Mafia V, Final Fantasy Edition Sign up and Questions!

[Goldenboko]

You miss the point, no townie would believe it until my role revealed a Mafian, until then I can't be trusted. I did point out Lulu, and vote with two mafians, didn't matter see. Until I got a "guilty" that was a mafian they wouldn't care. Maybe if you didn't tell them there was a possibility of a mafian cop my roleclaim would've helped.

[Miriel]

Oh, and I mentioned this in the Mafia forum, but I think revealing the roles was detrimental to anyone who wanted to take on a false roleclaim. Towards the end, if it wasn't for the role reveals, Mafia might have been able to last a bit longer (although I think we were doomed no matter what). Process of elimination, although it helped Mafia, helped out the town a lot more.

[Psychotic]

You miss the point, no townie would believe it until my role revealed a Mafian, until then I can't be trusted.

Same for town cop.

Maybe if you didn't tell them there was a possibility of a mafian cop my roleclaim would've helped.

I agree.

[Del Murder]

I also agree that the revelation of role notes weren't a good idea. In the end that proved Edgar's downfall.

All and all I think qwerty and Psy did a good job, but I wouldn't want to do the 'everyone has a role' game again.

EDIT: Power! So much power! I feel it returning in my veins!

[Shauna]

I thought this game went well. Too many power roles though, and I need to learn to have some good judgement. xD The amount of times I thought I'd get killed because I defended someone who came up scum, or made final votes on innocent townies... xD

But yeah, I thought this was a good game. =] Look forward to the next one! =D

[Del Murder]

I want to play a game where the mafia were: Me, Miriel, Psychotic, and Jojee. That would be fun.

[qwertysaur]

Sorry about not coming on today. My computer is not working, so I'm using a friends. You can see the mason forum now.

The roles in the game were balanced, and the players were random. We were revealing roles because you would have all complained if the jester was lynched. Don't worry, next time we host a game were leaving you all in the dark. Glad you had fun though.

[Bahamut2000X]

I just got done reading the Mafia forum and that was a good read.

Though Miriel wanted me dead like every other post. Why the hate.


Though looking forward to the next game. Can't wait for that.

[Psychotic]

I want to play a game where the mafia were: Me, Miriel, Psychotic, and Jojee. That would be fun.

We should have a C9 game with those four, Lev, BoB, Qwerty, Lekana and I Took the Red Pill.

'twould be a good 'un.

[Dolentrean]

Ha ha ha, I think the game was great, albet I am the Nexus, that was fun XD

[Levian]

For what it's worth I think the initial set up was quite balanced. All three groups had a fair chance at winning. (well, maybe not the lovers, but such is the way of the serial killer. For that alignment they still had very much power.) It's just that this is an unpredictable game, and sometimes hit the fan, because of perhaps bad luck or bad judgment from the player.

I kinda want to join the next one now.

[Freya]

I hated my role. SOOOOOO much but hey Joy I won the game and I hated my role. So stick that in your juice box and suck it.

I wanted to get lynched tbh. Just to see what it'd tell the town and mafia. They'd be all "oh snap"

[oddler]

After death and after I got the list of roles in front of me, I really thought it was a pretty nice setup. I liked that there were modified or made-up roles, too. Throwing a little curveball here and there is awesome; I agree, though, that there was probably a little too much in this game to actually be able to make sense of it all. Nexus? Total BS if you ask me.

All in all, it was excellent fun. I'd like to see another non-vanilla game but I also agree that they should be few and far between.

It hugely sucked bad that I got night killed. Good shot, though.

[Levian]

Woah, nice work on the role descriptions. Must've taken you ages.

[Jessweeee♪]

hahaha...that was fun! Best role ever n.n