Maybe it was just they way you worded it... I dunno. Your problem (imo) is that you fail to see the bad in Rosa, and Arcane can't see the good in her. But I'm just going to leave it at that.
I'm not trying to act like I'm better than him. I've spent more than a year trying to get people to look deeper into Rosa, and I've dealt with people like him so adamant that there can't be anything but bad things about her for so long that I'm easily sick of and annoyed with it. However, I'm not someone who refuses to see the flip side, as he seems to be. Rosa's a liability at two points. Rydia could have melted the ice on Mt. Hobs without Rosa there (something I recently came to accept after DISCUSSING it openly with someone who actually wants to discuss her rather than find ways of confirming personal bias). BUT, she also has a lot more good to her than a lot of people are willing to see, and there's some amount of good to events in the game where people choose to only see the bad.
You are no better than ArcaneDude. So stop acting like you're better than him in every way.
