I think it's funny when people go to a forum for a specific game and ask the people in that forum if they should buy that game. You might only get the input from people who love the game, so of course their opinions about it would be the same... but you don't get the input from people who've played the game and disliked it. Therefore, some will like the game, and some will not, so getting others' opinions doesn't really help you much, because you might be disappointed.