If Tifa and Aerith fought...

[Firo Volondé]

Sephypoo was worried about Holy. Not Aerith.

Sephypoo was also worried about Aerith, she being the only person who was able to use the White Materia.

Bull and Crap. Anyone could use Holy if they gave thought to it, same as any other Materia, and especially after heading through the temple, where the instructions to it and its opposite were inscribed. Yes, Aerith was a threat, but were Aerith minused Holy, Sephy would not have given her a second's thought.

anyone could have used Holy? hmm looks like its time for our friend Mr Game Script to put in an aperence.

Cloud: What is this place?

Aerith: This forest leads to the City of the Ancients... and is called the
Sleeping Forest. It's only a matter of time before Sephiroth uses Meteor.
That's why I'm going to protect it. Only a survivor of the Cetra, like me, can
do it. This secret is just up here. At least it should be. ...I feel it. It
feels like I'm being led by something. Then, I'll be going now. I'll come back
when it's all over.

Cloud: Aerith?

Aerith left, but Cloud couldn't move towards her.

Sephiroth: Hmm...... She's thinking of interfering? She will be a difficult
one, don't you think? We must stop that girl soon.

Now call me a liar if you will but im sure Sephiroth is refuring to Aerith as the problem... again I could be wrong

Materia is open to anyone with the knowledge to use it. Aerith, as a Cetra, has the capability to hear the planet which is pulling her to use the power, but not the exclusive capability. And I never said Aerith+Holy was not a threat. Just that Aerith- Holy would not have been.

You're right, Aerith doesn't have exclusive capability to hear the planet - any living Cetra could. Hmmm... wait a minute! Aerith is the only living Cetra left! Therefore, Sephiroth was as worried about Aerith as he was about Holy, probably more, since Aerith was the one utilizing Holy, not vice versa.

Well Since Aeris can give and take more dangage, can heal her self with out Materia, can seal Tifa's materia to force her to only attack physically and has an actual weapon. I say Tifa's as good as finished.

Aeris > Tifa

And considering that Tifa is faster than Aeris, stronger than Aeris, has an incredibly powerful limit break combo and also that Aeris sucks physically, can no way give or take more damage than Tifa and that Tifa can actually fight.

Tifa > Aeris.

erm I have a question for you: how do you know Aerith isnt as fast as Tifa? not that I dissagre with you or anything but you actully never saw Aerith moveing much it doesnt mean that she cant move damn fast if she has to.

Tifa = Kick ass, Aerith = Kick much ass

And how do we know that Cait Sith cannot outarmwrestle Proud Clod? And how do we know Barret can't do quantum physics in his head? We have no evidence of Aerith moving quickly, hence we have no reason to believe that she is capable of things she has never been observed doing.

How do we know Tifa is faster than Aerith? We have no evidence of Aerith being unable to move quickly, hence there is no way anybody can claim that Tifa moves faster than Aerith, which is what ~Reno~ was saying.

Tifa the difa hands down, Aeris is too soft and I don't recall this Gsopel move that everyone's talking about.

Great Gospel - Aerith's Lv. 4 Limit Break.