I get the ideas from your dumbass. At least i'm not pointing out the smurfing obvious:
Yes that's what tends to happen at the end of a night phase.Quote:
Okay so then my theory of she was killed at night by a Mafia or second party still stands.
I get the ideas from your dumbass. At least i'm not pointing out the smurfing obvious:
Yes that's what tends to happen at the end of a night phase.Quote:
Okay so then my theory of she was killed at night by a Mafia or second party still stands.
I thought you were a dick for that yelling post, but you can take a joke so props to you. You're okay with me, Orange.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Orange
Although gotta say, telling people not to vote for inactives could well encourage mafia to be inactive just because they now know anyone who votes for them will be ripped into. Probably should've waited for more people to vote for inactives, then whooped their asses rather than warning them in advance. :bou::bou::bou::bou: happens though.
Hi, Orange. :)
So, now we've yet to hear from Pear and Red Apple this day.
Votecount so far, I believe:
Blueberry - (3) Green Apple, Kiwi, Lime
Green Apple - (1) Pomegranate
Orange - (1) Watermelon
Peach - (1) Mango
Plum - (1) Grape
Watermelon - (1) Cherry
Oh man you're so clever. Actually there was uncertainty about the furry role and some thought the furry died if it targeted Mafia. Get off your high horse dude.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Orange
Where out of anything that I've said did you see me say that I'm leaning towards Blueberry being a bad guy? I said I'm not 100% sure he's innocent. That does not mean I think he's a bad guy. Since it's only Day 2 I have very little evidence that anyone alive is 100% good or bad. The only 100% I have is for myself and the characters who have been sent to the farplane. I explain why I don't agree with you in the long post that took me forever to do. Check it out.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] LimeI don't understand what you're saying. You're leaning toward Blueberry being a bad guy but you don't agree with me? Why not?Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Pomegranate
That's not what happens at every night phase in every game. By the way, being an asshole is not allowed in this game. Go read the rules.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Orange
Assholes make the game fun though.
Well you guys lynched the doctor. So it's not like you really get a lot of protective roles. Even if the role IS right in that it targets a mafia and it dies then that's not what happened because the mafia had to target someone. If they had there would have been two deaths and not just the one. Unless the Hosts are making the kill player specific. In that case, said player could have been roleblocked but I highly doubt it.
SUMMARY:
Doctor is gone though so unless there is another protective role then someone else would have died last night had the STD thing been correct about mafia resulting in strawberries death.
So yeah.... mafia killed them last night MOST LIKELY.
I refuse to defend myself against this rubish.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] MangoYOU KILLED OUR DOCTOR FOR THIS?Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Peach
I AM SO OUTRAGED THAT I AM TYPING IN CAPITAL LETTERS
LOOK AT ME GO
WHOA-A-A-A-AOH!
##vote: Peach
ok I think I calmed down somewhat NO WAIT HERE I GO AGAIN smurf YOU PEACH!!!
METAPHORICALLY SPEAKING!!! smurf YOU!!!
seeing as how typing in all caps constitutes shouting on the internet, I am now curious as to see whether or not I will get lynched for being a noisy...whatever fruit I am. Pear or olives or something I dunno.
I don't believe that this is completely accurate. Everyone is just as likely to be Mafia as everyone else, so the fact that a player is staying out of the spotlight isn't really an accurate means of judging their role. A more practical reason to vote inactives is to get rid of the people who aren't helping. In this case, it's much, much more appropriate to instead vote those who are active and saying very little.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Pomegranate
This post is less directed at you and more so at the entire group of players. Just something to think about.
The postceding argument relies on the fact that Town Furry is in fact town-aligned. Judging by the "Town" in the title, I'm going to assume that it is.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Pomegranate
Excuse me? We just lost a cop and an extra kill each night all in one kill! On top of that a doctor, like you said. But, in my opinion, Town Furry is much more powerful than a doctor.
And Mafia will frequently rely on the fact that people feel such as you do in order to move in the open without being noticed. I've seen it happen many times. Because Mafioso understand that people will think that the people in the spotlight are drawing too much attention - staying in the spotlight is exactly what most think is top priority for a Mafioso - they think that they can hide easily by sitting in said spotlight. Again, activity is not an accurate basis for judgment, unless of course the inactive in question is hurting the town too much. It's extremely unlikely that an inactive will be Mafia though. Generally speaking, players with Mafioso accounts will have more fun with the game, so they won't be able to force themselves to be inactive for too long.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Pomegranate
Although you consede that you are wrong, I'm going to emphasize my opinion for a moment. I disagree with this whole-heartedly. If the Mafia want to win this game (with sixteen players, I figure that we have three or four Mafia, unless we have a third party, which is very possible), they're going to make a vote that matters during the day. Inactives hinder the town to an enormous extent, and those hindrences aid the Mafia. Mafia aren't going to vote seriously on an inactive at any time during a game unless it's faining townsperson. However, faining town is much lower on a Mafia's priorities than is killing town, so this happens extremely infrequently, and then mostly with noob Mafia.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Grape
This is absolutely inconsequential now that the role is gone. That's exactly what I'm saying. If the role was town-aligned, we just lost an amazing (albeit slightly risky) power role.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Watermelon
Okay, enough for theory. Let's get some relevant thoughts going.
This is what I'm talking about! This isn't helping at all, Cherry. You're being patronizing and just arguing, not discussing. If Watermelon isn't Mafia, then you're condemning an innocent man. Everyone is defensive in Mafia. If you don't defend yourself, you get killed. YOU GET KILLED. So defensiveness is not solely suspicious. It must be paired with other things first. Now, if you had instead voted someone else, say, Pomegranate (just a random role here), and then Watermelon jumped to Pomegranate's defense, it'd be suspicious. Sorry for the reference there, Pomegranate. Nothing personal :3Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Cherry
No, it really isn't.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Cherry
I agree with this in its entirety.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Lemon
I'm gonna lay it out. We need less arguing and more discussion. I didn't like all of that pointless junk with Banana on Day 1, which is why I voted him. We weren't unjustified in voting him; we can only vote based on what we know, and we know very little on Day 1. Also, we've had some mix-ups because of jokes and whatnot. Jokes are cool. It's okay to drop them, along with some sarcasm, every once in a while, but words are all that we have to go off of in this game, so keep the jokes and sarcasm to a minimum and it'll help the Town A LOT. Honestly, most of the arguing so far has been based off of such jokes. Without the jokes, we would be somewhere more productive right now. Heck, we might even have our Doctor right now.
And now onto my personal opinions. I know that it's early in the game, but I'm gonna go for it anyway. I'll just list all of them that are relevant.
[M] Orange - You need to chill out. This is a game. You are taking it too seriously. Colours matter. They really do. Being gone for so long will draw attention. Being gone for so long and then coming back so violently will draw even more attention. I'm not talking about good attention.
[M] Peach - That's me!
[M] Watermelon - Your excuse for voting Red Apple is absolutely meaningless. You can't just vote for someone randomly because you don't remember them posting much, after which you say openly that you understood at the time that Red Apple didn't "deserved" the vote. Just because it's all cleared up now doesn't mean that it's "all good." This isn't the most scummy thing that's happened yet, but it is in fact scummy.
[M] Raspberry - You haven't said much so far, but what you have said has been rooted in logic, and I like that. You're not arguing pointlessly with people.
[M] Blueberry - I think that the majority of votes against you has to do with the fact that you jumped on Banana so early. I don't agree with this at all. I'm not saying that you're scummy. I'm not saying that you're innocent. I'm just saying that I don't agree with the general concensus against you.
[M] Pomegranate - I don't agree with a lot of your logic, but you don't seem overly scummy to me. I have to stress though that colours do matter.
[M] Kiwi - I agree with Raspberry's idea. I even think that you are more suspicious than Blueberry. I believe that, if you flip scum, Kiwi, Blueberry is definitely Mafia.
[M] Plum - You seem level-headed. As of right now, I don't see you as scummy at all.
[M] Mango - You have added absolutely nothing to the discussion yet. You're distracting the town, and that is a horribly scummy thing to do. Tell us something that matters.
I'll address other players later. I have some things to get done before dinner.
Okay seeing as everyone is getting a little bit heated I am going to change the tone a bit. Come on guys, this is supposed to be fun! No need for vulgar words like "asshole" and "dumbass" and "rusty trombone".
But yes, if you are having trouble trying to decide who is evil or not, I'll divulge my methods for determining my fellow townsman's worth and you can apply it for yourselves. It's a really simple concept actually.
Do you know Um Bongo? They drink it in the Congo. Like seriously, I'm not :bou::bou::bou::bou:ting you, there's a cartoon rhino and a song and everything. Check it out:
YouTube - Um Bongo!
In case you couldn't quite catch the words, allow me to serenade you again.
Way down deep in the middle of the Congo,
A hippo took an apricot, a guava and a mango.
He stuck it with the others, and he danced a dainty tango.
The rhino said, "I know, we'll call it Um Bongo"
Um Bongo, Um Bongo, They drink it in the Congo.
The python picked the passion fruit, the marmoset the mandarin.
The parrot painted packets, that the whole caboodle landed in.
So when it comes to sun and fun and goodness in the jungle,
They all prefer the sunny funny one they call Um Bongo!
See? They drink that :bou::bou::bou::bou: in the Congo. Now lets have a look at which fruits they use. Obviously, they like Mango. We're awesome. They also endorse Mandarin's in the congo, which is basically the same thing as an Orange. An Apricot is pretty much just a yellow plum, so he's cool too. As for guava, that is just a fancy way of saying Pomegranite anyway.
So you see, anything that the Congolese see fit to add to their tasty fruit beverage must be above board, there is no way they would use mafia fruits to hydrate their little ones! So I think it is safe to assume that any of us fruits that they drink in the Congo are all the good guys.
So there you have it folks. Believe in the good people of the Congo, don't vote for Um Bongo.
That is exactly what I'm trying to say. The role is confusing however and it is easy to confuse getting an STD with death. This is why unfamiliar roles should be explained.
Let's be done with this discussion of the Town Furry's role. We've established what it does. If someone doesn't understand, they can go read through where it was explained. It's not that complicated. You're wasting our time.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Orange
I can't tell if this is sarcasm or not, but please don't support him.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M]Plum
I'm not seriously getting angry, Mafia arguments are just funny because in the end it's just Mafia and it doesn't matter that much. Makes some damn good reading afterward as well.
On a more annoyed tone, even though I feel I keep going on about this, I think the Town Furry role has been taken the wrong way entirely. It is an investigative role which may undesired effects for the town, but the role is so confusing we need an explanation.
Yeah, I misread what you typed. I was thinking you saying, "While I am not 100% Blueberry is innocent..." was meaning that you thought he was a bad guy. My bad.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] PomegranateWhere out of anything that I've said did you see me say that I'm leaning towards Blueberry being a bad guy? I said I'm not 100% sure he's innocent. That does not mean I think he's a bad guy. Since it's only Day 2 I have very little evidence that anyone alive is 100% good or bad. The only 100% I have is for myself and the characters who have been sent to the farplane. I explain why I don't agree with you in the long post that took me forever to do. Check it out.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] LimeI don't understand what you're saying. You're leaning toward Blueberry being a bad guy but you don't agree with me? Why not?Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Pomegranate
We have no evidence that anyone is 100% anything until they die. I agree, that's just the way the game of Mafia goes.
I'd like to quote a great sage in response to this:Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Peach
"Distracting the town" :lol: Seriously, where do you people come up with this stuff?Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Peach
Not true! This is why we have investigative roles.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Lime
Whatever, I'm not gonna argue with you. If you have nothing intelligent to add, then I'm gonna move along.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] MangoI'd like to quote a great sage in response to this:Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Peach
"Distracting the town" :lol: Seriously, where do you people come up with this stuff?Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Peach
Mango what is going on? I hope you're not some weird role that requires you to post stupidly!
No, no, Peach, you're right, I should do something intelligent.
Like, say, I don't know, voting off a power role for being "noisy".
If Mango's role is similar to Bahamut's from the last game, he's doing it all wrong.
I meant Ifrit. Not Bahamut. I'm stupid.
Bahamut was a Death Miller
o lolz
Peach, if we went by what Plum is describing then yes Strawberry did have investigative cop powers, but keep in mind that they also had STD spreading powers which is a killing power. Strawberry could have transmitted the disease to you, me, or anyone else and they would DIE. That isn't to say that it's a good thing Strawberry died especially if it's true she had investigative powers, but I still find a doctor to be much more useful than a disease spreading possibly investigative role.
Mango, you are acting strange as usual. Posting completely bogus and random things. It's like you're asking to get lynched.
Peach, colors do matter sometimes. I didn't say that they don't, but I said that in regards to the Town Furry role as of right now it shouldn't be a primary importance. We already know that it's a town role so the color argument at this point is futile. But I agree with Peach that we're focusing way too much on this role when we should be weeding out baddies right now so I'm going to drop it.
I felt my explanation needed to be said due to the fact that Pomegranate seemed to need it. ;) Peach stop wasting our time on saying i'm wasting your time.
I still don't think coloUrs matter. They did in that one game but that was it. Depending on your host you can have different colors. Only way they really matter is if they are green or red. But that's just my opinion.
Hey, to be fair, basing votes off of the Um Bongo theme song is just about as logical as "Hey our doctor is noisy, let's kill him" :shobon:
I have a Havard Professorship in mafia and I declare Mango is not contributing to the game, nor playing the role properly and furthermore... :holmes:
I know we are a very exciting fruit to watch, but take a look at the Doctor Murderer (aka Peach) sometime, will you? :|
Also Plum, what's the point of giving people new roles if you have to explain everything right away? Ruins all the fun of being a host. Sure it's a stupid sounding role but whatever, I can wait till the end to get find out what it is. If they feel like explaining something they will otherwise keep moving on! Can't understand something they wont explain :p
The only thing I need Orange to do is for Orange to actually contribute other then defending themselves with "DON"T VOTE FOR INACTIVE" because you weren't very active.
It's just hard to play when you are unsure of what roles people are and what their actual purpose is. It makes progression hard and keeps us at the early phase for much longer/a longer amount of time. It's not of massive importance but it's something that has a degree of relevance.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Orange
It'd ruin the game though wouldn't it. To tell exactly what's what right when someone died.
No it wouldn't.
"Town" furry. 'sall you need to know, bub. :)
Obvious distractions away from suspicious people are obvious.
We know what a doctor is when he dies, we know what a cop is when he dies, we know what a roleblocker is when he dies, why not another role? I admit I've probably been playing too much small Mafia where it's all quite linear.
##Vote: Mango
Distractions don't mean Mafia but I have no other clue so the next best thing please. Especially seeing as we are close to lynching active and helpful members.
Such noisy noisy fruit! There is so much meaningless horse pucky flying around here its hard to discern mafia from townie!
Peach, I'm sorry you disagree with my fabulous self but I think my thoughts on Watermelon hold more water (no pun intended) then your long winded state of play post. But since I voted to lynch Banana too turning on you for disagreeing with me would be plain stupid ;)
I find it kinda strange that the pretty little Blueberry hasn't said anything given he/she is on the chopping block, but I'd say its a time zone thing rather than anything sinister.
I think everyone is putting too much thought into the whole STD thing. I reckon whoever got the STD just had some sort of ill effect on our doctor if he tried to protect an infected person, which well since we lynched him case closed.
Let's not get hung up on the dead people and concentrate on the alive ones.
Peach is probably not the only scumball out there - it'd be a stupid set up if he was. Worth looking at others, though.
Just gonna quote this againAs serious analysis now, acting upset by the night kill and then asking others to lead the discussion is classic mafia behaviour. Watermelon is probably my #2.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] MangoThis is a very bad thing also tell me what to talk about please town thank youQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Watermelon
I amQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Plum
A) Active
B) Helpful
Your vote is utter bull:bou::bou::bou::bou:. The old "HE'S NOT BEING SERIOUS, WE HAD TO LYNCH 'EM" excuse. Please. :roll2
Mark these words: STDs will kill any town member who has slept with the infected furry. Laddy has done the exact same role in the last game he hosted and that is how it worked.
Rich. You are not helpful, you've been blathering on about some bongo crap for way too long. Even better is the fact that you have absolutely no sincerity until someone votes for you, and then you get all defensive.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] MangoI amQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Plum
A) Active
B) Helpful
Your vote is utter bull:bou::bou::bou::bou:. The old "HE'S NOT BEING SERIOUS, WE HAD TO LYNCH 'EM" excuse. Please. :roll2
:roll2
Ok, Plum, let's talk about dead people seeing as how that is apparently how you help the town.
Boy, Strawberry sure is dead. Yup. Dead as in the opposite of alive. And what with the (probably) only protective role being dead, let's look for the most convoluted explanation as to a death instead of the most obvious one. (THE MAFIA DID IT!!!)
And as for "YOU ARE ACTING DEFENSIVE WHEN PEOPLE ACCUSE YOU!" you're the only person who has accused me. And of course I'm going to defend myself when the reasoning is "uhhh distractions aren't mafia but I have no clue really guys :hahaha:"
Sorry buddy but I've been way more productive to the town than your "LET'S CONCENTRATE ON DEAD PEOPLE" tactic and it's not my fault if you ignore other posts because you have an unhealthy fixation with ones that mention Um Bongo.
I just disagree with your methods. Not you :3Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Cherry
I think that you should present your logic in a more sympathetic manner, that's all.
Anyway,
This is all opinion-based. Give us some facts.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Mango
I'll give you a fact. You are exhibiting behaviour that will distract the town on some level, most likely on a higher level. I'd appreciate it if you added some to the discussion. I won't vote for you yet, but only because I want to give you enough time to contribute.
[M] Mango, there's a lot that we can learn from dead players. Their roles, the manner in which they killed, the people who they affronted before they died - these are all things that can help in a large way to determine the roles of other players.
Uh, no. I've provided the correct definition of the Town Furry, challenged Banana's bizarre affliction with the joke and now I'm challenging you. Give me a quote to support what you're accusing me of because because what you're saying is BS to make yourself feel smarter unless you show evidence. :|Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Mango
This is what I'm talking about when I reference distractions. I shouldn't be sitting here explaining the game to you. I shouldn't have to do that. I'm done wasting my time on you, Mango.
When I said "you," I meant Mango.
Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] PeachI just disagree with your methods. Not you :3Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Cherry
I think that you should present your logic in a more sympathetic manner, that's all.
This is all opinion-based. Give us some facts.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Mango
I'll give you a fact. You are exhibiting behaviour that will distract the town on some level, most likely on a higher level. I'd appreciate it if you added some to the discussion. I won't vote for you yet, but only because I want to give you enough time to contribute.
Dear Peachy I'll agree my methods are odd but they make sense to me;)
I agree Mango is being really really distracting but I'm not as convinced of him as I am of Watermelon. I think Mango is just being a douche townie rather than scum (no offensive buddy:bigsmile:)
Here's a fact: couldn't give a :bou::bou::bou::bou: if you did vote for us, because when they find out who we are and our alignment, you're incredibly smurfing dead. So knock yourself out :monster:Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Peach
Read my posts. I have made good points against you and Watermelon. What more do you want me to say about them? Feel free to ask questions about my suspicions and I'll do my best to answer them.You're right. Guess we better spend the entire day talking about the ins and outs of their role instead of actually finding some mafia. That's a good tactic and not "exhibiting behaviour that will distract the town on some level".Quote:
[M] Mango, there's a lot that we can learn from dead players. Their roles, the manner in which they killed, the people who they affronted before they died - these are all things that can help in a large way to determine the roles of other players.
No you haven't. We won't know the correct definition until the game is over.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Plum
Oh no, someone telling jokes! That's surely mafia behaviour! You caught a live one there, Plum!Quote:
challenged Banana's bizarre affliction with the joke
No, you're making a fool of yourself.Quote:
and now I'm challenging you.
"Heh you think you're smart but you know what you're not :smug:" nice ad hominem attack you got going on there. But I digress-Quote:
Give me a quote to support what you're accusing me of because because what you're saying is BS to make yourself feel smarter unless you show evidence. :|
Here's your quote. Distractions don't mean mafia... but you're going to vote for the guy everyone calls distracting anyway. The name of the game is "mafia". Not "guys who distract". Who the smurf votes for someone when they think the behaviour that person is exhibiting is not the way mafia act?Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Plum
ps: none taken cherry :aimkiss:
I agree. I'm not of the opinion that Mango is scum yet. I just think that you aren't helping, Mango.
Could you restate your case on Watermelon, Cherry? Leave out the picking at random part.
Your first real act was to contribute a vote about 8 posts into the thread with no basis other than personal prejudice. This is obviously a very considerate and un-mafialike act!Quote:
Originally Posted by All following quotes by Plum
Quote:
The wonders of humour are lost on poor Banana.
Quote:
if we're going to read into things so much, maybe it's possible Banana is unhappy that Watermelon is in danger and is trying to turn the town on Red Apple. Personally I don't believe this but yeah, way too over analytical.
then he spends time trying to bail out Red Apple from Banana's suspicions accusing him of misreading into Jokes and insinuating that Banana and Watermelon were mafia in collusion, and now we know that Banana was our doctor.Quote:
I didn't come to Red Apple's aid, I told you your suspicions were not well founded. Isn't it funny how you vote the person who voted Watermelon, cast suspicion on the other person and make Watermelon safer. These are the kinds of things you should be looking for, not silly jokes.
the old "I'm going now" chestnut right as he tries to deflect criticism of himself back onto our former Doctor.Quote:
I have to go soon.
No, really, you are wrong. You voted because he made a joke and I told you you read into things too much. Don't turn this back on me.
then he again defends people who were directly involved in the killing of the doctor, and has the nerve to comment on the "i have to go now" excuse right after doing it himself. Indicative of poor character.Quote:
What a nice coincidence! 'I agree with you, this person is fishy because I feel so and you said so, everybody else is just as fishy, vote and bye.'
First off your hit and run vote puts Blueberry up to three votes, which would not be questionable if you had actually given a justifiable reason you had thought up, or at least an extension on the aforementioned reason. The good old 'I have to go now' tops it off really.
Aggro's random fruit for making casual throwaway comments, after defending Red Apple making jokes earlier in the thread, at the same time as making many posts about STD's that served no real purpose other than to misdirect the flow of discussion away from working out who could be mafia, while at the same time whinging at anybody he percieves to be doing the same thing.Quote:
Btw, these are the fantastically insightful comments made by Orange. Every. Single. Last. One of them.
So far all Plum has done is defend people who were trying to accuse our doctor of being mafia, misdirect the flow of discussion and lash out aggressively at people who dare to go against his own ideas.
But this man is not suspicious at all, no. Rather, the fruits posting about concentrated juice drinks are clearly the deranged criminals here!
My last post was @Cherry.
Wow, you ignored the rest of the quote where I voted for you. Nice one.
First off, at the time there was no knowing Banana was the Doctor. You are really bad at basic literacy, as I said it is just as likely that he and Watermelon are working together than it is likely the little comedian is misleading us. That kind of means that theory was barely serious if you still don't get it.
I didn't actually vote for Banana. If I wanted him that bad I would have. And once again, nobody knew he was a doctor. You should have spoken up, but oh wait, you didn't know, because it was day one.
I did not bandwagon vote and then go. I just left, because as human beings we are generally occupied by other things. My departure was not nearly as suspicious.
Funny how you only bring all this up when I vote for you. It screams butthurt.
While Mango's sudden change of behavior troubles me, I agree that focusing on the dead when there's other things we should be focusing on is silly. I am pretty much repeating myself with that one though, but a few people didn't seem to be getting that.
To put it in simple terms & not to be long winded, Watermelon was one of 3 players who voted for inactive players on Day 1. At first my choose Watermelon out of those 3 was totally random but he/she in subsequent posts made quite the effort to dismiss his behavior as merely Day 1 randomness. Examples:Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Peach
Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Watermelon
If Watermelon had of just dismissed my assertion immediately I would've probably changed my vote to Blueberry. But my vote as it stands is for Watermelon. Pick all the holes in my logic all you want now guys;)Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Watermelon
Yes I am deeply offended by your well thought out vote for me in a game of mafia. I have never been voted for in a game of mafia before, and this insult to my character has cut me more than you could ever know.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Plum
Sorry, sassy lassy, I'm actually having the time of my life making fun of your terrible reasoning here. :jess:
but seriously, is all you have "you are dumb! learn literacy!!" and "you DARE stand up for yourself when someone votes for you"? because I think you need a new angle. Maybe try to accuse me of exposing myself to children at a Burger King or something.
Oh and, how is it relevant that no one knew he was the doctor before he died? The fact is he was the doctor, so no matter how suspicious any of his actions may have seemed, they weren't, because he wasn't a mafia. Therefore the suspicion then falls on those who rounded on someone who eventually turned out to be a Townie and rallied around those accusing him of being mafia. Not to mention you've been pretty unrepentant about it since then and continued to show signs of favouring Red Apple.
fdvjkdbfvhjfbvhjdbfhjfjhff hjndbnkfdnbkgfbmkfmbkf
probably one of your better posts today
You are such a bumface.
##Unvote: Plum
I keep my promises. Mango your argument that Plum killed the doctor makes no sense. We only know that Banana was the doctor because he is dead. Nobody had any way to know that Banana was the doctor.
:lol:Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Plum
Okay, I understand now. I still don't agree with you, but everything has been said and we're in understanding now. Thanks :3Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] CherryTo put it in simple terms & not to be long winded, Watermelon was one of 3 players who voted for inactive players on Day 1. At first my choose Watermelon out of those 3 was totally random but he/she in subsequent posts made quite the effort to dismiss his behavior as merely Day 1 randomness. Examples:Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Peach
Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Watermelon
If Watermelon had of just dismissed my assertion immediately I would've probably changed my vote to Blueberry. But my vote as it stands is for Watermelon. Pick all the holes in my logic all you want now guys;)Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Watermelon
Plum, just give up. It's futile.
I mean to give up the convincing of Mango. The stubbornness knows no bounds, and it doesn't appear that we'll get anything meaningful out of him any time soon.
Where did I argue that he killed the doctor? All I said was that he has consistently defended the actions of those who tried to cast suspicion on the doctor as mafia before and following the doctors death. Also, I hate to quote myself but:Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Grape
:kiss:Quote:
Oh and, how is it relevant that no one knew he was the doctor before he died? The fact is he was the doctor, so no matter how suspicious any of his actions may have seemed, they weren't, because he wasn't a mafia. Therefore the suspicion then falls on those who rounded on someone who eventually turned out to be a Townie and rallied around those accusing him of being mafia.
Stubborness according to Peach:
Defending yourself from accusations of being mafia when you are not actually mafia.
By the way, Peach, I did invite you to ask me any questions you felt like asking on the subject of who I found suspicious (You and Watermelon) but good job in trying to write someone who is accusing you of being mafia as not meaningful.
Unfortunately for you, I am not going away, and my vote against you won't either.
PS: Love you, Plum :love:
No problem Peachy ;) But now that you've given up on Mango offer up another possible mafioso so the douche off in the last 2 pages of this thread makes it hard to discern anything outside of my Watermelon theory :p
Hey Cherry, seeing as you're up in Watemelon's grill, what do you think of that quote I picked out? Of him asking the town what they wanted to talk about today? To me that is pretty damn suspicious. I'd like to hear another view on it though, and you seem like a clear-headed fellow.
You know I totally missed that Mango to be honest (this thread is filled with distraction). When you add the post you picked out too my theory my vote for Watermelon just galvanized!Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Mango
It is and it's clear to me that the only way this early on to try make sense of what happened yesterday and weed out who was really defending who is to lynch one of the people who were on the chopping block with Banana that contributed the least, acted the most suspicious, and gave the poorest reasoning.
##Unvote: Green Apple
##Vote: Watermelon
I meant it is to Mango's comment about Watermelon.
Haha, you guys looking way too hard into this. You have no hard proof that I am Mafia.
I'm glad we can agree on that. However, Peach is still my #1 and I'd like some thoughts on that.
Here is my case.
- Voted off our doctor for poor reasoning - being "Noisy", whatever that means.
- Has since ignored any attempts at debate about the issue and has attempted to write it off as "rubish" and not meaningful.
- Hypocrisy when it came to the dead guy debate issue:
Quote:
Let's be done with this discussion of the Town Furry's role. We've established what it does. If someone doesn't understand, they can go read through where it was explained. It's not that complicated. You're wasting our time.
ie, changes her view whenever the view of the town seems to change. How convienient. ;)Quote:
[M] Mango, there's a lot that we can learn from dead players. Their roles, the manner in which they killed, the people who they affronted before they died - these are all things that can help in a large way to determine the roles of other players.
For all my bickering with Plum, I still think Peach and, to a lesser extent, Watermelon are reaaaal bad dudes.
Sorry for playing badly guys. ;(
It's interesting that you come out and post when people start accusing you. Where have you been for the past 4 hours?Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Watermelon
Green Apple is my #1 right now, but just as suspected Watermelon would come out and play when someone voted for him. Too predictable.
This pretty little Cherry wants to hear Watermelon plead its case, I might change my vote if I can be convinced but its gonna have to be a good case ;)Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Pomegranate
pockets of white desireQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Cherry
as ever,
they overflow
hush now, my darling.
you can tell i'm not being played by marick because I can actually write poetry
Oh yeah. Very predictable, like something a Mafia would do, hm?? I'm defending my pride and honor as a watermelon! All you have against me is what I have said or being defensive, yet I'm not responsible for Banana's lynching or the death of Strawberry.
Mango your just jealous ;)Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Mangopockets of white desireQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Cherry
as ever,
they overflow
hush now, my darling.
Yes keyword defending. Instead of aiding the town with discussion you instead lurk the thread and wait until someone calls you out until posting. How wonderful.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Watermelon
Well, what do I have to add to the discussion that's already have been said by another fruit?
Yeah but you didn't try to stop either now did you? As I've seen from previous games it's those who distance themselves most when the town messes up that are scum. Your just picking a spot on the compost heap right now darling ;)Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Watermelon
...Quote of the century!Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Watermelon
I'll just say right now that I'm not Mafia scum, so picking on the big guy is not gonna solve anything.
Watermelon, my point is that you should not just sit on the side lines while people vote off innocent people. If you have something to contribute then say it. Who cares if someone else already mentioned it? It makes it look like you may be afraid to reveal too much or give too much help to town.
I'm way too pretty to have a size complex, the best things come in small packages ;)Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Watermelon
I've seen things you people wouldn't believe.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Watermelon
Already been have said not of being on yet.
Attack ships on fire off the shoulder of Orion.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Pomegranate
Any of you scrumptious little fruits wanna do a vote count?
I watched C-beams glitter in the dark near the Tannhauser gate.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Cherry
Please stop quoting Blade Runner.
All those moments will be lost in time... like tears in rain.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Pomegranate
Time to vote Peach.
I just gave up on arguing with Mango, for the record. I've already stated my opinion on this numerous times though, so I'll be done with it.
I actually find Kiwi the most suspicious.
Solid logic, right? Nah, but it's okay because this is Day 1.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Kiwi
So then you say that you reasonably support the logic that you used in your Day 1 randomness post?Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Kiwi
This trend, Kiwi's empty logic, has been consistent up until now. I'm not saying that it's a definite scum move, but I think there's some weight in it. We'll see what happens with Kiwi in the future.
[M] Red Apple - He joke voted and Banana got on him. Despite Red Apple admitting it was a joke he never did change his vote from Watermelon.
[M] Orange - Posted that people should not vote for inactive people most likely because Orange was that inactive person. Hasn't really contributed anything aside from telling people not to vote for inactives, discuss the color argument, or talk about Strawberry's role. Orange is discouraging discussion despite failing to present anything worth discussing.
[M] Peach - "You are a noisy Banana *vote*" Yeah, not cool.
[M] Raspberry - Tried coming up with a post that defended Blueberry and made Kiwi look bad, but ended up looking silly because Kiwi posted right before him.
[M] Pear - Hardly posted anything and hasn't even voted. "I'll be back and vote later." Never happened.
[M] Blueberry - A few people believe that Blueberry thinking Banana's suspicious behavior and not voting for him is suspicious. I don't. But I disagree that defensive = mafia. Obviously, no one wants to die this early in the game unless you are a jester or something which is why most people will defend themselves from getting lynched. :p
[M] Pomegranate - Full of sweet succulent juices.
[M] Plum - In reference to Strawberry Plum responded with this little gem:Really now? :greenie:Quote:
So sweet yet so evil.
[M] Mango - Sporadic behavior. Posts nonsensical things and then switches to actually being helpful. What is suspicious is that most of the more conducive posting came after Peach and Plum went on the attack.
Kiwi, Cherry, Watermelon, Green Apple, Lime, Lemon, and Grape coming up.
Grape - "Voting for inactives is stupid" Yet, some how voting off a random player is better. They voted for Strawberry by the way who is confirmed town.
Cherry - Voted for Banana because they saw nothing wrong with Watermelon or Red Apple. Banana is confirmed town. Make of this what you will.
Kiwi - Initially believed that Blueberry that Blueberry was probably not mafia, but then Day 2 rolls around with Lime and Kiwi is singing a new tune. Kiwi jumps on board with Lime and votes off Blueberry citing that Blueberry knew Banana was innocent and that's why they wouldn't vote them and voted for someone they knew wouldn't get killed so they wouldn't look bad. I think that's what Kiwi was trying to say.
More coming soon if I can.
Watermelon - Text book suspicious behavior. Lurking the shadows while town kills each other off. Only coming out and contributing when called out. Has still failed to contribute anything other then "I AM NOT MAFIA".
Lime - While Lime has some logic some of the points don't make sense. Like his belief that we shouldn't be lynching inactives because they can't tell us anything if they're dead. News flash, they don't tell us anything anyway because they are inactive. Either way inactives are not helpful to town.
Who do I have left? I think Green Apple and Lemon.
Lemon - Hasn't really posted anything suspicious to me, but then again they haven't really posting anything helpful either. One could say they post just enough to slide through the cracks, but I don't think so yet.
wow alot can happen while your out hmm so far peach's thesis has stuck out the most to me I think I will start taking notes as I read people statements and probably follow up in the general pomegranate format, keep it up guys I like how your interpretting things
That's pretty much my logic (or illogic take your pic)Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Pomegranate
I believe both of those posts are from day 1, before I had any theory or clue to be honest right and I believe there was a "##:vote noisy banana" that also happened on day 1, now I'm still mulling over things in my head, i'm not completely convinced blueberry is trecherous, but seems to be an alter boy to this point in the game, it just makes me suspicious and since I haven't been brought to believe anyone else to be mafia I went with my gut feeling. It is also my guess that the other 2 living people who voted for banana aren't mafia, why get your hands dirty in the daytime when you can use the fear of the mass to do it for you, it also keeps you away from the fingers that get pointed at people who did lynch the man. I also figured I would be sleeping when the original 12 hour period lapsed so I made myself counted.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Peach
I actually find Kiwi the most suspicious.
Solid logic, right? Nah, but it's okay because this is Day 1.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Kiwi
So then you say that you reasonably support the logic that you used in your Day 1 randomness post?Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Kiwi
This trend, Kiwi's empty logic, has been consistent up until now. I'm not saying that it's a definite scum move, but I think there's some weight in it. We'll see what happens with Kiwi in the future.
by all means peach if you know who it is do share but I doubt your vote will be more based in logic than mine.. not on day 2 that is
Oh it turns out I missed this post. Pear did come back and vote, but I don't understand the reason behind it.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Pear
Inciting premature voting in the first few hours of Day 1.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Green AppleQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Blueberry
Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Green Apple
There was also no Red Apple at that point, but you didn't mention him. ;)Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Green Apple
It is clear that Green Apple has it out for Blueberry. Most of his posts direct to that. If Blueberry is lynched today it could reveal the reasoning behind that, but I'm not yet convinced that Blueberry is the larger threat. With that said
##Unvote: Watermelon
##Vote: Green Apple
Okay I'm done. :greenie:
Hey, sorry I haven't been on much. I've been pretty busy. I see you guys have been busy too.
I read over 100 posts of pure craziness. I lost my train of thought when reading Mango's posts, which made me wonder if that was his/her reasoning for making them, but then I saw they were trying to prove a point with (most of) them. I see your point dude but I think you went a little overboard with it. And it's not that surprising that, who was it Plum, voted for you. You're acting pretty suspicious.
Thinking over Green Apple's post from way earlier, I was starting to think Blueberry could be a rotten fruit but they haven't posted much for me to commit to a vote for them. Oh, and Lime, I mentioned Orange earlier because Blueberry voted for them and I was speculating that Green Apple could be pointing the finger at Blueberry to keep them away from Orange, but I realize now that was foolish of me because, as far as I can remember, Orange only had that one vote.
The one person that caught my eye was Watermelon coming out after they got another vote to defend him/herself. I admit, again, my first vote for you was a joke and if I had been around to see the later things Banana was saying I probably would have changed my vote to him, but I noticed you hadn't posted for quite a while and only came out when you were one vote closer to being lynched.
##vote: Watermelon
Blueberry - (3) Green Apple, Kiwi, Lime
Green Apple - (1) Pomegranate
Orange - (1) Watermelon
Peach - (1) Mango
Watermelon - (2) Cherry, Red Apple
Mango (1) - Plum
1 and a half hours left.
*sigh* just went through the trouble of tracking down all the votes to see where we stood then I got back to front page and fruit basket beat me to it.. poo. Where is blue berry? they should at least be heard on the day of their possible execution
watermelon it's probably a good time for you to make a statement as well, you might not get another shot
I had justified my reasons for why I thought Blueberry was suspicious earlier in the day, I just didn't feel the need to repeat it. To call it 'hit and run' voting either shows that you didn't see that, or that you have some sort of an agenda to establish against me.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Plum
The strength with which Watermelon is taking his defensive stance, however, is off the back of Cherry's random picking of him as a mafia. Their reasoning was that voting for inactives is "classic mafia voting", but there's been no solid reason as to why Watermelon and not anyone else that voted for an inactive (yes, even me, to begin with). I believe Cherry may be playing it all up to make Watermelon look more suspicious than he actually is. This smells of mafia to me as well, but not enough...Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Pomegranate
Twas a joke. Day 1, remember.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] PomegranateInciting premature voting in the first few hours of Day 1.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Green AppleQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Blueberry
Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Green Apple
Red Apple had posted in the discussion and sign up thread, which indicated to me that he was active, and probably not posting in the main thread to avoid all the jibber-jabber of Day 1 and only join in when the business end came up. Only ever so slightly suspicious in my books, but not as suspicious as someone who signs up to play the game and then isn't around at all after that.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] PomegranateThere was also no Red Apple at that point, but you didn't mention him. ;)Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Green Apple
It is clear that Green Apple has it out for Blueberry. Most of his posts direct to that. If Blueberry is lynched today it could reveal the reasoning behind that, but I'm not yet convinced that Blueberry is the larger threat. With that said
##Unvote: Watermelon
##Vote: Green Apple
Okay I'm done. :greenie:
I could go on, but I don't need to defend myself as to why I think Blueberry is suspicious. It's been well-documented in previous posts. I don't know how it could be misinterpreted by you as some sort of unfounded witch hunt.
Oh dear shiny Green Apple I'd like to point out my vote for Watermelon isn't quite as random as you make it out too be.
As I said earlier I voted for him as 1 out of 3 suspects of inactive player voters. Since then Watermelon has exhibited strange behavior lurking & not offering up anything that helps the town weed out the mafia. His denial of being scum hasn't been at all convincing either, the evidence is in the thread. My day 2 vote is staying with Watermelon!
Mhm, exactly. I was thinking the exact same thing on Day 1.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Kiwi
I wouldn't expect you change your vote to yourself!Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Cherry
But your point is exactly why I felt the need to say "not enough.."
Keep on your toes. Don't leave town. etc. etc.
:D
Leave town my shiny Granny Smith looking darling? Why would I do that? Nice too see someone keeping me on my toes;)
Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Cherry
Quite the change of mine. Your reason for voting for Banana was completely bogus. Either you don't understand how this game works very well and cannot comprehend that being an attention whore day 1 is suicide for mafia, or you just went after Peach's vote to get rid of an easy target on the town side.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Cherry
Watermelon tends to do that.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] CherryOn the defensive immediately, thats what I like too see!Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Watermelon
Why did I pick you over the other 2 who exhibited this voting pattern? Well is closing my eyes & picking one at random a good enough reason;)
No it isn't actually.
Could I be guilty of the Day 1 madness bug I refused too accept Watermelon was guilty of? Maybe my Pomegranate friend;) But given how often you seem to change your mind (hits play on Hot N Cold by Katy Perry on iTunes for effect) who really knows?
Just to keep one thing in mind, no death is inconsequential in this game. Strawberry could have been killed off for numerous reasons, but all of them point to the benefit of the player that targeted her. One theory to consider is that Strawberry was killed to make the people that voted off Banana look better. Strawberry was revealed town so people may think "oh well then Peach and Cherry could be town too then". If that's what you're thinking, don't. Banana was still confirmed innocent and Peach's vote for Banana for being noisy is still bogus.
My mind hasn't changed. I still think Watermelon and Green Apple are suspicious and so are you. ;)
If being fabulous is suspicious then guilty as charged ;)Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Pomegranate
Vote Count
[M] Blueberry (3) - [M] Kiwi, [M] Lime, [M] Green Apple
[M] Watermelon (2) - [M] Cherry,[M] Pomegranate, [M] Red Apple
[M] Orange (1) - [M] Watermelon
[M] Green Apple (1) -[M] Pomegranate, [M] Pomegranate
[M] Peach (1) - [M] Mango
[M] Mango (1) - [M] Plum
[M] Plum (0) -[M] Grape
13 minutes remaining.
Wow, I still have time to vote~
Sorry was busy shopping all day~
As to save my own skin and throw us into a tie, I'll vote for Watermelon, nothing personal, but it is the quickest solution I have at the moment~
##Vote: [M] Watermelon
EDIT: Watermelon, it is nothing personal but 13 minutes is not enough time for me to read all these pages and come up with anything, so it is a stall tactic~
Don't ever change, Cherry. :aimkiss:Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] CherryIf being fabulous is suspicious then guilty as charged ;)Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Pomegranate
Oh, that looks like three for the both of us huh, Blueberry? Guess I'll have to save myself then.
##Unvote: Orange
##Vote: Blueberry
Don't worry doll I won't;)Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] WatermelonDon't ever change, Cherry. :aimkiss:Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] CherryIf being fabulous is suspicious then guilty as charged ;)Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Pomegranate
Nice of you to join the party pretty Blueberry;)
Ouch~ Oh well, been fun while it lasted. Thanks for all the fish~
<3~
It's relevant because not even the mafia would know it.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Mango
How can you say this. Everyone does something suspicious, town or not.Quote:
The fact is he was the doctor, so no matter how suspicious any of his actions may have seemed, they weren't, because he wasn't a mafia.
Because townies accusing other townies doesn't happen.Quote:
Therefore the suspicion then falls on those who rounded on someone who eventually turned out to be a Townie and rallied around those accusing him of being mafia.
DAY OVER PLS! Final Votecount and flavour coming momentarily!
You're missing the point completely. It doesn't matter if whatever he was doing looked suspicious or not, it wasnt because he was not mafia. In fact, he was one of the Townies most important players. Whether the mafia knew he was a doctor or not makes absolutely no difference, they would have known he was a Townie and he was leaving himself open to be gotten rid of easily, it's a simple choice to make.Quote:
It's relevant because not even the mafia would know it.
How can you say this. Everyone does something suspicious, town or not.
Because townies accusing other townies doesn't happen.
Final Vote Count
[M] Blueberry (4) - [M] Kiwi, [M] Lime, [M] Green Apple, [M] Watermelon
[M] Watermelon (3) - [M] Cherry,[M] Pomegranate, [M] Red Apple, [M] Blueberry
[M] Green Apple (1) -[M] Pomegranate, [M] Pomegranate
[M] Peach (1) - [M] Mango
[M] Mango (1) - [M] Plum
[M] Plum (0) -[M] Grape
[M] Orange (0) -[M] Watermelon
[M] Blueberry was running out of time. I have to vote for [M] Watermelon to keep myself alive! But [M] Watermelon was not so happy about this.
"Smurf you buddy, I'mma vote for you now! Gotta save myself!"
As the timer ticked over, [M] Blueberry realised he had just lost!
"I have some final words before I go," he said. "I'm juicy~~"
With that, he burst open and his sweet sweet juices fed the earth. They also stained the clothes of the other fruit standing around, which caused huge lines at the Laundromat the next day.
[M] Blueberry was a Mafia Goon played by The Summoner of Leviathan~ Thanks for playing!
Night actions please!
Pomegranate was taking a stroll through the park, thinking about the death of Strawberry.
Strawberry and I were close, like all medical professionals get with their patients I suppose. But even more so in our cause.
As Pomegranate sat down on a park bench, she saw ducks gathered around the edge of the pond.
Ignoring the fact that the ducks should've been elsewhere at night, she sighed, thinking about how Strawberry loved ducks...
She started coughing. Pomegranate had swallowed a bullet. She collapsed on the park bench, and it wasn't until the park security tried to remove her that they found out she was dead :(
[M] Pomegranate was a Gynecologist played by Shiny! Thanks for playing :jess:
Day Three starts now and will continue for 24 hours!
:eek:
Damn.
So shall we squabble over what the point of that role was, or something else today?
xD
Personally I'd like to complain about someone opening the thread just before I go to bed *shakes fist*
I'll throw out some thoughts in my next post and then hit the hay, unless someone wants to respond and keep me up of course.
i'm fairly certain of what a gynecologist does, i'm just curious as to if she could cure aids
I've had a quick trawl through of those that seem odd to me, but the only think I've picked up on as a little is Cherry's earlier comment:
This is not what I was saying!Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Cherry
I was saying that it's ridiculous to base your voting off people who voted for inactives, sure you could say it's a mafia tactic, but both town (Strawb for example) and mafia (Blueberry) do it, especially on day one.
I can understand why you think those people could be sus, but I'm not sure how you could logically conclude that the other three were suspicious because Strawberry died, please explain how that makes sense xD
Hmmm, it appears there's nothing else jumping out at me tonight, so I'm going to sleep now and be back on tomorrow at work if I can xD
Okay, I suppose the first and simplest assumption we can all begin to work with is that since Watermelon had his head on the chopping block, and only his changed vote saw Blueberry ousted, it wouldn't be out of line to therefore assume that there is at least one other mafia in the ranks of those who voted for Watermelon.
Off the back of what I was seeing in Day 2 proceedings, I think Cherry has the most to answer for. The vote for Watermelon by Cherry was laid on fairly shaky grounds;
That vote could've gone to anyone of the three, so why Watermelon?Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Cherry
My thinking is that Watermelon's defense of his vote for an inactive in Day 1 provided an opening to the mafia to begin targeting him and buttering all of us up to believe that Watermelon was acting suspiciously. They wanted us to think that posting in defense of your own actions was suspicious activity. It would've worked too, had all the pre-existing doubt over Blueberry not existed and Watermelon's vote change not come in.Quote:
Originally Posted by Cherry
You may think that if Cherry was really going to put Watermelon in the spotlight, it'd be with words stronger than "is closing my eyes & picking one at random a good enough reason?" but this is how the mafia play their game. They try not to get too involved in the actual to-ing and fro-ing, but stand back and throw light punches until other people begin to believe their lies. Not only that, but when Cherry said this, Fruit Basket had just come in, moments before, announcing an extension of the day by 12 hours. Hmm.
Peach had this to say about it when Watermelon posed the question to Cherry "why me?";
Exactly. Not getting involved, but yet managing to garner 3 votes against Watermelon (one of which is confirmed mafia). Almost enough to have finished him off.Quote:
Originally Posted by PeachThis is what I'm talking about! This isn't helping at all, Cherry. You're being patronizing and just arguing, not discussing. If Watermelon isn't Mafia, then you're condemning an innocent man.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Cherry
How would Cherry know what time zone Blueberry is in? It's not hard evidence by any means, so why does Cherry exonerate Blueberry of suspicion so quickly? Obviously because they're one and same.Quote:
Originally Posted by Cherry
It's early, I know. But frankly, I think I've seen enough.
##Vote: Cherry
Thank you for finding more stuff on Cherry there, Mr. Smith, you've given me motivation to look further.
I didn't find much, but I noticed another little thing that was a bit off:
Attacking Watermelon for not trying to stop the death of Strawberry and Banana. What could Watermelon do to stop the death of Strawberry? xDQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] CherryYeah but you didn't try to stop either now did you? As I've seen from previous games it's those who distance themselves most when the town messes up that are scum. Your just picking a spot on the compost heap right now darlingQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Watermelon
With that said (but mainly what I said in my last post), I'm gonna throw a vote on you, it's not permanent by any means, I just want you to take this seriously and answer my questions :D
##Vote: Cherry
I should be able to get on at work tomorrow, see what's happening and reevaluate my vote.
day 1 voting results obselets have been striken
Final Vote Count
[M] Banana (3) - [M] Peach, [M] Cherry, [M] Strawberry
[M] Watermelon (2) - [M] Plum, [M] Red Apple
[M] Red Apple (2) - [M] Watermelon, [M] Banana
[M] Strawberry (2) - [M] Grape, [M] Mango
[M] Blueberry (2) - [M] Lime, [M] Green Apple
[M] Raspberry (1) - [M] Pear
[M] Mango (1) - [M] Kiwi, [strike][M]Strawberry[/strike]
[M] Orange (1) - [M] Blueberry
[M] Grape (0) - [M] [strike]Banana[/strike]
[M] Cherry (0) - [M] [strike]Green Apple[/strike]
[M] Kiwi (0) - [M][strike] Mango[/strike]
day 2 voting results
Final Vote Count
[M] Blueberry (4) - [M] Kiwi, [M] Lime, [M] Green Apple, [M] Watermelon
[M] Watermelon (3) - [M] Cherry, [strike][M] Pomegranate[/strike], [M] Red Apple, [M] Blueberry
[M] Green Apple (1) - [strike][M] Pomegranate[/strike], [M] Pomegranate
[M] Peach (1) - [M] Mango
[M] Mango (1) - [M] Plum
[M] Plum (0) - [M] [strike]Grape[/strike]
[M] Orange (0) - [M] [strike]Watermelon[/strike]
day 1 voting
[b][M] Blueberry (2) - [M] Lime, [M] Green Apple
[M] Banana (3) - [M] Peach, [M] Cherry, [M] Strawberry[b]
i have boldened what I would like to bring your attention to as it may or may not hold
any value at all.
-peach
-cherry
both not a fraid to get there hands dirty, alot of suspicioun is drawn to people who
have innocent people killed, especially early in the game. Later when you have some
convoluted judgement basis it's easy to pass it off as "someone is acting suspicious"
It is my initial assesment these 2 individuals are not mafia
-Lime
-Green apple
2 people found blueberries statements suspicious from day one, or were they just not
sure whom to vote on? having fingered a mafia from day one these two are very unlikely
to be mafia themselves, or perhaps one of them is and figured this assessment would be
coming? I'm hoping the evil mastermind hadn't come out yet in day 1 so I'm putting my
seal of "unlikely" who votes on a teamate from the get go? not a very good one.
I also had strawberry as an unlikely but that is of little concern now.
Side bar of slightly suspicious [m]strawberry was killed slightly after they changed
their vote from [m]mango perhaps it was so they wouldn't come back once banana was dead?
or merely coincidense? you decided
Now I would be more willing to rule [m] orange out of being mafia, if he had at least one
more vote, who votes on teamates right? but since blue was his only vote he remains
somewhat suspicious (allow me to eleborate further because after reading this I'm not sure
I made my point) if [m] orange were mafia and already had one vote, I don't believe [m]blueberry
would have voted on them, since there were no other votes this goes as undecided)
day 2 voting
-watermelon
I cannot determine anything based on your vote because you did it out of a strong sense
of self preservations, mafia or not your vote tells me nothing, well accept that you
voted on the same guy blueberry did last round, who still only has one vote.. mildly suspicious
unrelated to voting
-lemon
-pear
[strike]-ras[/strike] (he has been more active since I wrote this originally)
these three get the not very active award, it comes with mild suspicion
List of Players
[M] Red Apple -
[M] Orange - cranky about inactives, got one vote 2 rounds in a row
[M] Green Apple - unlikely, fingered mafia
[M] Lemon - becoming much more suspicious for not voting 2 rounds in a row.. kind of looks too inocent
[M] Lime - unlikely, fingered mafia
[M] Grape -
[M] Peach - deductive logic or mafia-mastermind? tbd
[M] Watermelon - very verbose, unlikely to live much longer extremely defensive, lurker?
[M] Cherry -
[M] Raspberry -
[M] Banana - Doctor Slipped on a human peel Day One
[M] Pear - ??? what do we know about pear? nothing at all, very suspicious
[M] Blueberry - mafia, tried to hide amongst the sheep and innocents
[M] Strawberry - Town Furry Night killed Night One
[M] Pomegranate - poor pom, had him as mildly suspicious for swing voting
[M] Kiwi -
[M] Plum - heated debates with mango, lets temper take over more to come...
[M] Mango - kind of annoying, suicidal towny trying to get lynched? or hiding in as much
attention as possible? I'm leaning towards suicidal towny
Now I've taken a little time to break down one of the longer posts by [m]peach it is very interesting indeed
Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Peach
Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Peach
Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Green Apple
mr peach you seem very intelligent, possibly enough so that you could be talking about yourself with full confidence your mind games go unnoticed, i'm not fingering you as mafia but I do have my eyes on you as you go from not suspicious category, to the somewhat category. Not being intelligent is not a crime in the least, it is the most valuable thing we have in this game, keep it up with your assesments I look forward to reading more
lol
you said fingering.
note that is me using green apples statement to blueberry as a refference to peach's comment, not green apple saying that about peach
if our lives realy on this... we're screwed:freak:Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Plum
I find the concept of digital penetration highly amusing. Highly amusing.
[M] Cherry (2) - [M] Raspberry, [M] Green Apple
21 1/2 hours left.
Just a little perspective at the time of cherries initial vote the vote count wasQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Green Apple
blueberry (1)
plum (1)
it is true that 2 other people had voted for her the previous round, so cherry could have concluded there would be a total of 3 this round, but i'm not convinced cherry was thinking this far ahead
that first her I mean blueberry
aww crap I cut the quote off too early... are you sure there is no editing posts?
Just a little perspective at the time of cherries initial vote the vote count wasQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Green Apple
blueberry (1)
plum (1)
it is true that 2 other people had voted for blueberry the previous round, so cherry could have concluded there would be a total of 3 this round, but i'm not convinced cherry was thinking this far ahead
Kiwiiiiiiii, oooooooooooooooh. I don't wanna die. Sometimes wish I'd never been born at all!Quote:
[M] Mango - kind of annoying, suicidal towny trying to get lynched? or hiding in as much
attention as possible? I'm leaning towards suicidal towny
##vote: Peach
For the reasons stated yesterday. You can carry on ignoring me and I can carry on voting for you. Come on. It'll be fun! One day the rest of the town will wake up to what a horrible monster you are.
Still not entirely convinced of Watermelon's innocence. Consider the idea that both he and Blueberry were mafia. They were both in trouble, so it would make sense for a mafia in that position (perhaps one with an ability like Godfather, roleblocker, whatever) to sell the goon down the river to save themselves and make themselves look good.
Also something about raspberry's posts today are setting off warning bells in my head.
Tries the ol' hit-and-run tactic. "I'm going to bed/work/a Hannah Montana Concert" and repeatedly says this over the course of an hour. That one always makes me wonder. I know sometimes people say it and mean it, but it is also often used by mafia as an excuse not to post. Anyway, our berry puts out some feelers on Cherry, and then when Green Apple votes for him, Rapsberry (who still hasn't gone to sleep like he insisted he was about to!) immediately shows up to weigh in with a vote of his own.
I went back through and looked through posts from and concerning Blueberry and Pomegranate from Day 2. I haven't read Day 3 yet.
Green Apple did give a reason for voting Blueberry; they agreed with my thoughts on Blueberry. Plum, you appear to jump to the defense of Blueberry after they amass 3 votes pretty adamantly and then ice the cake by accusing Green Apple of voting for them without reason. I'll also point out that Pomegranate was also faily defensive of Blueberry so perhaps this isn't that weird. However, it makes it more probable that you have a reason for the defense since Pomegranate obviously didn't.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] PlumWhat a nice coincidence! 'I agree with you, this person is fishy because I feel so and you said so, everybody else is just as fishy, vote and bye.'Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Green AppleI agree to this. Even when I dismiss all the first day banter as..well.. first day banter, I'm still thinking Blueberry is fishy.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Kiwi
That's not to say you other fruits haven't been getting the sniff.
##Vote: Blueberry
I AM SERIOUSLY GOING TO BED NOW.
First off your hit and run vote puts Blueberry up to three votes, which would not be questionable if you had actually given a justifiable reason you had thought up, or at least an extension on the aforementioned reason. The good old 'I have to go now' tops it off really.
You're right about the Blueberry jumping on Banana thing but what made him stand out to me was that he pointed at Banana to get the focus there, then voted for someone else in what appeared to me as a confusion tactic. It just didn't make sense. I'm bringing this up because you, also, put up a semi-defense for Blueberry and sort of pointed out the, "Eh, maybe... maybe not," possibility. Everyone is a Maybe/Maybe Not. No real point in saying that.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Peach
The people close to being lynched on Day 1 were Blueberry, Red Apple, Strawberry, and Watermelon (excluding Banana). At this point, I disagree with what Pomegranate said since lynching to get more information is a risky business without people claiming and accusations flying. Either way, going by Pomegranate's logic, Blueberry flipped Mafia so I'd think that he was the missing link Pomegranate was looking for.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Pomegranate
I'll have to put you in the same boat as Peach and Plum for putting up albeit a small defense for Blueberry.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Red Apple
Looking at the votes for Day 1, I also see something beneficial for you and Watermelon, however. You both were on the "chopping block" and voted for each other. If either of you were baddies, it would've been very easy for either of you to switch and make things look much safer for one of you. Also, having more than one bad guy close to dying that early seems unlikely (referring to Blueberry being the other close one) and it would have spurred a change in votes from one of you, I would think. But you both stuck it out and I think that takes balls.
Okay, reading onto Day 3 now.
Cherry.
Right. Exactly why would a Mafia be making noise? Seems like a bizarre reason to vote.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Cherry
Blueberry votes for Watermelon to save his Mafia skin.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Blueberry
However for the duration of day two Cherry is trying to take Watermelon down on the basis that 'he was inactive and acted strangely.' I only picked one quote out but it seems to me like cherry tried to set Watermelon up for the lynch on day two to possibly save his Mafia buddy. There needed to be somebody to match Blueberry's votes so why not a player who you don't need a long winded reason to vote for?Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Cherry
[M] Cherry (2) - [M] Raspberry, [M] Green Apple
[M] Kiwi (1) - [M] Mango
17 1/2 hours left.
I didn't vote for Kiwi. ;)
I agree with your train of thought but I don't think using an 'almost lynched' player for that would be the most productive. However, going back to Banana, that line of thought would refer to Cherry and Peach since they both voted for him (excluding Strawberry since she was Town). I think it's likely that one of them is a bad guy for this reason.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Green Apple
I'm going to agree again. It sounds like the same thing Blueberry did on Day 1 with the, "Hey, I don't like this guy but I'm not going to commit to anything serious."Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Green ApplePeach had this to say about it when Watermelon posed the question to Cherry "why me?";
Exactly. Not getting involved, but yet managing to garner 3 votes against Watermelon (one of which is confirmed mafia). Almost enough to have finished him off.Quote:
Originally Posted by PeachThis is what I'm talking about! This isn't helping at all, Cherry. You're being patronizing and just arguing, not discussing. If Watermelon isn't Mafia, then you're condemning an innocent man.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Cherry
No vote on Day 2 from Grape, Lemon, Orange, Peach, Pear, and Raspberry. WTF guys. Way too many people not doing anything. Jump in here and get crunk already.
I don't like Peach or Cherry. I'll vote for Peach to keep the count even for now.
## Vote: Peach
Votecount up to now:
Cherry - (2) Green Apple, Raspberry
Peach - (2) Lime, Mango
Pretty sure Mango voted for Peach, not Kiwi, Fruit Basket.
Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Fruit Basket
Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Mango
damn, fruit baskets got it in for me
You're missing my point. It does matter if Banana was doing things that others found suspicious, and they don't stop suspicious just because he was town-aligned.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Mango
Ugh, sorry, everyone. I just haven't been too arsed about Mafia when Doom 2 is out on XBLA now :exdee:
Perhaps I'm just a bit braindead at the moment, but could I get you (or someone else) to clarify why it's not a productive train of thought? Blueberry is proven mafia, so unless there's a mafia-voting-for-each-other-to-trick-town ploy in the mix, it logically follows that the next person up was the intended prey for the day.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] LimeI agree with your train of thought but I don't think using an 'almost lynched' player for that would be the most productive. However, going back to Banana, that line of thought would refer to Cherry and Peach since they both voted for him (excluding Strawberry since she was Town). I think it's likely that one of them is a bad guy for this reason.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Green Apple
In any case, we appear to have reach the same destination with our theories via different proofs (me; exploitation of Watermelon, you; the Banana gangbang), so I suppose the evidence is all adding up against Cherry (and Peach)!
[M] Cherry (2) - [M] Raspberry, [M] Green Apple
[M] Peach (2) - [M] Mango, [M] Lime
14 1/2 hours left.
I can't believe that you'd do this to me, Lime! We were buddies! I saved your ass in the war, and now look how you repay me. I can't believe that you'd betray me like this.
on another note lets talk about dead people xD
yes xDQuote:
Originally Posted by Strawbooble
there is no cure for aids if you touch an aid you die duh xDQuote:
Originally Posted by Kiwi
a gynecologist can choose one person each night their openings are sewn shut so that they cant talk and say annoying stuff anymore too bad she didnt get mango right xD
i think that mango is a scum because mangos are typing songs and linking those to and thats a bad thing or maybe not because i have a maybe maybe not in my brane head duh xD
everyone listen to mango and lime because they know all the stuff on there xD
##vote: Lime
##daykill: mango
you are a noisy mango xD
well now you are a silent mango
woo its peaceful in here xD
xE
x3
xT
xI
xO
xP
many x face
Woah there, Peach. Chill.
Mango. Oh lawd, you know just how to make me laugh. :aimkiss:
My initial instinct on Mango is: Town. Maybe even a cop, perhaps, since he's asking us to look at Peach. I realize he gave no founding reasons, but that just reaffirms my thoughts, because what real reason can a cop give besides "trust me" without giving things away?
Peach, care to claim your role by any chance? It looks a little suspicious the way you're badgering Mango and now trying to day kill him?
i need a clean-up on page thirteen xD
mangos not a cop because i know who the cop is and its not mango mango is a scum trust me
stop sucking upQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Pear
also call me peachy from now on
I'm not a Strawbooble :cry:Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Peach
also mango is not a normal goon
haha um, no. I have no founded reason to trust you, peach. I hated you in Mario Party and I hate you now :nonono:
That being said, what reason would you give me to trust you? And how do you know who the cop is?
cry so goodQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] RaspberryI'm not a Strawbooble :cry:Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Peach
okay dont trust me but i am serious i know who the cop is
i also know one of the mafia
also mario kart is old throw it away there are new games more than that
i have to have a pear do you
also we already have that we know who got on the wagon on day one~
We probably don't have any more protective roles (assuming that the Gynecologist could potentially have Doctor powers?), so won't all this pointing fingers at, and trying to discover the cops potentially get them killed?
Also, where are Cherry and Grape, I've asked both of them questions and had none answered!
alcohol badsQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Lime
why i didnt see it now!!!Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] LimeThis was in response to something Blueberry said. And I agree.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Green Apple
In summary, "I hate you, you suck, but I'm not voting for you because oh look over here." Start attacking a fruit then back off and let everyone else actually kill them off, yeah? I don't like it.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Blueberry
Word. Inactives blow all kinds of butt in every way. Lynching them tells us nothing if they don't tell us what they think, especially when it's this early in the game. If you're inactive and unhelpful, then fooey on you.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Banana
Anyway, Blueberry, I pick you.
## Vote: Blueberry
again i should see it but im blind to your tricks!!!Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] LimeI don't really understand your allusion to Orange. Why'd you bring up Orange? And you're saying Green Apple could be doing X but you're not sure if you believe it. "It could be what's going on... but just in case it isn't, I'm just throwing that in there so I have something to fall back on," yeah? xDQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Red Apple
Yeah, sorry if that came across as me pointing specifically to Green Apple's quote about what Mafia would say. I was simply using that as a lead-in to my reasoning about Blueberry. xDQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] PomegranateThat was clearly a joke on Green Apple's part. Green Apple even stated as such. No one in their right mind would fling around that amount of poo posts on day 1 and actually be serious unless of course they intend for the poo to stick like you seem to be intending.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] LimeThis was in response to something Blueberry said. And I agree.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Green Apple
Not sure I follow what you're trying to say. You make it seem like you disagree with my reasoning but then go on to say that Mafia would draw attention to Banana without voting for him which is exactly what I was saying about Blueberry.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] PomegranateVarious other people in this thread have said that Banana was posting defensive, but that it was not actually a dead ringer for being mafia. One of those people was Strawberry. That's why she, myself, Blueberry, and others did not vote for Banana. If anything a mafia would either vote for Banana or simply say "WOW WHAT YOU'RE DOING IS REALLY WEIRD BANANA EVERYONE LOOK AT HOW BAD AND WEIRD BANANA IS" not "you make equally valid points" and "let's just ignore that".Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] LimeIn summary, "I hate you, you suck, but I'm not voting for you because oh look over here." Start attacking a fruit then back off and let everyone else actually kill them off, yeah? I don't like it.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Blueberry
My exact thoughts from Day 1. And I still hold to them.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Kiwi
I just... argh. You just did almost the same thing Blueberry did yesterday. "Hey, I'll talk about this and then oh wait here's my unrelated vote, bye." Just saying.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Grape
I'm sticking with my Blueberry vote from yesterday. But now I suspect Red Apple and Grape for the same stuff.
## Vote: Blueberry
Also, 12 hours for this day?! Holy crap, I just barely got on here in time to even read the thread and post replies and a vote. Seems like it's cutting it really short, in my opinion. Need more talking from a lot people. : (
you are not poetic i dont even like your writingQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Lime
everyone make you look dumb even youQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Lime
hi lime i see you nowQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Lime
small talk is smallQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] LimeYeah, I misread what you typed. I was thinking you saying, "While I am not 100% Blueberry is innocent..." was meaning that you thought he was a bad guy. My bad.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] PomegranateWhere out of anything that I've said did you see me say that I'm leaning towards Blueberry being a bad guy? I said I'm not 100% sure he's innocent. That does not mean I think he's a bad guy. Since it's only Day 2 I have very little evidence that anyone alive is 100% good or bad. The only 100% I have is for myself and the characters who have been sent to the farplane. I explain why I don't agree with you in the long post that took me forever to do. Check it out.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] LimeI don't understand what you're saying. You're leaning toward Blueberry being a bad guy but you don't agree with me? Why not?Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Pomegranate
We have no evidence that anyone is 100% anything until they die. I agree, that's just the way the game of Mafia goes.
this where i finally see youQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] LimeI went back through and looked through posts from and concerning Blueberry and Pomegranate from Day 2. I haven't read Day 3 yet.
Green Apple did give a reason for voting Blueberry; they agreed with my thoughts on Blueberry. Plum, you appear to jump to the defense of Blueberry after they amass 3 votes pretty adamantly and then ice the cake by accusing Green Apple of voting for them without reason. I'll also point out that Pomegranate was also faily defensive of Blueberry so perhaps this isn't that weird. However, it makes it more probable that you have a reason for the defense since Pomegranate obviously didn't.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] PlumWhat a nice coincidence! 'I agree with you, this person is fishy because I feel so and you said so, everybody else is just as fishy, vote and bye.'Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Green AppleI agree to this. Even when I dismiss all the first day banter as..well.. first day banter, I'm still thinking Blueberry is fishy.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Kiwi
That's not to say you other fruits haven't been getting the sniff.
##Vote: Blueberry
I AM SERIOUSLY GOING TO BED NOW.
First off your hit and run vote puts Blueberry up to three votes, which would not be questionable if you had actually given a justifiable reason you had thought up, or at least an extension on the aforementioned reason. The good old 'I have to go now' tops it off really.
You're right about the Blueberry jumping on Banana thing but what made him stand out to me was that he pointed at Banana to get the focus there, then voted for someone else in what appeared to me as a confusion tactic. It just didn't make sense. I'm bringing this up because you, also, put up a semi-defense for Blueberry and sort of pointed out the, "Eh, maybe... maybe not," possibility. Everyone is a Maybe/Maybe Not. No real point in saying that.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Peach
The people close to being lynched on Day 1 were Blueberry, Red Apple, Strawberry, and Watermelon (excluding Banana). At this point, I disagree with what Pomegranate said since lynching to get more information is a risky business without people claiming and accusations flying. Either way, going by Pomegranate's logic, Blueberry flipped Mafia so I'd think that he was the missing link Pomegranate was looking for.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Pomegranate
I'll have to put you in the same boat as Peach and Plum for putting up albeit a small defense for Blueberry.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Red Apple
Looking at the votes for Day 1, I also see something beneficial for you and Watermelon, however. You both were on the "chopping block" and voted for each other. If either of you were baddies, it would've been very easy for either of you to switch and make things look much safer for one of you. Also, having more than one bad guy close to dying that early seems unlikely (referring to Blueberry being the other close one) and it would have spurred a change in votes from one of you, I would think. But you both stuck it out and I think that takes balls.
Okay, reading onto Day 3 now.
you did it the hard way there was a easy oneQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] LimeI agree with your train of thought but I don't think using an 'almost lynched' player for that would be the most productive. However, going back to Banana, that line of thought would refer to Cherry and Peach since they both voted for him (excluding Strawberry since she was Town). I think it's likely that one of them is a bad guy for this reason.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Green Apple
I'm going to agree again. It sounds like the same thing Blueberry did on Day 1 with the, "Hey, I don't like this guy but I'm not going to commit to anything serious."Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Green ApplePeach had this to say about it when Watermelon posed the question to Cherry "why me?";
Exactly. Not getting involved, but yet managing to garner 3 votes against Watermelon (one of which is confirmed mafia). Almost enough to have finished him off.Quote:
Originally Posted by PeachThis is what I'm talking about! This isn't helping at all, Cherry. You're being patronizing and just arguing, not discussing. If Watermelon isn't Mafia, then you're condemning an innocent man.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Cherry
No vote on Day 2 from Grape, Lemon, Orange, Peach, Pear, and Raspberry. WTF guys. Way too many people not doing anything. Jump in here and get crunk already.
I don't like Peach or Cherry. I'll vote for Peach to keep the count even for now.
## Vote: Peach
Votecount up to now:
Cherry - (2) Green Apple, Raspberry
Peach - (2) Lime, Mango
Pretty sure Mango voted for Peach, not Kiwi, Fruit Basket.
doth say the guilty!!!
the only way for the town to win is to kill the copQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Raspberry
trust me
when the cop die so did the mafia
i eeted them in my salads tomorrow and in wine!!!Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Raspberry
no really i have no so i can went
let me show my worth all of you and say them all!!!
dont tell me i am going to make you win without the betrayerQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Pear
you dont want him on your team its not fun
every one who help out town have to put songs here i go second
You think I'm an ignorant savage
And you've been so many places
I guess it must be so
But still I cannot see
If the savage one is me
Now can there be so much that you don't know?
You don't know ...
where all of them go xD
read this
haha i win
another one for all of you
they say
they say the truth will set you free,
so why am i in chains?
they say
they say the best things come
the best things come to those who wait
who will wait for me?
id lay down my life
fall to my knees
if youd surrender your arms
run into mine
and lay down with me
who knows
who knows what right anymore
i dont wanna fight anymore
ive been fighting for too long
we will find a way
make our own
somewhere far away from here
dont look down
here i come
one day ill find you
and lay down my life
fall to my knees
if youd surrender your arms
run into mine
and lay down with me
if what dont kill you only makes you stronger
why do i still feel the pain
id rather die than have to wait much longer
this kinda living drives a man
it drives a man insane
id lay down my life
fall to my knees
if youd surrender your arms
run into mine
and lay down with me
so surrender your arms
run into mine
and lay down with me
oh no i talkin to mahself
or am i just thinking
its been so long in the dark with no one else that i can hardly tell the difference anymore
also shut up mango i am going to help the town much more than you
yeah im starting stuff with you mango come fight me good
holy crap mango has passed on his... erm psychotic tendencies to peach, but where did mango get them from, or is mango the origin?
this is me guessing there is some sort of additional role of asshole or something like that, and you influence others to be retarded as well perhaps?
25 posts without saying anything, how sad
I go away to have lunch and come back to this xD
mango got them not!
facade!
facade!
then take from this never to go away for lunch
stay here
forever
It just seems like Peach is now trying to get in the way of the town, either to try and get himself killed, or to make it look like he's trying to get himself killed, so he doesn't get killed :\
That doesn't really go anywhere though...
So Peach, what were you trying to say by making that massive string of quotes by Lime?
the scum will win the scum will win~
they sang!!!
the town has won the town has won~
they sang!!!
for has not the town won already indeed it has but the town will win alone no scum to poison these pure waters~
they sang!!!
hey everyone, been busy, sorry. Being a grape is hard work.
I had a question to answer, but I read all of peach's posts and completely lost my train of thought.
well when the game started we all could winQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Raspberry
but now only town may win
and so some of us must lose,
as we knew we must in the beginning
can they're been a lose with a whiner?
not!!!
clean up on page fourteen
as well as every after
and every before
for there is a traitor amongst us!
i been forgot my xDs so here are lots to keep them all company
xD
xD
xD
xD
xD
xD
xD
xD
xD
xD
xD
xD
xD
xD
if you want more ask and answer the riddle
you know the riddle
the riddle that goes
four legs in the morning
two at noon
and three in the evening
dont call it personal because i know its not but when you come back youll see that i made a selfish and ruined all your plansies~
Are you simply describing the way that mafia works, or are you answering my question about Lime and implying that he is scum who is trying to look like town by uprooting another mafia member?
Well that's my absurd inference of your poetic ramblings anyway...