He's not personally attacking you. He's calling you out on having an invalid argument. His point is that Vaan and Penelo don't forget their motivations after certain points in the game (and I'm still waiting to hear why you think this is the case), and anyone who has actually played the game without prejudice can see that. If anything, you're the one resorting to personal attacks. I haven't once seen him say anything that amounted to "you don't know what you're talking about," yet that's exactly what you just said of him. Funny that you're ignoring his points and throwing around fancy Philosophy 101 debate words while he is actually presenting a viable argument. If you know so much, prove it instead of whining that he's picking on you when he isn't.Originally Posted by Renmiri
Blaming gamers for XII's poor story telling is not owning
I respect Wolf Kano's and your points, Cap'n Basch in spite of his gorgeous name (Bash!!!!) is just a weak debater that resorts to AD HOMINEN attacks when he sees his pet game offended. He knows nothing of story telling theory yet he tries to put me down pretending he knows. Won't fly, I have several classes on it under my belt.
He would do better to discuss XII story telling on it's merits, not on my and any other people's "flaws" because we don't love it.
Reply With Quote