Anna]

I had two good reasons for claiming when I did.

1. I wanted to mess with Psychotic's head a bit because he said his goal this whole game was to lynch me (which didn't work since he's bulletproof and could never have shot him anyway).
2. This one is a secret but it really it only affects the mafia.

But go ahead and vote me if you want, Luneth. If I go I'll get to use my ability and also get out of this crazy town. Win win.

You've talked about myself and Wedge, what do you think of the rest?

[[M] D'Anna]

Wedge, what is the name of your role? Please post the name. I did not believe Yuffie until she posted Jack of All Trades and it was that post that finally convinced me and caused the day to end up like it did.

I'm seriously considering calling for everyone to roleclaim and then we try to find the mafia by sifting out the BS roles. We're running out of time and we're losing useful roles left and right without the players having a chance to actually use them for the good of the town (see: Spy).

[[M] D'Anna]

Something I missed earlier.

I investigated her night 1, turned up guilty. So did Wedge night 2 and Faris night 3. I investigated Notcis this past night to determine if I'm paranoid I didn't get anything back unfortunately. So I'm rather useless, folks! Sorry.

Why investigate Noctis and not yourself. Sure, Noctis went after Blank and she flipped scum so he could hardly be on her team, but that doesn't mean he wasn't a SK or some other variety. But you know for a fact that you are town so it's a 100% guarantee of knowing if you are Paranoid or Insane?

[[M] D'Anna]

Here's what I don't like. I don't like Wakka and Leila's vote switch to Yuffie at the end of Day 4 once the votes were stacking up for Blank. It smells bad. Real bad.

[[M] Apollo]

Ok. I'm going to bed, but I promised myself I would vote before I slept.
Thank you Stiltz for confirming Refia for us. Made more sense with the mindsmurf.
In case anyone missed it before. Here is the link I posted.
Given the possibilities that this presents, it would appear that the spy can read anonymous night actions.

This means that Refia may have had four nights of understanding what was going on around the place. Not sure if its all messages (unlikely), or if it's a targeted understanding of particular night actions. (though the page does mention it being anonymous. Though who knows how it's set up this time...)

Regardless, here is Refia's summary of thoughts on everyone.
The most notable of these, from I can see would be...

[M] Wedge - Pending on some of what Wedge comes out with on his reports, I'm thinking scum. There's some things that just bother me about night actions (or lack there of).

Given Refia's role, the specific mention of Wedge's lack of night actions is quite notable.
Am I reading into this too much?
I'm quite inclined to vote Wedge due to this. If I do, Wedge will be at 5 votes (including selfvote), right?
I don't want to bandwagon, but I don't have any other leads...

For now I will go with Wedge, but I'll try to be back in the morning.

##Vote: Wedge

[[M] Colette]

I had two good reasons for claiming when I did.

1. I wanted to mess with Psychotic's head a bit because he said his goal this whole game was to lynch me (which didn't work since he's bulletproof and could never have shot him anyway).
2. This one is a secret but it really it only affects the mafia.

But go ahead and vote me if you want, Luneth. If I go I'll get to use my ability and also get out of this crazy town. Win win.

You've talked about myself and Wedge, what do you think of the rest?

I'm still doubtful but I can accept it if you wanted to mess with someone. The unusual role claim aside you have been helping the town so I will not be voting for you today.

The rest of the town:-

Setzer seems to be town. He has made a lot of solid posts and provided good insight. I also think the same of Leon and Rydia. I also think Leila is town for now.

Wakka has not done much good. You commented on his vote for Yuffie but I also find his other votes interesting. He voted for Noctis for being irritating and today he has voted for Penelo who has been inactive. To put this in other words he has voted for people who are unlikely to be actually lynched for very poor reasoning.

Penelo has been busy like myself but I think today will let me get a better handle on her. Cid has also not been around much. With these two I do not know if it is a mafia tactic or what. I know I am not in a position to cast judgment onto inactive players so I will understand if others think the same of me.

Balthier has been a little odd, coming in and out without saying too much wrong or drawing too much attention. He also hid behind Noctis in the Blank vote.

Relm hasn't said very much apart from hunting Yuffie. With Yuffie gone Relm is one to keep an eye on today.

Faris is someone who I just don't know about. Her claim seems believable but there is something not quite right with how she acts.

[[M] Harry - Dad's Dad]

Something I missed earlier.

I investigated her night 1, turned up guilty. So did Wedge night 2 and Faris night 3. I investigated Notcis this past night to determine if I'm paranoid I didn't get anything back unfortunately. So I'm rather useless, folks! Sorry.

Why investigate Noctis and not yourself. Sure, Noctis went after Blank and she flipped scum so he could hardly be on her team, but that doesn't mean he wasn't a SK or some other variety. But you know for a fact that you are town so it's a 100% guarantee of knowing if you are Paranoid or Insane?

I had no idea that I could do that.

Here's what I don't like. I don't like Wakka and Leila's vote switch to Yuffie at the end of Day 4 once the votes were stacking up for Blank. It smells bad. Real bad.

Sorry, forgot to bathe. Let me remind you: first night I investigated Yuffie she came up Guilty, so I assumed she was guilty.

Alright kids, got my results back for Noctis... GUILTY. So either Faris and Wedge are innocent or I'm useless paranoid!