P4 - Mafia XIX Game Thread - [Game Over] Mafia DOMINATION

[[M] Caprica]

Couldn't the Naoto Night-kill also be because the SK and Mafia both targeted her on that night?

I don't know, you will have to ask someone with more experience playing the game. I was just stating a theory, I threw it out there with the hopes that if it is true then maybe the Role Blocker might be able to at least give us a hint. Being new to the game I am just trying to come up with logical theories as to why things happen.

I would say it's a possibility.

I also think that discussing it is a waste of time because we have no way of finding out all the night actions. Pushing for discussion about it is a very scummy thing to do because there are so many things that can happen.

Also note that it exactly what Mitsuo is basing his case against me off of.

Tip: base your case using evidence from the thread, that way others can see it and form their own opinion on it. Unless of course you are an investigative role, then you roleclaim and say what you found out.

A roleclaim is when you say. This is a generic role claim formula, you might have to modify it based on what the role actually is.

[q] I am {role here} and targeted this {person here} and got {result here}[/q]

[[M] Greg - Hot Dad]

I am the punisher and targeted adachi on night two, and got jack squat for results/

happy? also, weren't there two deaths on night two? If I am supposed to be the serial killer, how can I have killed someone AND attacked Adachi?

[[M] Caprica]

Rise, by day four he really only had my posts on day one, I had nothing to do with day 2 or 3, and on day 1 he was fine with me. He HAD to have tried to night kill me and failed!

My suspicion of you was finalized when you went after Hanako so adamantly.

I very clearly stated why this was suspicious, and that is why I think you are scum.

Stop inventing reasons for me to be suspicious of you.

[[M] Greg - Hot Dad]

Rise, by day four he really only had my posts on day one, I had nothing to do with day 2 or 3, and on day 1 he was fine with me. He HAD to have tried to night kill me and failed!

My suspicion of you was finalized when you went after Hanako so adamantly.

I very clearly stated why this was suspicious, and that is why I think you are scum.

Stop inventing reasons for me to be suspicious of you.

that doesnt make any sense, WE WERE ALL AFTER HANAKO THE NIGHT BEFORE (until about ten minutes before the day ended)

[[M] Greg - Hot Dad]

So here's a question: say you guys lynch me then I flip the punisher. what would you do next?

[[M] Caprica]

I am the punisher and targeted adachi on night two, and got jack squat for results/

happy? also, weren't there two deaths on night two? If I am supposed to be the serial killer, how can I have killed someone AND attacked Adachi?

Because I think you didn't target Adachi, but killed either Morooka or Chie. Whoever you didn't kill the other killer did.

Or you are just Mafia and Souji killed the other person for some reason. (Part of his role was Orange which means it's a killing role.)

[[M] Caprica]

So here's a question: say you guys lynch me then I flip the punisher. what would you do next?

Apologize in the discussion thread, wait until day 6, hope we are not nightkilled, then continue trying to sniff out the mafia.

Also for all we know Punisher could be a mafia power role.

[[M] Greg - Hot Dad]

I am the punisher and targeted adachi on night two, and got jack squat for results/

happy? also, weren't there two deaths on night two? If I am supposed to be the serial killer, how can I have killed someone AND attacked Adachi?

Because I think you didn't target Adachi, but killed either Morooka or Chie. Whoever you didn't kill the other killer did.

Or you are just Mafia and Souji killed the other person for some reason. (Part of his role was Orange which means it's a killing role.)

Didn't they both think I was innocent? why would I attack them?

[[M] Greg - Hot Dad]

So here's a question: say you guys lynch me then I flip the punisher. what would you do next?

Apologize in the discussion thread, wait until day 6, hope we are not nightkilled, then continue trying to sniff out the mafia.

Also for all we know Punisher could be a mafia power role.

it's not, that wouldn't be fair. What you guys don't realise is as long as I'm around, that's one less person the mafia can get rid of each night.

[[M] Greg - Hot Dad]

wait, cross that out, if they can't get me they'll just go after others

[[M] Caprica]

Ah, so Souji shall be lynched today...

End votecount.

[M] Souji (5) - [M] Naoto, [M] Kashiwagi, [M] Kanji, [M] Daidara, [M] Daisuke
[M] Hanako (4) - [M] Namatame, [M] Mitsuo, [M] Nanako, [M] Adachi
[M] Rise (1) - [M] Souji
[M] Naoto (0) -
[M] Daidara (0) -
[M] Kou - (0) -
[M] Mitsuo (0) -
[M] Kanji (0) -

Here is the ending votes from day 3.

[[M] Trevor - Gay Dad]

What does the Day 3 Votes have to do with anything?

[[M] Greg - Hot Dad]

yeah I made my vote early in the day and then left and when I came back Souji was dead, so that only gave you my day 1 posts to be suspicious of.

[[M] Caprica]

What does the Day 3 Votes have to do with anything?

It's to show where my suspicion of Mitsuo came from. Because he is convinced I started to go after him for no reason, which is not the case at all.

[[M] Trevor - Gay Dad]

Oh, okay.