She's alright. She's probably not as stupid as portrayed, but thats beside the point.

Ashley's songs are better, and she's hotter with Black Hair. Also, I don't care whether she actually really sucks, or if she was just having very bad day's during the super bowl and that other performance she lip synced. The songs are still cool.

But Michelle Branch is hotter than both of them, by a noticeable amount. And more talented by far.