Round 3 Part 2 - Team 3 (Team 3SD)

[BG-57]

Here's the third draft of the summary. Green text has been altered:

After careful consideration Team 3SD has selected Candidate #3 as our choice for Cid's Knight.

Several candidates were eliminated early from consideration, mainly due to issues with spamming (#2) or personality conflicts (#4).

While we feel that the remaining candidates all could bring some real benefits to the site, Candidate #3 stood out as bringing the best qualities and the least disadvantages.

This well respected candidate has been active for a number of years, and has a reputation for being helpful. We feel these are important qualities for a Cid's Knight to possess, although popularity and friendliness can also be important, albeit secondary, qualities.

Candidate #3 seems to be a well-rounded and safe choice for ck, his/her positive aspects outweigh his negative aspects and it’s easy to see how he/she would benefit the community. Three also holds a strong advantage over all the other candidates in several aspects including history, activity, personality and community spirit.

Though it is true three only posts in the gaming forums, this flaw can be applied to candidates one and four who only post in the general forums.