This is an extremely important question.
Printable View
This is an extremely important question.
Cake or death? Equally important.
Also, depends what cake and what pie.
Does cheesecake count as cake? If not, neither. :-/
Pie is the only answer. All things in pie form are good. Apple pie. Spaghetti pie. Slang referring to women's genitals pie.
Only a few types of cake are good. Birthday cake. Chocolate cake. After that you have things like yellow cake and urinal cake which are gross bad.
Both.....but homemade .....
guys guys i think this thread was supposed to be a joke where the setup is "Cake or Pie?" and the answer is "both! so that'd be PIKE (PIe + caKE)"
I think pie, but I'm not sure. I like both.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Denmark
Leave Pike as a fish :)
EoFF's first New Year's resolution will be to stop making food threads.
There are more enjoyable cakes than pies but there are some pies are are awesome.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Faris
That wouldn't go over well....
For every food thread made, a CK loses a wing.
Answer for this is pie.
Pie is generally superior, though it can depend on the type of pie and cake involved (my mom bakes an excellent chocolate chip cake which outclasses many pies).
Cakes are better. Let's be real, here.
Pizza = pie. I rest my case.
No. Why.Quote:
Originally Posted by Værn
Why do you do this.
Somebody please explain it to me. You have a perfectly good name for pizza. It's called pizza. Pies are nothing like that. Hell, you people don't even understand the wonder of a true blue pie. A meat pie. Dessert "pies" like apple pie and whatever are still pie, but pizza... pizza is not a pie. It is not.
Please stop throwing around words wildly America. There's no such thing as Canadian bacon. It's just smurfing ham.
Cake. Fools say otherwise.
When I visited Norway a couple of years ago, I was introduced to a delicious "Deer Pie", with its delicious meat. It looked VERY similar to this one:
http://pippahunnechurch.com/wp-conte...humblepie2.gif
:drool:
Caaaake! :)
The only pie I like is apple, but I don't like cake at all. Except cheesecake which, having baked several, I would say most definitely is more cake than pie.
I dunno. There are times when either are acceptable. I love them both so much. :love:
How do you define a pie? Is it not something made from a crust, containing some sort of filling or topping? Because, if you ask me, a pizza seems to fit that definition. Feel free to argue that it's not a "proper" pie, but that won't change whether it is or is not actually a pie.Quote:
Originally Posted by JiroNo. Why.Quote:
Originally Posted by Værn
Why do you do this.
Somebody please explain it to me. You have a perfectly good name for pizza. It's called pizza. Pies are nothing like that. Hell, you people don't even understand the wonder of a true blue pie. A meat pie. Dessert "pies" like apple pie and whatever are still pie, but pizza... pizza is not a pie. It is not.
Please stop throwing around words wildly America. There's no such thing as Canadian bacon. It's just smurfing ham.
And please stop throwing accusations around wildly, Australia. I've never referred to anything as "Canadian bacon." Ever.
No.Quote:
Originally Posted by Faris
Food threads are an essential part of EoFF and I won't let you take that from me! :mad2:
Fun fact: I am named after a roleplaying character I invented when I was like 12, who was named after the weapon. So there were actually no fish involved!Quote:
Originally Posted by Flaming Ice
blaming America for something and then citing a Canadian example? i feel the same way about Canadian bacon, don't lump us with themQuote:
Originally Posted by Jiro
say "i meant north america" and i will actually murder you
A pie is pastry.Quote:
Originally Posted by VærnHow do you define a pie? Is it not something made from a crust, containing some sort of filling or topping? Because, if you ask me, a pizza seems to fit that definition. Feel free to argue that it's not a "proper" pie, but that won't change whether it is or is not actually a pie.Quote:
Originally Posted by JiroNo. Why.Quote:
Originally Posted by Værn
Why do you do this.
Somebody please explain it to me. You have a perfectly good name for pizza. It's called pizza. Pies are nothing like that. Hell, you people don't even understand the wonder of a true blue pie. A meat pie. Dessert "pies" like apple pie and whatever are still pie, but pizza... pizza is not a pie. It is not.
Please stop throwing around words wildly America. There's no such thing as Canadian bacon. It's just smurfing ham.
And please stop throwing accusations around wildly, Australia. I've never referred to anything as "Canadian bacon." Ever.
It would be like making a resolution to join the gym. It'll only last a few weeks max one month. :roll2Quote:
Originally Posted by PikeNo.Quote:
Originally Posted by Faris
Food threads are an essential part of EoFF and I won't let you take that from me! :mad2:
Quote:
Originally Posted by LockhartedA pie is pastry.Quote:
Originally Posted by VærnHow do you define a pie? Is it not something made from a crust, containing some sort of filling or topping? Because, if you ask me, a pizza seems to fit that definition. Feel free to argue that it's not a "proper" pie, but that won't change whether it is or is not actually a pie.Quote:
Originally Posted by JiroNo. Why.Quote:
Originally Posted by Værn
Why do you do this.
Somebody please explain it to me. You have a perfectly good name for pizza. It's called pizza. Pies are nothing like that. Hell, you people don't even understand the wonder of a true blue pie. A meat pie. Dessert "pies" like apple pie and whatever are still pie, but pizza... pizza is not a pie. It is not.
Please stop throwing around words wildly America. There's no such thing as Canadian bacon. It's just smurfing ham.
And please stop throwing accusations around wildly, Australia. I've never referred to anything as "Canadian bacon." Ever.
Exactly, a bread crust is not pastry. By that logic bread with a crust is a pie. :/
You guys shouldn't be so close minded. It is both.
A pie can also be: ice cream (cherry-flavoured ice cream with cherry pie pieces) and a soup (vegetable broth, with small miniature pies filled with ground beef).
omgomgomgomgomg
WHAT EVEN IS A PIE
WHAT
I DON'T KNOW ANYMORE
MIND HAS BEEN BLOWN I JUST CAN'T EVEN.
A PIE IS NOTHING
THE PIE IS NOTHING
THE PIE IS A LIE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
You sound like you could use some pie.
I know, I may have to have myself a festive mince pie right now.Quote:
Originally Posted by Chris
pie
/pī/
Noun
A baked dish of fruit, or meat and vegetables, typically with a top and base of pastry
I only eat pies from tins.
As soon as I saw your name as a reply. I KNEW what it would be referring too.Quote:
Originally Posted by Parker
cake obvs
Cake, solely because you can't make carrot cake soup with pie.
Sounds like a challenge in my ears! Let's do battle!Quote:
Originally Posted by Jowy
It wouldn't work! The pie crust wouldn't mix with the partially melted ice cream and turn into the most delicious substance known to man.
No I don't mean North America I mean I ordered pizza from a US outlet and it had "canadian bacon" on itQuote:
Originally Posted by Denmarkblaming America for something and then citing a Canadian example? i feel the same way about Canadian bacon, don't lump us with themQuote:
Originally Posted by Jiro
say "i meant north america" and i will actually murder you
what does that even smurfing mean
no
no this is all wrong
Quote:
Originally Posted by JiroNo I don't mean North America I mean I ordered pizza from a US outlet and it had "canadian bacon" on itQuote:
Originally Posted by Denmarkblaming America for something and then citing a Canadian example? i feel the same way about Canadian bacon, don't lump us with themQuote:
Originally Posted by Jiro
say "i meant north america" and i will actually murder you
what does that even smurfing mean
no
no this is all wrong
Canada has superior pigs ;)
Back bacon - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Fun fact: I am named after a roleplaying character I invented when I was like 12, who was named after the weapon. So there were actually no fish involved![/QUOTE]Quote:
Originally Posted by Flaming Ice
Well weapons are still good anyways...but you could always slap people with a pike.
GET OUT.Quote:
Originally Posted by Denmark
What in the hell is this?Quote:
Originally Posted by Jowy
One of the main reasons why I'm choosing pie. Not to mention chicken pot pie. Apple is my favorite kind of pie if it doesn't count.Quote:
Originally Posted by Værn
And if pizza pie does count, I would like to mention that they make pizza with desert added to it. Doesn't really sound appealing until you've tried it.
Carrot cake soup is just vanilla ice cream and a slice of carrot cake stirred together vigorously in a bowl until they blend together.
At first I thought cake but the more I think about it... I'm gonna have to go with pie. I've always had more of a savoury tongue but a pie can be both sweet and savoury. Cake you are stuck only with the sweet.
So for me, pie is the winner... due to it's versatility.
Pie, Pie, you are so versatile
Pie, Pie, oh how you make me smile
Cake, Cake, oh for goodness sake
You're just to sweet for me to take...
For oral pleasure and tongue parties galore
A pie will always leave you wanting more
The sweetness of cake is always second best
Unless it's a cream one you can rub on your chest...
PIE! Ooohhhhh PIE!
Run my tongue over your pastry, MY, OH MY!
PIE! Ooohhhhh PIE!
You are the applie pie of my EYE!!!!!
Pie...
~ Bubba - Dec 2012
Why not.... cake-pie?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bubba
That needs a "google serach" ;)
Although I do enjoy a good Pumpkin Pie every once in a while, I enjoy many more flavors of cake.
Also frosting is better than crust :colbert:
It depends on the pie. I have a particular favorite. :jokey:
carrot cake
cheesecake
chocolate bourbon cake
chocolate lava cake
coffee cake
cupcakes
ice cream cake
german chocolate
red velvet
rum cake
spiced pumpkin cake
strawberry shortcake
tiramisu
Ever heard of chocolate pie shots? No. It's chocolate cake, because it's better.
CAKE, MOTHERsmurfERS.
Eddie Izzard -- Cake or Death? - YouTube
Relevant.
Ever hear of upside down apple cake shots? Nope. Ever hear of pumpkin cake shots? nuh uh. Pecan cake shots?Quote:
Originally Posted by Shorty
Ever hear of chicken pot cake, cheese burger cake, frito cake? Or spaghetti cake?
NO. All of those are delicious forms of pie that cake cannot achieve. So get out.
Applie pie and pecan pie sucks and pumpkin pie is mediocre at best and made only better with whipped cream and vanilla ice cream served with it.
AND NONE OF THOSE OTHER THINGS ARE SWEET AND SUGARY FOA YOU CHEATER
Never come back to America, ever. Your apple-pie hating kind will not be tolerated in these borders.
Listen man, I like pies but you're naming all the wrong ones.
BANANA CREAM, FOA. THAT IS THE BEST ONE. Oreo is second, but I can make an oreo cake that's better, so.
So you lose.
CHERRY PIE! :jokey:
Pies are so much better than cakes, but I love and enjoy both. I just prefer pies more. :)
Neither.