-
I mean, sure, I pushed for No Death. But if you take a look at my reasoning for it, my idea was simply to not kill anyone until we have anything to go with, as I usually play mafia beginning with the night phase. Considering we now have 6 warriors of Cosmos instead of the hypothetical 5, I'd say my reasoning was sound. It was never my intention to refrain from lynching later on. But of course, I could be just saying that, you might think. That aside, do you really think I'd kill someone for disagreeing with my vote, Nutty? Wouldn't make me a very smart guy, would it 
Another thing I'd like to talk about is the character identities. I don't really think we can trust what people say in that regard, especially those revealed today. Karifean stated precisely in the rules that we may lie about this, and after the revelation of how detailed the nighttime descriptions are. That said, they're still a bit vague, and we can still assume someone lied about their identity beforehand. So theoretically, even though I said I drew Noctis, that doesn't mean that really is the case. I think the only person we can safely assume is completely honest about their identity is Formy since Keflavik was pretty clearly part of that description. So either he got it or was really lucky in guessing that someone had it - in which case the person who actually got Kefka knows that he's lying. That said, that doesn't mean he's truthful about everything - he could very well be working for Chaos but just decided to do nothing that night. I kind of don't know what to think about Scruffy's revelation, to be honest, since the only person in the description that would match Dagger was the killer. So either he's actually a vanilla townie, which is why he didn't actually get mentioned, laying the cards on the table to prove his innocence, or the actual killer. I need to hear what other people say about him before I can make a decision.
With all that said, so far I'm more or less convinced it was Nutty, however. Unless I missed something, there was no mention of someone who could be Lenna - and no one else - and judging from the previous round, I think it's pretty safe to assume Nutty has a nighttime ability, and I'm pretty sure all abilities were represented in the description. And then there's the fact he was so quick to not only reveal his character, seemingly so as to clear himself of all suspicion, as well as accuse me. Granted, all this could simply be newbie mistakes, but I can't help but feel very suspicious.
I won't cast my vote yet, though, since 1) an early vote didn't seem to win me much fans on the first day
and 2) I realize my accusation of Nutty may be reactionary to his accusation of me, so I want to see what other people have to say first.
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules