So I got a 1up in my box I finally got, meaning I got an extra game. My games were:

Perfect dark for n64
Vector man for genesis
Dr mario/ puzzle league for gba
Call of duty 2 big red one for ps2
Black and bruised for ps2

All in all, some good stuff but not fantastic. I'll try it for a couple more months and see. I'm also thinking of doing a blog or something where I'll review the service as a whole and then review/write about each individual game I get from this as something for fun.