Thanks for saying that but fact it seems not many people care about my sig making thread -_- anyway back to business...
Erm...honestly the 3rd one is nice because of the animation.That's my opinion...and the 1st and 2nd one...I like the layer that have lines to cover the base layer of the sig...I can't do that in GIMP as I really admire it.But uh...this time...to me the 2nd sig...that effect or whatever you call it...i think you've over done it...Oh...and the text...I some of your sigs using the text that are in the 2nd and 3rd sig...so umm...kinda common and I think you should use new ones although yupe...the text are nice.Where do you download it from?