So much for trying before saying it sucks, eh? I think perhaps some of you may have misunderstood the rules a little. From what I got out of it, you can still reveal your role or ask people to vote with you, you just have to do it publicly in the Mafia thread, which opens for new ways to lay your strategy. Not much different the from last time, except there's just no talking outside the thread, which could be interesting. I'm willing to at least test it out, and so should you(!), and then for the next Mafia game we can pick whichever method proved to be the best. Let's have fun imho.