The most comfortable by far was the Gamecube pad, god I loved that thing. Other than that yeah I'd probably say the 360 pad is a good one, very comfortable to hold and perfectly designed for FPS games. My only major gripe with it is that it is absolute horse trout for fighting games, would take the PS pad for fighting games all day every day. If I had both consoles all my Tekken, Soul Calibur, Street Fighter and Blazblue etc etc would be PS3 versions without question.