Anniversary Mafia Game Thread - The Final Day

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

real investigative psychic

I meant in real life, seriously I think investigative psychics are bunk, and so is my role.

[[M] Athena]

At this point I want to know what Faris did last night.
Who did you watch?

Good point. Confirm your Tracker ass.

[[M] Apollo]

And you gunsmith, whose gun did you look for?

[[M] Athena]

Already said Luneth about 5 posts up.

[[M] Apollo]

Sorry, my brain ignored the lack of reveal there
I agree with your action though. Let's see what Luneth has to say.

[[M] Mike - Funny Dad]

real investigative psychic

I meant in real life, seriously I think investigative psychics are bunk, and so is my role.

I'm at work, where mafiascum.net is blocked, but I can't seem to find a list containing Oracle. You are most likely a Bumbling Detective; a protective/modifying role could be why Balthier took an extra day to die. The death toll of your hint recipients is too staggering to be coincidence. I can believe that a modifying role hit you once, but every time?

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

I'm at work, where mafiascum.net is blocked, but I can't seem to find a list containing Oracle. You are most likely a Bumbling Detective; a protective/modifying role could be why Balthier took an extra day to die. The death toll of your hint recipients is too staggering to be coincidence. I can believe that a modifying role hit you once, but every time?

The closest thing in the wiki to what my role is is amnesiac cop, but my role name is green not blue.

[[M] Walter - Smart Dad]

At this point I want to know what Faris did last night.
Who did you watch?

Sorry, I was trying out this new game I bought. Anyway, to answer your question. I've tracked Cid to see if he was doing anything during the night since he's been silent ever since. The result came up: Faris

Hell if I know what this means, though.

[[M] Apollo]

Let's assume Balthier didn't lie about the report.
If Penelo is telling the truth and Wedge is an SK then either Wedge has the role of SK and Courier/Mailman/Whisperer (which seems a little unfair, but I suppose it's possible), or there is someone out there who is a Courier/Mailman/Whisperer who knew/guessed to send a report to Balthier last night so that he could confirm Wedge's claim yesterday, which is highly improbable (I think we can rule this one out).
The alternative would be that Penelo is lying and Wedge did send the report to Balthier yesterday.

Initially I was quite sceptical, but the more I think about it, the more plausible the first situation becomes (by that I mean, I would consider it). It is entirely possible that Wedge has some sort of kill every other night role, but if it is the case, I wouldn't say his kills were associated with the actions he has claimed (see my analysis above).
The best way to confirm/deny this would be to know where he went each night.

[[M] Apollo]

At this point I want to know what Faris did last night.
Who did you watch?

Sorry, I was trying out this new game I bought. Anyway, to answer your question. I've tracked Cid to see if he was doing anything during the night since he's been silent ever since. The result came up: Faris

Hell if I know what this means, though.

So long you're telling the truth, we know that he has a night role, and we know what it doesn't mean.
It means that Cid isn't a killer (could still be a mafian though), he isn't a roleblocker, and he isn't inactive.
WHERE ARE YOU CID?! SHOW YOURSELF!

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

Let's assume Balthier didn't lie about the report.
If Penelo is telling the truth and Wedge is an SK then either Wedge has the role of SK and Courier/Mailman/Whisperer (which seems a little unfair, but I suppose it's possible), or there is someone out there who is a Courier/Mailman/Whisperer who knew/guessed to send a report to Balthier last night so that he could confirm Wedge's claim yesterday, which is highly improbable (I think we can rule this one out).
The alternative would be that Penelo is lying and Wedge did send the report to Balthier yesterday.

Initially I was quite sceptical, but the more I think about it, the more plausible the first situation becomes (by that I mean, I would consider it). It is entirely possible that Wedge has some sort of kill every other night role, but if it is the case, I wouldn't say his kills were associated with the actions he has claimed (see my analysis above).
The best way to confirm/deny this would be to know where he went each night.

Er what? I'm the serial killer who is the mailman, what? Also, I've already candidly told you every thing I've done every night (you even quoted it), so what more do you want me to say?

[[M] Apollo]

Sounds ludicrous, huh?
Those are the possibilities, I personally think it is more likely that you're telling the truth here.
Just need to cover all bases.

[[M] Athena]

It is fishy that everyone who gets a report ends up dead at some point soon after. But if he was a killer mailman then why would he tell the truth about the reports?

[[M] Mike - Funny Dad]

The closest thing in the wiki to what my role is is amnesiac cop, but my role name is green not blue.

Green seems to indicate a role manipulator so far.

[[M] Walter - Smart Dad]

I think Wedge is being completely honest, and that only unfortunately makes Penelo look like a big fat liar.