I'll explain.

Quote Originally Posted by Karifean View Post
A black-haired adolescent was relaxing in his room, deciding to get some much-needed sleep after the stressful day. An androgynous person who apparently couldn't decide what hair color suited them best was observing them through a crack in the door. When they realized the man was not planning on heading out that night, they decided to leave them alone.

While returning to their room, they passed by a man clad in white armor who was heading into the room right next to theirs. The armored man was met with the smiling face of a girl and decided to keep her company for a while, worried she might get attacked. When the man realized nobody was going to come, he decided to call it a night, casting a protective spell on the room before he left, just in case.

A few corridors away, a blonde man with a confident smile on his face was wandering around, looking for the colorfully clothed man who had drawn much attention to themselves with his creepy way of talking during the day. He found him in his room and decided to make some small talk with him, asking him a few questions while closely observing his mannerisms. They were soon joined by an older man whom both the blonde man and his conversation partner knew. The older man seemed interested in joining their conversation, so they talked for a few hours about their situation. Over time the older man gradually recovered some of his memories regarding the colorful man.

After some time, the men decided it was time to get some sleep, so the blonde man and the older man left the room and went their separate ways, both in a good mood. However, as the blonde man rounded a corner, he was suddenly met with the eerie, unsettling smile of a girl. He instinctively realized the person before him was not his ally and drew his blade, but it was already too late; the girl started chanting and the next thing the man knew he was floating in the air unable to move, and before he could react any further he felt himself being ripped apart. But even that feeling left him only moments after, and he would never move ever again.

qwertysaur has died, he was Seifer, Cosmos-aligned Proud Hero.

Based on this, there are several people who took certain actions at night. Let's see how many we have.

So, in order, we have:
- a black-haired adolescent
- an androgynous person who can't decide on hair color
- a man in white armor
- a girl
- a blond man
- a colorfully clothed man
- an older man
- (another girl?)

Depending on whether the girl described as the killer is the same girl as the one protected earlier, there were seven or eight characters described.

What I meant before was that none of the two girls was explicitly described as pink-haired or anything else that might directly point to Lenna. I didn't mean there wasn't anyone that couldn't be Lenna, but there was no one person mentioned that could only be Lenna. The girl could be Dagger, Porom, Relm, etc.

That said, both might actually be the same girl, or both Nutty and Scruffy could be telling the truth about their identities, so they might be both of the girls described. That would suggest either of them is the killer, unless the mysterious ninth person is another girl. But if you're telling the truth, Shauna, then you are the ninth person because Shadow doesn't appear on this list.

Trying to deduce who these characters are, based on common knowledge of FF and what people have claimed their characters are, here are some possibilities of who each person is:

- black-haired adolescent - Noctis (it could easily be some other guy, like Zack, but considering I've revealed myself as Noctis, I'm guessing this is me)
- androgynous character - most likely Faris (either blond or purple hair depending on artwork - it fits)
- man in white armor - Cecil comes to mind
- a girl - either Lenna or Dagger, if both Scruffy and FFNut are telling the truth
- a blond man - confirmed to be Seifer
- a colorfully clothed man - definitely Kefka
- an older man - Fox's Cid, most likely
- a girl - again, either Lenna or Dagger

If we assume everyone so far has revealed their true identity, that only leaves Shauna's Shadow as unmentioned in the nighttime report.

This would point to either Scruffy or Nutty being the killer. But the problem is, if the girl protected by the knight and the girl who killed Seifer are the same person, that actually leaves two open spaces, and people could be lying.

Of course, cosidering there are roles such as the roleblocker and the switcher, it might be hard to deduce just from that who the Chaos representatives are. And then there's the fact that all the identifying roles - of which we have at least two, unless someone was idle, so Fox's Cid and the now deceased Seifer - can be of either alignment.