Yeah, a lot of people hate his run, but I'm personally with Raistlin on him. Great script writer, not as good as a show runner. I think that overall the RTD era was a bit better in that regard, but that era can also lay claim to some of the best episodes Moffat ever penned. And I certainly wouldn't say that Moffat's turn as show runner has been awful. Uneven in places certainly, but still enjoyable.