Danny Elfman vs. John Williams

[Kawaii Ryûkishi]

Batman vs. Superman, really, when you come down to it.

<u>Danny Elfman</u><ul type="1"><li>Pee-Wee's Big Adventure
<li>Amazing Stories
<li>Beetlejuice
<li>Batman
<li>Edward Scissorhands
<li>The Nightmare Before Christmas
<li>Sleepy Hollow
<li>Spider-Man
<li>Red Dragon
<li>Big Fish</ul><u>John Williams</u><ul type="1"><li>Jaws
<li>Star Wars
<li>Superman
<li>Raiders of the Lost Ark
<li>E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial
<li>Home Alone
<li>Jurassic Park
<li>Catch Me if You Can
<li>Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban</ul>Only listed the stuff I've heard, considering Danny's composed for about a hundred flicks and John's done about two hundred. Did you know he's been doing this since the early fifties? The man is ancient.

Items like "Star Wars" represent the entire series, of course, etc.

[Del Murder]

Batman and Williams.

[nik0tine]

Didn't John Williams also do Jurassic Park?

[Samuraid]

Both are excellent composers.

[Pauten]

Didn't John Williams also do Jurassic Park?

Yup, that he did. I like John Williams better, but yeah there both good at what they do.

[nik0tine]

How 'bout this, these guys, or Bach?

[Kawaii Ryûkishi]

Get your own thread.

[fire_of_avalon]

Elfman. I like Williams, don't get me wrong I like him a lot. But Elfman.

EDIT: And Batman.

[rubah]

Actually, for me, It's Nightmare Before Christmas vs. The Olympic Spirit.

The Olympic Spirit wins out so much it's not even funny.

Go John Williams!

(maybe after we march a danny elfman field show I could change my mind)

[krissy]

williams bcuz elder rule
which isn't to say elfman isn't amazing

[My name is...something..?]

John Williams.
Hard decision, but I think I made the right one.

[eestlinc]

Oingo Boingo vs the John Williams Tuba Concerto

[Skogs]

How 'bout this, these guys, or Bach?


Agreed, but of the two choices available, I'd have to go for Williams.

[JAS4Yeshua]

John Williams, all the way. Danny Elfman's style is great, but Williams is the master. :D

John Williams Filmography (http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0002354/)
Danny Elfman Filmography (http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0000384/)

[Shoeberto]

The problem with Elfman is that you can pretty much tell when it's his score, or at least when it came to Batman and Spiderman you could. I vote Other Guy because I can't think of any movies outside Star Wars where I could recognize his sound, which means his works are at least somewhat more unique than Other Other Guy.

[Kawaii Ryûkishi]

If you can't tell it's his sound, that means it <i>isn't</i> unique.

[eestlinc]

having a recognizeable sound is good...

both have done some great work. I'll take John Williams for epic scope.

[Shoeberto]

If you can't tell it's his sound, that means it <i>isn't</i> unique.
I meant that each of his sound tracks aren't unique from each other if they all sound the same. I can only vouch for this on Spiderman and Batman, though. I still choose Other Guy.

[Chris]

John Williams is my composer hero!
...John Barry is the only possible match.

[Kossage]

I'd have to say I like John Williams more. I've enjoyed listening to his music in Jaws, E.T., the six Star Wars movies, the three first Harry Potter movies, the two first Jurassic Park movies, the three Indiana Jones movies, and of course Superman. He has this fantastic ability to create a world of his own through music, and he has composed many famous themes during his career. He knows how to weave themes together and knows to create unique and emotional themes (Imperial March, Force theme, Jurassic Park theme etc.), unlike James Horner who nowadays re-uses many of his themes in his newest scores (although Horner did compose some wonderful scores too, such as Willow and The Land Before Time to mention a few).

I do enjoy Elfman's works too in scores such as the first two Batman movies, the Nightmare Before Christmas, Sleepy Hollow, Spider-Man movies, Darkman, Big Fish, and Edward Scissorhands (one of my all time favourites; gotta love that choral work and beautiful themes there, not to mention that "the Grand Finale" is one of the best songs he has ever composed) just to name a few. Elfman used to have this quite odd and quite crazy style in his early works, but nowadays he doesn't compose like that as often as before, although his scores are still good.

All in all, I like John Williams more, although Danny Elfman is an awesome composer as well. It's just that Willams just knows how to make things work and how to create a musical world that can even live outside the movie (this is clearly evident in the Star Wars movies, at least the Original Trilogy anyway), whereas Elfman sometimes stumbles with his work and can't hold the consistency in some of his scores, although most of the time Elfman does manage to create wonderful themes such as the theme heard in "Grand Finale" in Edward Scissorhands for example. So yes, both Williams and Elfman are wonderful composers, but if I had to choose between them, I'd choose John Williams.

[Big D]

John Williams has a great style. Enjoyable, epic, with a lot of spirit and often a great pace. The themes from Indiana Jones, Jurassic Park, Star Wars and Jaws are classic recognisable to virtually anyone. I'm also enormously fond of Williams' music from the 1996 Olympic Games.

Danny Elfman's good, but his works don't stand out for me so much.
Didn't he also compose the theme to The Simpsons?

[eestlinc]

yea, the Simpson's theme is Elfman's work.