Lets settle this once and for all...

[Hazzard]

Lets see what our Characters think.

Well I think im best since Renmiri says so oh and I have big ass sword and im strong, and I talk quite good man! Yeah im cool, Better than Balthier

I think I am good as My voice sounds very sophisticated and my clothing is so much better and old-fashioned, just like my gun. And im very helpful and careing too. So thats why you should pick me.

Thats the gist of it. thats the characters plea to you.

I don't think so? That's you just being a bit too sarcastic .

Here's what they should be like.

Basch - Loyal, never one to retaliate with bitterness in the heart. I am kind, you can always count on me. Never did I abandon my knightly vows, I care for the people of Dalmasca, and for Lady Ashe.

Balthier - The leading man I like to call myself. Travelling the skies of Ivalice as a sky pirate with my partner Fran, life is never dull! I have also been seen as a charmer.

I'm really torn betwixt the two of them
But i picked Balthier because he's posh!

If Basch had more lines and a bit more charisma like Auron, then I would go for him.