Not me! That's why I asked someone else to do it. ;)
Not me! That's why I asked someone else to do it. ;)
Clever clever! *puts on bulletproof and lynchproof vest as well as mafia detection goggles*
hmm Mafia detection goggles... suspicious >.> lol
Well, at the time that Lui Bei changed his vote to Sun Shang Xiang both he and she were tied with 2 votes each. However Gan Ning had 3 votes at the time (Cao Cao x 2 and Lui Bei). So why did Lui Bei change his vote away from Gan Ning and onto Sun Shang Xiang? This put her with the most votes and saved Gan Ning from the lynch.
You find these suspicious?
http://privateislandparty.com/avacti...RayGoggles.jpg
Of course.
Before anyone grabs this chance, I'm going to put myself on the spot. I'm sure most of you must have noticed that I had removed my vote on the previous day for Liu Bei, who turned out to be a confirmed scum at his lynch. Now, I'm glad no one has questioned it so far, I'm bringing this up so we can start some serious discussion, despite it gunning any suspicion on myself. On my behalf, I want to say that at any time of the day, I really had no idea Liu Bei was scum, nor was I playing along with any scheme he may be scheming if he were doing such a thing with me. Let's see what we can out of this, shall we? :letsgo:
Ma Chao, if you do not want us to think you are guilty of anything, please share your thoughts so far...
Actually, I'm going to take this quick opportunity to comment on suspicious activity by Sima Yi in the latter half of yesterday.
I know Sima highlighted pretty quickly that this would make him look bad, and in a sense I side with him there because killing Lu Bu almost looks like blatant incrimination. But, defending Lie Bei and putting heat on Lu Bu in the same post can't be ignored.
A continuation of this - I'm also sensing a kind of nonchalant nature to this vote. Sima isn't attacking Lu necessarily, but he seems pretty deadset on voting for him. Again, I'm not saying this = Mafia, especially considering Lu was just a relatively ordinary member of town and I don't know why Sima would gun for him.
But this truly gets me suspicious. Soon before Lie Bei is lynched, Sima starts targeting the player with the second most votes! Not only with weak reasoning, but also this inconsequential type of post I keep seeing. There's also arse-covering, "I'm not sure if Sunshine is scum" makes him look okay if she does die and flips town. Nonetheless Sima is, almost passively, trying to shift heat here.
Just food for thought really. Post might be a bit sucky, I have to go quickly.
How can someone Vote for me twice? if I posted twice voting for the same person, wouldn't that kinda be cheating... Curious to say the least.
Coupled with the fact that even if I did have "3 votes" it still would not have been enough to stop Liu Bei from the lynch.
Zhuge Liang gave Cao Cao the pwer of two votes for day 1 that is why you had two votes against you from one person. Also, up until Lui Bei unvoted you and voted for Sun Shang Xiang the majority vote was on you. It wasn't until after this event did other townies show up to vote Lui Bei for the lynch.
(SPOILER)
(SPOILER)If Sima was scum and had voted for Lu Bu, shouldn't:
a) there be more votes for Lu Bu from the scum side?
b) he have changed his vote to Sunshine towards the end of the day since she and Liu Bei were close in the tally?
(SPOILER)I might just be missing something in your logic, Zhao Yun. If you could clarify your suspicious thoughts, that'd be great.
(SPOILER)Also, sorry for that day one vote. Purely random selection. I love you :D
(SPOILER)Whoops. I meant to include more of a quote from Zhao Yun in that post. Having all these spoiler tags everywhere confuses me :). Oh well, I guess you guys can scroll up two posts to see what he had to say anyway.
Both of those things would have been far too obvious. Voting patterns need to be spread, and all you need to do is look at FDR from President Mafia to see just how risky outright breaking close ties is to save your Mafia buddy. It was more subtle to try and stir others into doing it. The case against Sima definitely isn't strong enough to be certain he's Mafia, not by a long-shot. But I just found his behavior yesterday not quite right.
Also, love you too, baby.
(SPOILER)I dunno. Sima also made an offhand comment about me posting in Spanish (which was hilarious, as I'm sure you all remember!) and saying how suspicious it seemed. As I'm not mafia, I'm assuming Sima Yi is more likely to be a townie that speaks his mind and lays all his evidence out on the table for people to digest rather a mafia that stirs the pot. Could be wrong. My suspicions of Diao Chan are still floating about in the back of my mind, but since she still hasn't gotten in on the action, I'm rather short on possibilities
Sorry, brahs, last night was all booze, pizza, and Game of Thrones 'cause I'm catching up a buddy on culture. Work is like a half hour away too, so this is going to be, like, short. I should be back for the endgame, so don't pass out on me yet.
Stealing this move from a teacher:
Diao Chan, Zhang Fei, Liu Bei all, like, voted for Sun Shang Xiang. Liu Bei was dirtier than Woodstock. Where does that leave the other two?
Gan Ning, Meng Huo, Huang Gai, Zhang Jiao were all on Liu Bei. Sure, Liu Bei was scum, but what misleads people better than voting for your own? Gan Ning seems oily enough, Meng Huo was pretty spammy, Huang Gai I think voted and disappeared, and Zhang Jiao was the hammer for Liu Bei's demise. I'd say I had to have been pretty baked to be mafia and then kill a scum, but then that's me.
##Vote:Zhang Fei because everyone talks better when there's some heat on, babe.
I'm going to leave these bits of information right here, smoke a bowl, and peace out.
Ok, first I'll apologise for my absence; it's exam period, and you people are on the wrong side of the planet.
Secondly I'll explain my vote on Sunshine. While her post probably didn't deserve a vote, I hate it when people are clearly not reading through the thread properly. I understand that her vote was a stab in the dark and a vote to get things going, but she had completely missed the fact that the post she was quoting was an edited joke post by now confirmed mafia member Liu Bei. I said originally that this looked like it could have been a badly planned scum tactic, as I couldn't understand how someone could miss something so obvious. I also said that it may have actually just been a mistake, I still think that both are possible, and both are detrimental to the town.
Sunshine's Post:
(SPOILER)
Liu Bei's edited post:
(SPOILER)
Ma Chao's original post:
(SPOILER)
Lastly, I'll talk about what I've found to be suspicious. I didn't really like the way that Liu Bei and Cao Cao attacked each other, threw votes upon each other, buddied up and then unvoted each other. It just seemed like they were having a pointless argument to distance themselves from each other, while at the same time looking active. (this also happened with, to some degree, Sima Yi) The conversation started here and continues for a while.
I didn't like it as I was reading through it, and I like it less now that I know that Liu Bei is scum. I haven't read anything that makes me feel a vote is needed, but did anyone else find this odd?
Alright guys, I have important news you must read.
Do not under any smurfing circumstances kill me.
This is why.
I am the Bomb. Why did I tell you this? because I think the mafia has already figured this out with all my India hints and that's why they didn't go through with their framing me ploy. Thus the town is at a disadvantage. This now puts us on a level playing field.
As for my vote, it is going on Zhang Fei. He has only posted once and it was to vote alongside a confirmed scum. I know this gives him two votes now but I was going to vote for him before Zhang Jiao posted and I don't know if I will be back today. So my mind hasn't changed.
##Vote: Zhang Fei
I miss DD. :(
My apologies to everyone for my absence over the last few days. I was indisposed on the farm. Moving cattle and making silage. Ah the joys of the countryside. But I'm back now and currently reading all the fun I've missed. Great news that we killed some scum but we need to keep the nose to the grindstone here. I am surprised we have a role claim already in the game but as its a bomb role claim it is definitely an important one. Not suggesting anything but it is surely some food for thought right there.
Anyway I'll be back to post in a while. Plenty of reading to do!
vote count:
zhang fei (2)- sima yi, Zhang Jiao
Sorry I've been inactive real life tends to get in the way :p Sorry to hear about Lu Bu, he actually did his best to contribute & help town yesterday. Liu Bei, despite the fact I was beginning to believe may of been innocent, flipped scum. Not only are we rid of our first scum but we're rid of a spam artist hindering town!
As Sun Ce has pointed out Liu Bei saved Gan Ning from thew lynch with his vote. Now I am aware that Gan Ning did vote for Liu Bei but as we've seen in the past scum aren't above throwing each other under the bus in order to win. Despite the fact they voted for each other in game interaction between the 2 seemed rather sparse. Liu Bei focused on spamming & Gan Ning was just posting here & there. I'll let things play out a little more before voting
In fairness now the majority of Liu Bei's spamming was on day 0. We were all guilty of spamming a little bit on that day. Maybe not to the same level but still.
Anyway. I'm completely lost with all the names and the faces don't help this game either. I was feeling a little suspicious of Sun Shang after her last minute attempt to off Cao Cao on day 0 with that last minute vote but since she was nearly a casualty of the first lynch where we nabbed scum, I'm not so sure. I'm wondering if the votes for her were an attempt to save Liu Bei. But I've nothing to go on so I would appreciate input from others.
Mr. Yin :(
##vote: Sima Yi
My vote is based more on the analysis I did earlier in the day as opposed to the bomb thing. I think the claim was just part of Sima's imitations of past players (that being DD's India) and shouldn't be taken into too much consideration. Just like the Slowpoke Werewolf incident.
You mean they have a framer and they were going to frame you but didn't? How would you know this? And wouldn't they want the town to think a bomb is guilty, so an innocent is lynched and another dies in the blast? I'm confused :(
I'm not inclined to believe the role claim of anybody this early in the game
Roleclaiming at such an early stage doesn't exactly scream innocence. Care to offer any opinions on anyone Lu Meng?
I have little to offer in this case. I also believe role claims this early in the game are less than subtle and you don't want to scream "LOOK AT ME" in this game. And the role claim of the bomb? Seems a bit convenient when people begin to make an accusation in his direction.
Gan Ning claiming bulletproof seems very convient also especially given without Liu Bei's vote change yesterday he wouldn't still be here.
Okay I am back, this is getting interesting. About smurfing time
Sorry, I meant killed, not lynched.
Apparently, but then again, does a jew joke make you a nazi?
That's basically like saying if my grandma had balls she would be my granddad, the answer is no she probably a Hermaphrodite
Does she?
Fair enough :lol:
This is the second time you have attempted to slur me, I feel that you could possibly be scum.
Incidently if I did have a bullet proof vest, then wouldn't that make me not Mafia as townspeople kill with a lynch not with a bullet.
Also how do you figure that without his vote change I wouldn't be here, Liu Bei had 4 votes, I (if your including the vote by Liu) would only have had 3, seems to me your desperate to get rid of me... very suspicious indeed.
##Vote: Cao Cao
Well my friend nice of you to weight in finally. I am gunning for yes, didn't I make that obvious before now? 1 good vote deserves another then I suppose!
##Vote: [M] Gan Ning
Wow.
Voting for somebody because they say something negative towards you is a horrendous move. You want a vocal town and the freedom of opinions so ideas and thoughts are bounced around. Also, this just screams over-defensive. Your card was marked anyway with the voting patterns, but seriously, want to incriminate yourself more? I won't mind. :monster:
##unvote: Sima Yi
##vote: Gan Ning
Gan ning did help to nail the "supposed" mafia godfather. Perhaps he might be a towns person. Nothing is true. Everything is permitted.
Vote for me or not, I don't mind, we will see who is scum, and for being over defensive, he was trying to get rid of me, I know I am not Mafia and he is trying his best to get rid of me so in my mind that makes him a very likely suspect, what is the flaw in that logic?
By your own mouth you admit voting for someone because they voted for you is very suspicious, Cao Cao has just done exactly that, or did you miss that?
I'm going to be bold and attribute that to luck. It was only one vote, and the reasoning about it was shaky enough. Heck, I wouldn't be surprised if it was a vote to avoid potential connections which Gan forgot to remove.
@ cao cao
smurf
@lu meng
An innoncent man has NO need to lose his temper lol stupid no edit!
Sorry didn't see this post before I replied, I just want to clear this up.
The final vote was this:
Let say for instance we put the vote from Liu back to me, you see it don't you? Liu had 4 votes, I (if your going to count the vote of Liu as a vote to have me lynched) would only have had 3, so how is it that he "saved" me? so your reasoning for voting me (imo) is completely baseless.
Be my guest and lynch me if I'm wrong, but then you will know I am not Mafia at least.
My original point about you still stands Gan Ning. You pop up just enough not to seem inactive & attack active players. Your vote on Liu Bei, who flipped scum, as Zhao Yun pointed out was little more than a lucky vote. Plus you're ultra defensive reaction to my allegations at your guilt don't paint a pretty picture. Just saying
I go out for lunch for a few hours and I see a nice war has unleashed itself. To be honest Cao Cao and Gan Ning seem to be potential mafia in this case but then again... aren't we all. I'll try to be more active now that I'm back
But as we have seen from some players in previous games, losing the head is exactly what they do when accused and most of them turned out to be innocent. Everyone reacts differently to an accusation. Besides, what ever happened to the bomb claim earlier. Are we just ignoring an potentially valuable nugget of information?
I am the inactive one? you didn't post till just under 48 hours of the game, obviously there was 24 hours of the night but still... and as I had explained before, I work, I have other commitments outside of the game, so I can't post as much as others, and besides I think I have been quite active during day 2, granted I don't hang on every last post everyone makes but I am new to this game and I feel I only want to post when I want to state my opinion on who I feel is a potential Mafia Scum, does that make me a bad player because I don't reply every 2 minutes?
And tbh I think your just grasping at straws here, I honestly don't consider my posts to be "ultra defensive" I think my posts were accurate and to the point, I said I thought Liu Bai was Mafia, I posted my reasoning, what else is there for me to contribute to the thread other then that? Was it not Lu Bu who said he wanted this to be a bit more constructive, was that post not echoed by others, this is what I have been doing, I read the thread then I post my thoughts.
We all have commitments outside of the game I get that. As for your 48 hour bit that was the beginning of Day 0, my active on Day 1 & 2 I'm one of the most active players. I'm not calling you a bad player because you don't post much but it wouldn't hurt you to contribute more, you know to help town win. My friend if I'm grasping at straws then you're picking up the ones I drop.
I don't think either Gan Ning or Cao Caro are really inactive, everyone has crap they do outside of the game and throwing the blame on someone due to inactivity is only useful when they post only enough to keep them from avoiding suspicion. I don't find gan ning to be suspicious as much as I used to, he may be mafia but I personally doubt it. Currently Zhao has had some decent points being made and as of yet does not have too much suspicious activity to take note of.
For some reason I'm really starting to think that Cao Cao is mafia but I still need to look up the evidence I have before I vote so I know my reasoning for being suspicious.
By the way, ever since Sun Shiang Xiang stopped being mentioned, she seems to have faded out. Quite a contrast to when she had heat on her. And she's kind of a whore.
She works hard for her money. But that's a good point.... there is quite a bit of reason to suspect that woman.
But she did give a good reason for going inactive for a while, her cat died. Considering I see no reason to call bullsmurf on that maybe she's having a rough time. In which case a replacement may be a good thing.
Is that his only post?
I would ask you where you think I am picking up the straws you drop, you said that the fact that I voted for Liu was a weak reason, you could also say that you voted for me on day 1 in cohorts with Liu and then Liu could have changed his vote incase the worst happened (from his perspective) and he got lynched, and didn't want to associate you with voting for me, so changed to Sunny, then you proceed to claim that I was the one who is suspicious even though I helped kill the Mafia Godfather, by putting it up to pure luck, if it was pure luck I would have said something like this:
I Vote Liu Bei cause I don't like him impersonating the Rock.
I thought he was Mafia and he was, surely this gives me a little credibility no? It seems to me your trying to get the others to discount my reasoning which in my mind is completely unbaseless, I have given sound reasoning, you on the other hand have voted for me twice now, once in cohorts with Liu who is proven Mafia and again after I voted for you, which according to Zhao Yun makes said person suspicious then you try to reason it away with completely baseless reasoning, you are the one who I suspect the most and you keep trying to discredit my ability to reason... sounds to me like you want me to be lynched because I have good reasoning skills.
it made me laugh a little bit. If that's his only post.... lmao I may just vote for him.
Liu Bei said everything there is to say about Jiang.
But yeah, that's weird. Quite obvious for a Mafia though, so I'm unsure.
@Gan Ning I also voted for Liu Bei originally because he was impersonating The Rock lol Dude if you want to make me look bad go find some evidence rather than just saying "he wants to lynch me because he thinks I'm a way better player than me & he is jealous". I mean ha?
@Lu Meng That is Jiang Wei's only post
....Is it bad that I find that hysterical?
And incriminating?
Mafia have used the tactic of silence to their advantage before. Out of sight, out of mind!
I assume he means me & Gan Ning's little bitching fest :lol:
I meant both to be completely honest.
That last quote post is now pointless.....smurf :lol:
You know what smurf this school yard bulltrout
##Unvote: [M] Gan Ning
##Vote: [M] Jiang Wei
I figure by now the mods would have to have found a replacement for this player if they weren't inactive on purpose
Thats not how I meant it and I am surprised you find it as such, I said what I said because I think your Mafia, and as I have been able to reason out that Liu was Mafia it stands to reason that you should try to discredit me if indeed you are Mafia, this is not me being arrogant again I say this is sound reasoning and you once again are trying to discredit me, first you said I was grasping at the straws that you drop, NOW you are saying that I am just hiding behind a coat of arrogance, this in my mind coupled with the fact that you have been unable to back up your claim that I am grasping at the straws you drop, to me sounds like you are really trying your best to lower peopls opinion of me in here.
I think I may just join you, because I like active players. If he's town then he isn't contributing anything. I hate to feel that I'm jumping on a bandwagon but for now Ima go on an inactive genocide.
##vote: [M] Jiang Wei
Hopefully this doesn't screw me over later.
You didn't really reason Liu being Mafia, you made a halfhearted remark and got lucky, if I may be so brash. :smash:
Cao Cao at the end of the game I gotta make a gallery of your quotes, some of them have been quite spectacular.
As though we don't already know!
So yeah has anybody else got anything to add?
Plenty but none of it relevant if we all go after an inactive.
So instead of you providing evidence that I am "grasping at the straws that you drop" you are challenging me to back up my claims. Ok:
First lets start at the begining, you Voted for me x2 as did the Mafia Godfather, he feared he may have been killed (either by HC finally getting irritated enough by his constant changing of avatar ect. or by the amount of people who expressed their dislike of "what the rock was cookin'") I had (what was in my mind at least) sound reasoning for voting for him, and so to disassociate your voting for me he changed his vote.
You voted for him... granted but then this could have (very easily) been a tactic you discussed before hand incase such a situation like this ever arose, and you switched to me because "I was keeping my head above water" which again is very poor reasoning.
Time after time you keep saying that I was "saved" by Liu changing his vote from me to Sunny this I also disproved... several times, making it sound like I was in the camp with the Mafia, but lets not forget what is more to the point, if Liu had not been killed and I had, who's votes would they have been? yours and Liu's.
After my asking you to provide evidence that I was not trying to "grasp at the straw you dropped" you countered with "He is hiding behind a coat of arrogance" then when I stated my reasoning for saying what I said you THEN ask me to provide credibility to my reasoning to the fact that I think your Mafia.
After failing to get others to agree with you, you decide to point to other people other then myself because they are inactive players in (again what is in my mind) to get the spot light off of you.
Now if you would be so kind, please point out where I am "grasping at the straws you drop".
It was just a joke. Take it as one. I've given all the thought I had today.
When's the deadline anyway?
I kind of hope our 2 votes get some sort of reaction from Jiang Wei because I'd hate to lynch someone who didn't offer their opinion unless they flip mafia of course :lol:
[M] Zhang Fei (2) - Sima Yi, Zhang Jiao
[M] Sima Yi (0) -Zhao Yun
[M] Cao Cao (1) - Gan Ning
[M] Gan Ning (1) -Cao Cao, Zhao Yun
[M] Jiang Wei (2) - Cao Cao, Meng Huo
Gan Ning really have a boner for me :lol: Now I have to go read the entire thread DAMN YOU :lol:
:eep:Again.... I guess you failed to read the post where I said I knew it was changed... *sigh* Oh well.
I'm sorry I have been inactive most of the day. I've been just a bit busy :( Making cremation arrangements for an animal is a bit harder than a human. That, and chasing a baby around all day takes up all my time.
There was certainly a lot to catch up on! A lot of good points so far. I'm till leaning toward voting for Sima Yi, but I haven't decided. I think I may have skimmed over some stuff because I'm not sure where Gan Ning went wrong.
Another thing, that has hardly anything to do with the actual game... Stop with the spoiler tag bulltrout. It's rather annoying. I've gotten to the point where I don't even read your posts.
During the last day of Mafia, we saw Liu Bei revealed as a traitor to the Han, and Lu Bu killed by mysterious assassins. Liu Bei's sworn brother, Guan Yu, was distraught upon hearing this news. He had be riding from Xiao Pei towards Xia Pi when a messenger rode over the hills and delivered the news of Liu Bei's treachery and subsequent demise to him.
"Brother!" said Guan Yu, "How could you have fallen so low as to betray your ancestors, and your sworn brothers? For what reason could you have turned your backs on us and the oath we swore under the peach tree?" And thusly Guan Yu fell to the floor and wept bitterly, and was inconsolable.
Seeing that their general was in no fit state to continue on with the journey, Guan Yu's men set up camp only 50 miles out from Xia Pi. Once his quarters were erected, Guan Yu, still openly weeping, sequestered himself away within and refused to speak with anyone.
Even in his grief, however, the God of War realised he could not wallow in self pity forever.
"Though you may have forsaken us, brother" said Guan Yu "I will strive to continue on the path towards the ideals you followed before your indiscretion. What little use I may be, I will strive to forge a land of Benevolence!! so that the people may not suffer and the Han be restored to their former glory!"
Gathering his wits about him, Guan Yu then began making preparations for his next move. He called in his advisor, Guo Jia, and enquired as to what steps he should take to carry on his quest.
"I have decided to forge ahead on the path Brother Liu fell from" said Guan Yu to Guo Jia, " The land is divided and frought with conflict and infighting between the various warlords. There is also the matter of the hidden group moving freely in the shadows to be dealt with. What say you the best course of action?"
Guo Jia laid the matter before Guan Yu thus: "Eight hundred years ago, Duke Wen of Jin supported Prince Xiang of the declining Zhou Dynasty, and all the feudal lords backed Duke Wen. The Founder of the Hans, Liu Bang, won the popular favor by wearing mourning for Emperor Yi of Chu. Now Emperor Xian has been a fugitive on the dusty roads. To take the lead in offering an army to restore him to honor is to have an unrivaled opportunity to win universal regard. But you must act quickly or someone will get in before you."
Guan Yu was not appeased. Said he: "Sound counsel, surely, to someone, somewhere. However that one is not me, and I do not understand the relevance of your words. How to deal with the threats before us and quell the conflicts between the good, in order to weed out the evil?"
Said Guo Jia "I like big butts and I can not lie, you other brothers can't deny, that when a girl walks in with an itty bitty waist and a round thing in your face you get SPRUNG!"
Guan Yu became enraged at this proclaimation and seized upon his Green Dragon Sabre, and lo! He beheaded Guo Jia with one swift strike.
"I am surrounded by so much clay fowls and mud dogs!" exclaimed an exasperated Guan Yu. Gathering himself and his resolve, he marched out and bade his army break camp and continue their march to Xia Pi.
Guan Yu's cohort had drawn within 10 miles of Xia Pi when scouts came speeding toward Guan Yu to inform him that a large host of soldiers were bearing down upon them. Not knowing if they were friend or foe, Guan Yu ordered his men into battle formation and prepared for the arrival of this force.
Shortly, riders bearing the flag of BoB Loony appeared, heading a force 5000 strong. They held ground a mile in front of Guan Yu's troop, and the leaders made for the middle of the open ground to enter into discourse.
Once close enough to cast an appraising eye over the man, Guan Yu found himself most confused. With a face like a smacked bumhole, the spindly body of a sickly 12 year old boy, whispy bumfluff patchy moustache and beard and absurdly dressed in all black for no apparent reason, the man hardly seemed leadership material. He immediately began to address Guan Yu:
"Hi mate, names BoB Loony, prefect of Eizon, would you like to come in and see me pie charts? We can look at stati-"
How BoB Loony would have finished his sentence is a secret forever lost, for upon hearing the man speak a great and unexplained wrath consumed Guan Yu, and he beheaded him at once. BoB's force became stricken with fear, and surrendered to Guan Yu immediately.
The episode has been celebrated in poem:
[hip, hip, hip]
There once was a kiwi called Loony
If he was a bard he'd be Spoony
Guan took one look at his head
Thought he'd be better off dead
and no one mourned because he was an almighty tit who smelt like wet dogs
[yip, yip, yip]
With a greatly bolstered force at his disposal, Guan Yu marched on to Xia Pi without further incident. Upon arriving, he was given command of the city and took up residence in the prefects palace. After making the common greetings, a banquet was held in his honour. As the feasting drew to a close, Guan Yu called to him his most trusted officers and advisors.
"My lord, what say you of the current state of the land? Where shall we go from here?"
Said Guan Yu: "I fear it is yet too early to solve the problems of the land, with too little information. Many of the warlords are at odds with each other, and this evil coalition working in the shadows that Brother Liu had joined arms with that killed Lord Lu Bu pose a great threat to the peace of the land. I believe first we must interrogate lord Liu Bei's wife, Sun Shang Xiang, and discern her involvement or lackthereof within this group."
"But Lord Guan Yu, Lord Liu Bei himself was discovered to have been involved in this group, and yet he tried to cast suspicion onto Lady Sun himself before he died? Would it not imply that she herself is innocent?"
"Not so" said Guan Yu "she may yet be guilty. They may have been plotting a ruse to make her appear more innocent than she truly is. It is difficult to say for now, we lack information. But I do not quite trust her, yet."
Sun Shang Xiang's fate and Guan Yu's decision will be revealed in the next few posts.
I like how In the precess of typing my post there was a bajillion more posts xD
##Vote: Zhao Yun
Reason: the above picture -_-
##Unvote: Zhao Yun
Unfortunately the game doesn't work that way...
(SPOILER)'sup.
(SPOILER)Looks like things are moving along nicely. Don't really know what to make of it all though. I think Cao's been a bit suspicious getting people riled up against Gan Ning before changing his vote to inactive Jiang Wei. While Cao makes good points, I'm not convinced Gan Ning is mafia.
(SPOILER)Off to work for now.
## Vote: Cao Cao
[M] Zhang Fei (2) - Sima Yi, Zhang Jiao
[M] Sima Yi (0) -Zhao Yun
[M] Cao Cao (2) - Gan Ning, Yue Ying
[M] Gan Ning (1) -Cao Cao, Zhao Yun
[M] Jiang Wei (2) - Cao Cao, Meng Huo
Things are looking too spread out. Anybody wanna claim Mafia?
Can we all vote her just for the fact she keeps posting like this? This way we don't have to deal with this bulltit anymore?
Why did Yue Ying just vote me?
I don't know. There wasn't a reason. She seems to show up say some crap in spoiler tags that seems mostly irrelevant the swoops back out and disappears until the next day.
I can assure you, Lord Meng Huo, that I too hold deep affection for you. You have my permission to stroke my beard any time you so please, and, with enough wine, I may even let you touch my bum. All I ask in return is that you bring one of your fine war elephants with you and let me have a little ride around on it in the rice fields outside of Chang Sha.
os hit i didn't meant o type that lol
BAH! If only I had the power to night kill *evil laugh*
P.S. I'm back and hemp on logstick I've got a lot of reading to do. I've skimmed and, like, all I immediately want to know is how the voting for Liu Bei went. I've noticed Zhuge Liang is pretty crap at ordering how the votes actually went.
Your beard truly is a work of magnificence, the gods must have toiled for hours to get the features just right. You may rest without worry, my war elephants are always up for a rider of your magnitude.
-cough-
anyway why exactly did he vote for cao cao... I see no real reason (reason on his part)
Guan Yu, that is a brilliant piece of writing, but we do not need that here. Your brother was indeed scum and I am tempted to think all three of you are now.
Whoa that's a lot of recent posts.
##unvote:Gan Ning
##vote: Cao Cao
lol@smiley. it's also quite appropriate for 'ol ninny boy.
Dude I was joking unless you think I am mafia :(
NO JOKES MAFIA R SRS BZNESS
##unvote: Cao Cao
##vote: Jiang Wei
This all you got to say, buddy? You got to give a little to live a little, you know.
I'm still slowly recovering from work, but like, this Gan Ning development could be an important part of how we actually got to string up a mafia man. Like I said previously, I think all the scum were out weekending it up and forgot they needed to keep a watch on the votes, so bye-bye Liu Bei. Early voters are people we need to take a look at.
[M] Zhang Fei (2) - Sima Yi, Zhang Jiao
[M] Sima Yi (0) -Zhao Yun
[M] Cao Cao (3) - Gan Ning, Yue Ying, Lu Meng
[M] Gan Ning (0) -Cao Cao,Zhao Yun
[M] Jiang Wei (3) - Cao Cao, Meng Huo, Zhao Yun
@Meng Huo
Me and Sima Yi get two votes on Zhang Fei and this is,like, all he has to say? BETRAYED? By Yin? Or was that a typo about Yi? Whatever it means, BETRAYAL means something and it probably ain't good.
Smoothie break time.
I cba to do anymore vote counts.
Somebody make an accusation all ready I'm bored!
Somebody get The Rock back up in this bitch.
Actually I'm down to 2 votes as Lu meng unvoted me. Who else do you suspect Meng Huo?
Sunny, did you happen to explain the whole trying to kill me at the end of Day 0 thing? I forget!
3 hours left guys. (SPOILER) I just got an xbox 360 and ff xiii, so excited
I still have a slight suspicion of sun xiang due to the facts represented earlier. Not strong enough evidence for a vote I'm afraid.
##unvote: [M] Jiang Wei
for now I'll just stick with this...
AH 3 hours, might as well hang around to see the show :lol:
Oh and the Host told me to just vote for you so he could end the useless Day 0 and get the game started for real.
But if you knew that then why bother voting?
Well I'm kinda tired now and don't want to be on here all night (madness I know) so I'll cast my vote now. Since I don't have any solid suspicions yet I'm going to vote for an inactive like the rest of you.
##Vote: [M] Jiang Wei
3hours left... Oh lordy
3 hours left of Day 2 and we have gotten really nowhere... I guess maybe I'll just make my vote valid now.
##Vote: Sima Yi
Ima throw my vote where my suspicions lie most...
##vote: [M]: Sun Shang Xiang
@Meng Huo: Why Sunny?
Well it lies with a few reasons
1) Shes really the only one I'm suspicious of at the moment.
2) whatshisface who we lynched seemed to try to drive the attention away from her (among various other reasons which we've gone over (I'm a tad too lazy to go back and find this discussion))
3) she thinks Zhao Yun is sexy which is just... strange
I'll look into it a bit more very soon to provide my backup but until now I'll just rest with that.
[M] Zhang Fei (2) - Sima Yi, Zhang Jiao
[M] Sima Yi (1) - Sun Shang Xiang
[M] Cao Cao (2) - Gan Ning, Yue Ying,
[M] Gan Ning (0) -
[M] Jiang Wei (4) - Cao Cao, Zhao Yun, Lu Meng
[M] Sun Shang Xiang (1)- Meng Huo
I beleive this is the count now? 2 and a half hours left
Well I just got back from fighting space pirates, and the one thing I can say about this game is that nothing is making any damn sense.
I defended Liu Bei because I liked his personality. He was fun, and fun players make the game better. I also thought it would be too risky for a mafia to put themselves out there so early. It turned out that it was. xD
I made a mistake on Day 1 because I thought Lu Bu voted for Sunshine based on something he said, and that's why I kept my vote on him. I was confused because the names and posts in this game are very confusing. :confused:Quote:
A continuation of this - I'm also sensing a kind of nonchalant nature to this vote. Sima isn't attacking Lu necessarily, but he seems pretty deadset on voting for him. Again, I'm not saying this = Mafia, especially considering Lu was just a relatively ordinary member of town and I don't know why Sima would gun for him.
That is not what I was trying to do AT ALL. I just thought it may be better to get rid of a player who may need to be replaced than one who is very active. For Day 1 I think that is pretty fine reasoning. The only reason I didn't switch my vote was because Sunshine's posts did not seem all that scummy to me.Quote:
But this truly gets me suspicious. Soon before Lie Bei is lynched, Sima starts targeting the player with the second most votes! Not only with weak reasoning, but also this inconsequential type of post I keep seeing. There's also arse-covering, "I'm not sure if Sunshine is scum" makes him look okay if she does die and flips town. Nonetheless Sima is, almost passively, trying to shift heat here.
:squeeze:
*morphs into a ball and goes back to rolling through this madness of a thread*
http://images2.wikia.nocookie.net/__...Samus_ball.gif
Given that my reason for voting for Sunny the first time has been rebutted, if you can find where Liu Bei was drawing attention from her Meng Huo I may be persuaded to change my vote to her also.
ff xiii looks like a movie!!!!
I love our host.
no you do not
Then why does Jiang Wei have 4 votes?
Sorry I haven't been here yet again. The timings of the days are quite awkward for me at the minute, but I promise I'll try and be more active. Seeing as how we only have a few hours left, I'm going to go and skim the thread quickly and try and get a vote out there.
I'm sorry I haven't been here much, but my monitor died on me. I'm posting this from my mums laptop.
welcome back wei
Alas I guess my memory has failed me yet again, gah I just don't know who to vote for anymore
##unvote: [M] Sun Shang Xiang
I thought I was onto something, the only bit I remember is, it could be something but then he does vote for her later, but I don't know... it may have been part of his spam-filled plan to get the attention onto him. I just don't know
##unvote: Jiang Wei
##vote: Zhang Fei
smurf it I don't know
DAY 1 AS SEEN BY LIKE VOTES MAN
SSX -> Ma Chao (1)
Diao Chan -> SSX (1)
Gan Ning -> Liu Bei (1)
Sima Yi -> Lu Bu (1)
Yue Ying -> Zhao Yun (1)
Guan Yu -> Yue Ying (1)
Zhang Fei -> SSX (2)
SSX ->Ma Chao(0)
Cao Cao -> SSX (2x) (4)
Ma Chao -> Liu Bei (2)
Liu Bei -> Meng Huo (1)
Cao Cao ->SSX (2x)(2)
Ma Chao ->Liu Bei(1)
Liu Bei ->Meng Huo(0)
Cao Cao -> Gan Ning (2x) (2)
Liu Bei -> Gan Ning (3)
Meng Huo -> Liu Bei (2)
Liu Bei ->Gan Ning(2)
Liu Bei -> SSX (3)
Huang Gai -> Liu Bei (3)
Zhang Jiao -> Liu Bei (4)
People who posted after my final vote:
SSX
Meng Huo
Lu Bu
Sun Ce
They are people who could have, like, stopped Liu Bei from dying.
Two people are also noteworthy:
Ma Chao - Posted two minutes before my final vote and said he was going to watch (with popcorn!).
Gan Ning - Posted immediately after Zhuge Liang was closing the day. Possibly was around before the day actually ended.
[M] Zhang Fei (3) - Sima Yi, Zhang Jiao, Zhao Yun
[M] Sima Yi (1) - Sun Shang Xiang
[M] Cao Cao (2) - Gan Ning, Yue Ying,
[M] Gan Ning (0) -
[M] Jiang Wei (3) - Cao Cao, Lu Meng
[M] Sun Shang Xiang (0)-
2 hours and 5 minutes left
Why does Zhang Fei have 3 votes?
so Lu Meng has 2 votes?
Seems that way.