Mafia X: Harry Potter and the LYNCHER WINS HURRAY! oh and town beat mafia I s'pose

[[M] Mom – Host]

I know. But what would you do if we did vote for you? If all of us did? Huh?

I wouldn't count the votes, and nothing would really happen. Except I would become ANGRY. >:O

[[M] Dee]

I added why Crabbe role claim was stupid. and Im the one who got him to say it.

1. It was totally obvious to everyone why it was stupid.
2. I think he was feeling the pressure from the votes that were quickly piling up on him. Funny how fast that happened.

[[M] Al - Biker Dad]

Luna: I questioned Crabbe and Dumbledore. While I didn't get much out of either of them, some people have done far less than that.

Harry: Would you turn into the Hulk?

At the moment, I'm torn between Sirius and Crabbe. I believe Sirius should have gone for one of the people who jumped to save her. Then we would have got rid of Ginny today, because we would have thought she was Mafia. Which would have been bad, but if he had have killed a Townie, people would have thought Ginny was good, which she was.
I'll get to Crabbe later.

[[M] Mom – Host]

Vincent Crabbe (3): Buckbeak, Remus Lupin, Sirius Black, Luna Lovegood, Severus Snape, Dudley Dursley
Ron Weasley (1): Vincent Crabbe
Moaning Myrtle (1): Ron Weasley
Cho Chang (1): Draco Malfoy
Sirius Black (0): Vincent Crabbe
Mr. Filch (0): Remus Lupin, Buckbeak
Dudley Dursley (0): Voldemort

A good chunk of people still haven't voted. HARRY SMASH. 13 hours and 15 minutes!

[[M] Caprica]

Alright, so quite a bit seems to have transpired.

Here's my problem(s) with Crabbe.

a)You were very adamant about keeping your role secret, and then all of a sudden gave it up under pressure, though still quite easily in my mind. It just doesn't make sense to me unless you fed us a fake role.

b)While that may have been a legit roleclaim, the "pm" was laughable. There's hardly any information to go with your role - either you had trouble coming up with things, or the mods gave you a terribly uninteresting yet somewhat useful role.

c)Thirdly, you used the fact that Sirius has an unusual role to thus legitimize your unusual role. Not bad in and of itself, but we (and by we, I mean I) still don't believe Sirius 100%. (Also sort of an uninteresting role if it's just as he describes it.)

The whole problem with this mess is that it's still not super suspicious. Moreso than others, yes, but that doesn't necessarily make you scum.

What worries me are the inactives who can avoid all this scrutiny. They have the benefits of both being near invisible and don't give any reason to vote for them. I wish we could take a stab at them, but that's really hard right now, especially the way Crabbe came out swinging.

Sirius, you're still on MY list even though killing Ginny would have been a stupid mafia move. At the same time, in your situation, I don't think I would have swung that way either.

The only other person who has me going right now, and has been brought up by a few of you, is our good friend Dumbledore. Lots of activity but very little information. I'll take my quality over quantity.

But that's also me looking really hard for a lead.

OH! And I didn't like how Tonks came out so quickly to support Crabbe. I think there's a very high possibility that they're either both scum, or she knows he's not so that she can clear her name by clearing his. Once again, a bit of a stretch, but I'm looking for things to go on.

[[M] Caprica]

So I'm going to withhold my vote, yet again, for now, but I hope there's some activity while I'm sleeping so there's some good reading to wake up to. (Not too much, mind you - I don't wake up that early.)

[[M] Dee]

Iunno if I'll be back or not so I'll just put my vote back.

##Vote: Vincent Crabbe

[[M] Gaius]

Mafia's hurting my head. I'm voting this way just in case I don't get back to change my vote tomorrow morning.

##Vote: Vincent Crabby

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

At the moment, I'm torn between Sirius and Crabbe. I believe Sirius should have gone for one of the people who jumped to save her. Then we would have got rid of Ginny today, because we would have thought she was Mafia. Which would have been bad, but if he had have killed a Townie, people would have thought Ginny was good, which she was.
I'll get to Crabbe later.

As far as I was concerned, Ginny herself told us far more about the people who tried to save her. If Ginny flips town then we knew Voldy and Hermione aren't panicking scum, but if Voldy or Hermione flipped town then we don't learn anything about the other or Ginny.

c)Thirdly, you used the fact that Sirius has an unusual role to thus legitimize your unusual role. Not bad in and of itself, but we (and by we, I mean I) still don't believe Sirius 100%. (Also sort of an uninteresting role if it's just as he describes it.)

Ha! I agree, I woulda preferred Vanilla

Sirius, you're still on MY list even though killing Ginny would have been a stupid mafia move. At the same time, in your situation, I don't think I would have swung that way either.

I don't quite understand what you mean, if you clarify I could try and explain my thinking.

OH! And I didn't like how Tonks came out so quickly to support Crabbe. I think there's a very high possibility that they're either both scum, or she knows he's not so that she can clear her name by clearing his. Once again, a bit of a stretch, but I'm looking for things to go on.

I missed that. I'm going to go back and read through Tonks' posts now.

[[M] Felix]

Unfortunately, I'm not certain I'll be on in time tomorrow, either.

My main suspicion lies with Vincent Crabbe, at the moment, as he is the one trying to get us against Ron. For what reason, I am not certain. In case I do not get on tomorrow:

##Vote: Vincent Crabbe

[[M] Trevor - Gay Dad]

Actually, I have contributed a bit. Do you forget me so fast, Luna?

Anyway, out of Crabbe and Sirius, I'm not sure which one sets off my scumdar the most, but I'm also looking out for the inactives, Voldemort, and Ron. Inactives because...well, they're inactive, and it could mean something, but it also might mean nothing too big. Voldemort because he just seems so quick to get defensive. Ron because if the Shrink really is a shrink and he's telling the truth, Ron could be very, very dangerous to the town.

There's my :twocents:

[[M] Trevor - Gay Dad]

Ron is also a question because of his posting style...He seems awfully...I dunno, laidback. As soon as we all heard "omg he's insane!" and we were like 'oh ok boss" then he started to lay low.

Then again, it's only day 2 and so it may not mean anything, but since it's nearing the end of day two...

I would watch out for him, really.

[[M] Al - Biker Dad]

Not true, Sirius. Mafia don't care who die, as long as it's town. Killing Ginny revealed nothing. Hermione could still be Mafia, but just toying with Town in order to confuse us. Because she jumped to Ginny's defense, we immediately think Pro-Town. Same goes for Voldy.
Although, this still leaves the mystery of who killed the Godfather.

[[M] Caprica]

Alright, so I lied - I didn't mean to, but I got a phone call as I was laying down and this is so addicting I had to check it again.

I guess with the whole killing Ginny thing, if you wanted to find out what she was, we could've done that today, but that was poor thinking on my part - I keep forgetting that if your claim is correct, you HAD to kill someone, so at least voting for her was based in some logic - anyone else would have been even more of a swing in the dark. So I don't think I nearly suspect you as much as I did initially. Also, I'll be the first to admit, the Tonks thing is a pretty big stretch. There were three posts in a row that I thought were somewhat defensive, but looking back again, the first one really got me, but even the second time didn't seem so bad. Like I said, looking for anything, really.

If Crabbe really is a shrink (which I'm still having trouble believing) then we might have a problem on our hands with Ron - but crazy is much better than guilty. I'm trying to imagine an insane mafia role - I'm sure there are obvious ones and I'm just not thinking well right now. At the same time, we don't need an insane cop wandering around, but that will do much less harm than other roles for the time being.

Alright, bedtime for real now.

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

Not true, Sirius. Mafia don't care who die, as long as it's town. Killing Ginny revealed nothing. Hermione could still be Mafia, but just toying with Town in order to confuse us. Because she jumped to Ginny's defense, we immediately think Pro-Town. Same goes for Voldy.
Although, this still leaves the mystery of who killed the Godfather.

I never said they weren't possible scum, I said they weren't "panicking scum". As in "OH CRAP! OUR TEAMATE GINNY IS GONNA DIE! *Fixes*" We know this scenario cannot have happened for either player because Ginny isn't scum, therefore the Ginny kill teaches us more then a Ginny Supporter kill.