I guess it's all believeable if you assume that she's just not a naturally suspicious or cautious person, and being a catious person myself, that reason alone would cause me not to like her. But it's hard to believe that someone would be so trusting so quickly after everything she's been through and the situation they are in. That doesn't just go for Andrea, it's strange that all of Woodbury just gladly goes along with all the suspicious ass stuff that goes on around there.

I'll have to read the comic now because I'm sure this is better written in there.