Mafia X: Harry Potter and the LYNCHER WINS HURRAY! oh and town beat mafia I s'pose

[[M] Gaius]

Myrtle, while I think Dudley is very suspicious along with a few others of you, I have fully intended to vote for you since "yesterday".

If you were a vanilla townie this whole time, what was up with your thousands of roleclaims?

[[M] Felix]

Pettigrew:

There is little reason to believe that she is the last Mafia... We still are not certain if there is a second Mafia or not. There IS a possibility of a Vig, because of the Mafia killings, but there is no way to rule out a second Mafia yet.

Besides, what makes you think Myrtle is the last Mafia? There are still 13 players and any of them could be Mafia. Could you please explain your reasoning on this?

[[M] Aaron]

Me being ridiculous, I apologise whole heartedly, I honestly do.
But Voldemort Dudley's incriminating evidence is piling up, and you can see I'm contributing well now.

[[M] Dee]

You do make a good point about Dudley, which makes me want to vote him even more....but I'm still not sure. Just because you stopped doesn't change the fact that it happened. Why would any townie do that kind of damage to the town?

[[M] Aaron]

Pettigrew:

There is little reason to believe that she is the last Mafia... We still are not certain if there is a second Mafia or not. There IS a possibility of a Vig, because of the Mafia killings, but there is no way to rule out a second Mafia yet.

Besides, what makes you think Myrtle is the last Mafia? There are still 13 players and any of them could be Mafia. Could you please explain your reasoning on this?

I have a strong feeling Pettigrew is the survivor, if he is then he isn't much of a threat.

[[M] Aaron]

You do make a good point about Dudley, which makes me want to vote him even more....but I'm still not sure. Just because you stopped doesn't change the fact that it happened. Why would any townie do that kind of damage to the town?

Becuase I am an asshole, I admit, I'm a dick but I want to make it up now I really do.

[[M] Aaron]

Listen I have to go very soon, please vote Dudley, becuase there is little chance I'll be back.
If I die, then when I flip Town lynch Dudley, if I survive then brilliant (hopefully a mafian didn't)

[[M] Felix]

Myrtle:

If he were the survivor, he wouldn't be claiming that someone was 'the last Mafia', would he? I'm assuming that he would want to try to get as many people as possible under suspicion... It seems strange to me. The Survivor only wins if they are the last one, right? Then they would want EVERYONE killed.

As to Dudley, I'm not sure what to think. I'll likely end up going back and re-reading his posts...

[[M] Dee]

I'll take your word for it (maybe, Iunno yet. Plenty of time for more roleclaims), but if Dudley turns out to be town you're dead

[[M] Gaius]

Myrtle, I really wouldn't mind voting for either Dudley, Pettigrew or Rubeus. But if you were town, there'd never had been really a reason to lie.

So either you are mafia, or some alternative role that depends on whether you live or die, or you just really suck at this game.

[[M] Dee]

Dobby, I think the Survivor wins if he's still alive when the game ends.

[[M] Aaron]

If Dudley is town, lynch me if you want, but I was merely defending myself against him radical claims, besides how in any way is Dudley helping us?

[[M] Gaius]

If majority sways to vote Dudley, I'll change my vote. But I'm sticking with Myrtle.

[[M] Aaron]

Myrtle, I really wouldn't mind voting for either Dudley, Pettigrew or Rubeus. But if you were town, there'd never had been really a reason to lie.

So either you are mafia, or some alternative role that depends on whether you live or die, or you just really suck at this game.

Bad I may be, but I am no mafian.

[[M] Felix]

Luna:

You may be right... but even so, if he WAS the Survivor, what reason would he have to claim Myrtle was the last Mafia?