I can't say I feel strongly either way. I have a feeling that right now my gut reaction is to say that I like PS2 Tidus more, but I feel like that opinion is heavily influenced by my own nostalgia. I'm sure that if I sat down, played the HD remaster (when it finally comes out, that is), and had a chance to get used to PS3 Tidus, I'd like him just as much as PS2 Tidus.