In my experience, every single football forum I've visited is pretty much the same. I need to have some United forum to go to, and I went to RedCafe when United Rant died (I think it's back, haven't checked for ages). I'm more of a reader than a poster, mostly in the Twitter Discussion thread and particular transfer threads, but yeah, I'm there.
A bunch of them are indeed nutters but it's easy to filter that stuff out and focus on the gold you can find amongst the drivel.
There are pros and cons to them compared to United Rant. At United Rant, they tend to be way more vulgar at every opportunity, and I couldn't browse the place at work for REASONS. However, as stereotypically blokish as they might be, they definitely appreciated my statistical analysis of things far, far more than they do at the Caf. At United Rant I was renamed Martin Tyler for a while.![]()