EoFF Mafia Dissidia

[Scruffington]

I think we have enough leeway that we can afford a lynch or two outside of the "female" suspect.

What I find ironic is that out of the five suspects, three have directly voted for Shauna (Fynn, Formalhaut and FFNut). Lynching Shauna will pretty much confirm that two of these three players is mafia.

So basically if we lynch Shauna and she turns out to be town, we still gain a good amount of information and our odds get better the next day.

[Shauna]

;_;

[Formalhaut]

Brutal.

of course, we still have the fact that two people investigated me. Even if said investigators didn't want to reveal that I'm Mafia because it places a target on their back and reveals their role (which is fair enough), it should be noted that no-one has tried to subtlety implicate me as Mafia on this Day. Compared to the bandwagon on Day One, it's actually been pretty quiet.

Which does make Flynn and Nutty somewhat more suspicious. It all depends on whether or not Shauna flips town. Which, admittedly, I'm less certain she's Mafia. But I've stuck to my decision, mistake or not.

[Fynn]

Except only one investigating role actually checks for alignment - the detective. Aside from that, the identifier checks identity, and the investigator checks role, so basically, Qwert could have been a detective or investigator while Fox was an identifier who only confirmed that you're Kefka.

So you're not off the hook yet, Forms

(And I saw that typo regrettable)

[Formalhaut]

Except only one investigating role actually checks for alignment - the detective. Aside from that, the identifier checks identity, and the investigator checks role, so basically, Qwert could have been a detective or investigator while Fox was an identifier who only confirmed that you're Kefka.

I was typing on an iPad, my bad!

And I'm still working my head around the whole 'similar but different' investigative roles. I'm used to there just being a 'detective', and that's that.

[Formalhaut]

Also, if Qwerty/Seifer was the detective, was bad luck for our detective to be killed off in Night One.

[Freya]

If fox was investigating Formy for whatever reason, they wouldn't be on the same team. What's the point of that when you can talk to your team mate.

Fox and formy are not on the same chaos team.

So whatever fox found out, but doesn't want to share, is what is interesting. Fox has not pushed for formy to be lynched. Whatever fox found out, isn't incriminating on formy.

If Fox is Cosmos, pushing for a town is bad after you know they're good, that's obvious.

If Fox is Chaos, pushing for a town after having your investigation somewhat public, is extremely bad for you. If we lynch formy, formy is town, fox is in a very very bad light.

[Freya]

If fox is Cosmos and their evidence isn't strong for a lynch, it could be just not enough to judge by so it's skipped. It depends on what Fox found out on what they know on why they'd do whatever.

A + B = I don't even know

[Formalhaut]

That's a pretty good summary, I think. Fynn is correct though: Fox/Cid might just be an identifier, which is basically a poor man's Detective. My alignment isn't automatically resolved just because someone visited me in the night.

It will be very interesting to see who is investigated the coming night, though. There's A LOT of suspicion hanging around FFNut (and not without good reason). Fynn and Scruffy might be targets as well. Even you, Freya, as your character isn't as pinned down. People might investigate you for the flavour-text alone.

[Freya]

I'm fairly confident that our mafia is currently on different voting paths. That way if one person is on the wrong side, they other will at least look better.

[Formalhaut]

I'm fairly confident that our mafia is currently on different voting paths. That way if one person is on the wrong side, they other will at least look better.

Not a bad argument. Definitely at least one person who is currently voting for Shauna is Mafia. Well, I say definitely, I'm not hundred percent, but it seems likely.

[Freya]

If the wrong people get lynched and not protected in the night, this game will end on day four after the lynch.

After today, if it's a townie lynched, it'll be 7 total people, 5-2
Night 2 = 6 total, 4-2
Day 3 = 5 total, 3-2
Night 3 = 4 total, 2-2
Day 4 = 3 total, 1-2

That's if the mafia can keep low the whole time, they'll have to make it two days.

If The doctor can get a good protection down then that makes their lives harder.

So say

Night 2 = 5-2

Then that gives an extra day. They can't have that, it's a harder that way. They have til the end of day 4. Any bump in that makes life harder.

So thanks for that guys.

[Fynn]

stoll, even if today's lunch will turn out false, we'll be one step closer to catching the actual killer, which may as well happen on day three. A single Chaos representative that cannot kill will still be manageable and will definitely give us more time.

[Scruffington]

Thought I would update my info log with some new information revealed.

--CURRENT PLAYERS--

Noctis (Fynn) did not appear to perform an action.
Garnet (Scruffington) did not appear to perform an action.
Cid (Fox) watched someone. He is a Detective, Watcher, Tracker, or Identifier.
Kefka (Formalhaut) was watched and did not appear to perform an action.
Lenna (FFNut) did not appear to perform an action.
Shadow (Shauna) did not appear to perform an action.
Faris (Aerith's Knight) watched someone. She is a Detective, Watcher, Tracker, or Identifier.


--COSMOS-ALIGNED--
Freya (???) is a Doctor.


--DECEASED--
Seifer (qwertysaur) watched someone. He is a Detective, Watcher, Tracker, or Identifier.

--Detective, Watcher, Tracker, or Identifier.--
Fox (Cid)
Aerith's Knight (Faris)
???


--UNKNOWN--
Garnet (Scruffington)
Noctis (Fynn)
Lenna (FFNut)
Kefka (Formalhaut)
Shadow (Shauna)

I made some mistakes with my last post. The only 100% confirmed town at this point is Freya. Everyone else is fair game.

[Freya]