Pokemon Mafia - Official Game Thread (On hold)

[[M] Jeff - Single Dad]

Haha, sorry about trying to get you killed on multiple occasions, Bulbasaur xD I assure you it was only because you were inactive. ironic that you would come back at a time like this.

Well, you're probably a replacement, like Snorlax said. :] Same with Gastly.

No hard feelings, I promise

[[M] Greg - Hot Dad]

Ghastly

I promise I'll have a better grasp of the situation tomrrow. xP

[[M] Mom – Host]

Slowpoke

Vote Tally

Slowpoke: 8 - Geodude, Sandshrew, Snorlax, Kadabra, Meowth, Gastly, Clefairy, Bulbasaur
Kadabra: 4 - Psyduck, Jigglypuff, Pikachu, Slowpoke
Squirtle: 3 - Charmander, Vulpix, Eevee
Charmander: 1 - Hypno
Clefairy: 1 - Squirtle
Psyduck: 1 - Oddish
None: 2 - Togepi, Ditto

Slowpoke, please explain your reasoning as to why you think that Meowth is Mafia.

I used the info that kadabra is a werewolf to prove that meowth is a werewolf, but unfortunately it only proves it to me. Look at reactions I've gotten from meowth so far. He's done every single thing in the interest of a werewolf cooperating with Kadabra the entire time. same reason I initially expected kadabra, he was cooperating with butterfree. They have teamwork and aren't afraid to cover it up.

[[M] Mom – Host]

Slowpoke

I promise I'll have a better grasp of the situation tomrrow. xP

and by tommorow all things will seem normal but be in flux. You will know pretty much just as much as everyone else does.

[[M] Jeff - Single Dad]

Unvote:Slowpoke

I honestly just bandwagoned because I didn't know what was going on.

[[M] Helo]

Hypno

unvote:whoever
vote:Kadabra

[[M] Jeff - Single Dad]

vote:slowpoke

Did NOT bandwagon. I'm sticking with my thought that Slowpoke is mafia.

[[M] Trevor - Gay Dad]

You guys post too much, I've been pretty active but I still feel like I can barely keep up. The really inactive people are going to be really behind.

Anyway, this has gotten really crazy. I don't know what to think anymore, but it looks like it's going to be between Slowpoke and Kadabra now with most votes for Slowpoke now. If my vote's going to be wasted on Squirtle, then I may have to change it to who I think would more likely be mafia out of the two.

I think everyone who's getting overexcited should chill, though. This isn't a personal vendetta, let's try to think through this civily.

Here's something that Miriel said in the other thread.

To clear something up.

The majority of roles in play in this game can be found in the Mafia wiki, or the Mafia flash site. There are only a handful of roles which have specifically been created by Del Murder and I. Created as in, entirely new creations that we came up with ourselves. All other roles, or slight variations of roles can be found from the two linked Mafia sources.

The role of Mole is not one of the "official" roles of this game. That was just Del Murder being a trickster.

This means that mole doesn't count as one of the roles they could have created. Also, what do they mean by a handful? I'm not sure what the range there is, but it's at least more than one role that was created.

It does seem like Slowpoke's made a few obvious contradictions in this thread now, and I don't think his emotional outbursts or offensive tactics are doing him any good.

I also find it strange Slowpoke seems to know there's only 3 mafia and everyone else is innocent - Butterfree, Kadabra, and Meowth. How do you know there's only 3? In the last game with roughly the same number of players, there were 6 mafia. I don't think we should rule anyone out yet.

I have suspicions but it completely banks on certain results that I don't know for sure yet, so really, I have nothing definite. I'm undecided at what I should do right now and if my vote would actually matter if I changed it.

Thanks for all the stats, Snorlax. It's been helpful.

Slowpoke: 8 - Geodude, Sandshrew, Snorlax, Kadabra, Meowth, Gastly, Clefairy, Bulbasaur
Kadabra: 5 - Psyduck, Jigglypuff, Pikachu, Slowpoke, Hypno
Squirtle: 3 - Charmander, Vulpix, Eevee
Clefairy: 1 - Squirtle
Psyduck: 1 - Oddish
None: 2 - Togepi, Ditto

Real life calls again, so I'll have to make this one of the shorter of my posts, heh. I'll try to check back here before the day ends to see if I need to change my vote.

[[M] Joe - Army Dad]

Snorlax

Day 2 votes

Hypno Vote: Slowpoke
Hypno Unvote: Slowpoke
Hypno Vote: Snorlax
Clefairy Vote: Kadabra
Psyduck Vote: Kadabra
Kadabra Vote: Slowpoke
Sandshrew Current Vote: Kadabra
Charmander Vote: Kadabra
Jigglypuff Vote: Kadabra
Squirtle Vote: Clefairy
Oddish Vote:Psyduck
Charmander Unvote: Kadabra
Charmander Vote: Squirtle
Snorlax Vote: Charmander
Charmander Unvote: Squirtle
Charmander Vote: Slowpoke
Charmander Unvote: slowpoke
Charmander Vote: squirtle
Sandshrew Vote: Kadabra.
Vulpix Vote: Squirtle
Snorlax Unvote: Charmander
Snorlax Vote: Squirtle
Kadabra Unvote: Slowpoke
Kadabra Vote: Squirtle
Eevee Vote: Charmander
Eevee Unvote: Charmander
Eevee Vote: Squirtle
Pikachu Vote: Kadabra
Hypno Unvote: Snorlax
Hypno Vote: Charmander
Geodude Vote: Squirtle
Geodude Unvote: Squirtle
Geodude Vote: Slowpoke
Meowth Vote: Squirtle
Sandshrew Unvote: Kadabra
Sandshrew Vote: Slowpoke
Slowpoke Unvote: Kadabra
Slowpoke Vote: Squirtle
Snorlax Unvote: Squirtle
Snorlax Vote: Slowpoke
Kadabra Unvote: Squirtle
Kadabra Vote: Slowpoke
Meowth Unvote: Squirtle
Meowth Vote: Slowpoke
Gastly Vote: Kadabra
Bulbasaur Vote: Kadabra
Clefairy Unvote: Kadabra
Clefairy Vote: Slowpoke
Gastly Unvote: Kadabra
Gastly Vote: Slowpoke
Slowpoke Unvote: Squirtle
Slowpoke Vote: Kadabra
Bulbasaur Unvote: Slowpoke
Hypno Unvote: Charmander
Hypno Vote: Kadabra
Bulbasaur Vote: Slowpoke

Vote Tally

Slowpoke: 8 - Geodude, Sandshrew, Snorlax, Kadabra, Meowth, Gastly, Clefairy, Bulbasaur
Kadabra: 4 - Psyduck, Jigglypuff, Pikachu, Slowpoke, Hypno
Squirtle: 3 - Charmander, Vulpix, Eevee
Clefairy: 1 - Squirtle
Psyduck: 1 - Oddish
None: 2 - Togepi, Ditto

[[M] Adama]

Clefairy

It's pretty late here. My trainer has to go train with all the other Pokémon masters tomorrow, so I must go. Bye, friends and enemies.

Good luck to our side in lynching a mafia person!

Clefairy, cle cle!

[[M] Helo]

Hypno

Unvote: Charmander
Vote: Clefairy

[[M] Jeff - Single Dad]

I'd better get off to my pokeball too. =] Got some tournaments going on soon and I need to be rested up! Night all =D

[[M] Joe - Army Dad]

Snorlax

Day 1 Vote history

Psyduck Vote: Geodude
Pikachu Voteeodude
Hypno Vote:Psyduck
Sandshrew Vote: Psyduck
Slowpoke Vote: Geodude
Meowth Vote: Geodude
Hypno Unvote: Psyduck
Hypno Vote: Meowth
Snorlax Vote: Geodude
Geodude Vote: Psyduck
Snorlax Unvote: Geodude
Hypno Unvote: Meowth
Hypno Vote: Butterfree
Squirtle Vote: Psyduck
Kadabra Vote: Bulbasaur
Vulpix Vote: Gastly
Oddish Vote: Butterfree
Charmander Vote: Geodude
Psyduck Unvote Geodude, Vote Butterfree
Ditto Vote: Gastly
Eevee Vote: Charmander
Kadabra Vote: Geodude
Hypno Unvote: Butterfree
Hypno Vote: Psyduck
Psyduck Unvote: Butterfree
Psyduck Vote: Geodude
Clefairy Vote Butterfree
Pikachu Unvote: Geodude
Pikachu Vote: Psyduck
Psyduck Unvote: Geodude
Psyduck Vote: Butterfree
Squirtle Unvote: Psyduck
Squirtle Vote: Butterfree
Slowpoke Unvote: Geodude
Slowpoke Vote: Butterfree
Hypno Unvote: Psyduck
Hypno Vote: Butterfree
Hypno Unvote: Butterfree
Hypno Vote: Hypno
Hypno Unvote: Hypno
Hypno Vote: Geodude
Hypno Unvote: Geodude
Hypno Vote: Psyduck

Slowpoke, how does this show that Butterfree, Kadabra, and Meowth are working together? Butterfree only made three posts, and none of them were any kinds of comunication. Meowth did defend Butterfree, the reasoning being that Butterfree was active, and he thought it would be better to target sombody inactive, which you supported. Finally Kadabra never collaberated with anyone to my knowlegde. Please explain the reasoning behind your theory, because nobody else can see it.

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

vote: bulbasaur

I find this replacement person very suspiscious.

[[M] Joe - Army Dad]

Snorlax

Vote Tally

Slowpoke: 8 - Geodude, Sandshrew, Snorlax, Kadabra, Meowth, Gastly, Clefairy, Bulbasaur
Kadabra: 4 - Psyduck, Jigglypuff, Pikachu, Slowpoke
Squirtle: 2 - Vulpix, Eevee
Clefairy: 1 - Squirtle, Hypno
Psyduck: 1 - Oddish
Bulbasaur: 1 - Charmander
None: 2 - Togepi, Ditto