I turned the word 'Annifont' in the first post into a link to the zipped up font files for it. Hope hat helps.

Rye: I decided I think yours is just a bit 'busy' for my liking overall. It seems like there's a lot going on, even if there are just a few different pictures in it. Still, the new blue is a great improvement.

Dan: Probably a little too simple and the use of colours tends to put me off as EoFF Classic never really suited a variety of colours - all the previous banners were totally blue, if I remember correctly.

Zeldy: I don't mind the new font but Annifont would be an improvement. I agree with pretty much whatever else Psy said, too. I also agree with Unne that the use of Vivi - or some character that shows off or points to the older FF's - would be useful. I like the use o the eye, it's a pretty one, too!

Unne: Needs a black background, the white doesn't appeal to me at all. Not personally keen on animated banners either. Would be interested to see how you can get it to work under the stated requirement of JPG or PNG. Could also do with annifont.

Decessus: Also needs a black background, along with some FF characters and annifont.

bipper: We asked for a banner, not a title.