I liked his personality in awakening and by adding Justice into him he just got so... grumpy. He was such a jokester in awakening and that was refreshing. Then he just.... wasn't. He was so serious. In awakening he was pissed about the mage treatment but he still help a sense of humor. In 2 he just.. was boring.

I did romance him in my first play through, then fenris in my second, and sebastian in my third.

I played DA:O a few times but always ended with alistair cause he's just so adorkable.