Mafia X: Harry Potter and the LYNCHER WINS HURRAY! oh and town beat mafia I s'pose

[[M] Aaron]

Luna is barely online enough as it is, for all we know we are all town and Luna,Dobby and Dumbledore are mafia!

[[M] Mike - Funny Dad]

Well of course it might also be that Hagrids story is just a try to find anything convincing about anyone an he is not at all scum.

Remus is right, we haven´t heard anything from Luna for some time and Dumbledores posts are almost as unhelpful as Peters. I maybe was a bit quick with my vote on Hagger but I´m still noch taking it back right now.
We´re all a bit in the dark at the moment =/

[[M] Aaron]

I have a feeling though that Hagrid wouldn't come out with a claim like that if he was a mafia lying low.

[[M] Elize]

I haven't heard from Dobby in ages. I totally forgot about him.

[[M] Aaron]

Actually snape, investigate me tonight and tell me my role, that way we'll see if your telling the truth or not.

[[M] Mom – Host]

Have we reached a majority?

...

Are you serious?

Rubeus Hagrid (3): Voldemort, Moaning Myrtle, Mr. Filch
Severus Snape (2): Rubeus Hagrid, Remus Lupin, Moaning Myrtle
Voldemort (1): Albus Dumbledore, Moaning Myrtle

And it takes 6 to lynch.

[[M] Aaron]

Oops. xD

[[M] Elize]

He can't investigate anyone. It's completely random.

And I don't really trust you, either.

And I never actually got a scum vibe from Hagrid, but don't get me wrong, neither did I from Snape. His is just the only one that makes sense to me at the moment.

But the day isn't over yet. Hagrid's defence seems obvious, it's in his post, and Snape's as well, but I'd like to hear from everyone who isn't here.

[[M] Aaron]

I'm getting scum vibes from:

Snape
Filch
Hagrid
And Dumbledore

[[M] Aaron]

In fact...

If Filch is a paranoid Gun owner then that would be a LOT of killing roles in the game.
For so few people, two mafia, a serial killer/Vigilante AND a paranoid gun owner?

I doubt that.

[[M] Jeff - Single Dad]

I think the rest of you should know note that Snape is now much less eager for us to lynch him (now that people are actually accusing him) and that Filch, who under my theory would be a likely mafia partner, has jumped to his defense and against me.

Go back and look at his roleclaim for yourself, and then at my post. How does what I say not make sense?

And I was suspicious about Voldemort before, and I posted that. I stopped accusing him because I really don't have anything solid on him, and a pretty strong theory against Snape (and likely Filch, possibly Peter).

[[M] Al - Biker Dad]

How have I been any less eager? I've told people numerous times to do so and then they'll come for you. The only person I've been arguing with is Myrtle, because they've been acting Scummy. You haven't. I can understand where you're coming from. Myrtle just realised he had a chance to save himself and jumped on my case.

[[M] Elize]

In fact...

If Filch is a paranoid Gun owner then that would be a LOT of killing roles in the game.
For so few people, two mafia, a serial killer/Vigilante AND a paranoid gun owner?

I doubt that.

It would be, two mafia factions and a paranoid gun owner.

A third killing party wouldn't add up in the night kills.

How have I been any less eager? I've told people numerous times to do so and then they'll come for you. The only person I've been arguing with is Myrtle, because they've been acting Scummy. You haven't. I can understand where you're coming from. Myrtle just realised he had a chance to save himself and jumped on my case.

I've noticed many odd and scummy things about Myrtle and she would be the only lynch I would switch to. Reasons can be found in my previous posts, but seems fairly obvious to me.

[[M] Aaron]

Right fine, I have made my decision and won't be changing it.

##unvote: Hagrid
##Vote: Filch

Filch you are not a paranoid gun owner, and you jumped to Snapes defense very quickly.

[[M] Mike - Funny Dad]

I think the rest of you should know note that Snape is now much less eager for us to lynch him (now that people are actually accusing him) and that Filch, who under my theory would be a likely mafia partner, has jumped to his defense and against me.

Well of course I did. His story ist far more convincing than yours which implies a lot of guesswork. Seeing that his claim has already been partly proved (two times for my part).