Dynasty Warriors Game Thread: Mafia XX GAME OVER Mafia cockblock the Cult

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

I figured Zhen Ji would go out, considering she was bustin' some balls if you get what I mean

Joking aside, I am beginning to question Guan Yu. What gets me about him is his first reaction to Zhao Yun after his explanation for his role-claim. I'll quote him here.

Lord Zhao Yun, I thank you for coming and giving us your side of the story. It is good to see that you still retain a semblance of the chivalry and bravery that made your name legendary across the land in that perverted body of yours.

Now how is lying to us any resemblence of chivalry and/or bravery? I do not get this. Does anyone feel this way, and should we persue after him?

[[M] Jeff - Single Dad]

Anyway. Have we any suspicions today or anyone we should scrutinize?

[[M] Walter - Smart Dad]

I figured Zhen Ji would go out, considering she was bustin' some balls if you get what I mean

Joking aside, I am beginning to question Guan Yu. What gets me about him is his first reaction to Zhao Yun after his explanation for his role-claim. I'll quote him here.

Lord Zhao Yun, I thank you for coming and giving us your side of the story. It is good to see that you still retain a semblance of the chivalry and bravery that made your name legendary across the land in that perverted body of yours.

Now how is lying to us any resemblence of chivalry and/or bravery? I do not get this. Does anyone feel this way, and should we persue after him?

I'm glad you pointed this out. I don't remember seeing this before. I think it's worth looking into. Or at least pushing him for more information. He hasn't really had too much to say this whole time as well as Meng Huo. That being said, it doesn't give us too much more to go on.

[[M] Elize]

I figured Zhen Ji would go out, considering she was bustin' some balls if you get what I mean

Joking aside, I am beginning to question Guan Yu. What gets me about him is his first reaction to Zhao Yun after his explanation for his role-claim. I'll quote him here.

Lord Zhao Yun, I thank you for coming and giving us your side of the story. It is good to see that you still retain a semblance of the chivalry and bravery that made your name legendary across the land in that perverted body of yours.

Now how is lying to us any resemblence of chivalry and/or bravery? I do not get this. Does anyone feel this way, and should we persue after him?

I can't believe I missed that, yes it does seem quite odd... he's always seemed a bit off to me in terms of reliability . Now that I'm finally feeling better Ima go read up on some of his posts. I'll post anything I find strange obviously. Might as well make up for my fail these past few days.

[[M] Elize]

I still think people are paying too much heed to it, but that's just me. Well, really I just don't believe Zhao Yun is a cop. For mine, he was either just joking and going along with the general silly flow of the game, Cao Cao roleclaiming governer, whoever it was doing a fake daykill and so on. If not that, then he was just lying for whatever reason. As of now, I'm giving him the benefit of the doubt and just assuming he was joking, I would rather wait for him to come in and give his side of the story before jumping to any conclusions. But yeah, mainly I just don't believe he is a cop.

At this point of the game, I do not see this as a very valid reason to give someone the benefit of a doubt... joking isn't exactly the wisest thing to do in mafia, it can very easily get you killed. I feel that either Guan Yu is very lenient or was trying to get the heat off of Zhao. I find this just a tad suspicious to say the least.

[[M] Elize]

A new dawn, a new day. FYI guys, I'm the town concubine and I can absolutely confirm that Zhang Jiao isn't as good in the hay pile as he thinks he is and that Lu Meng is a terrible tipper.

Also did anyone catch this role claim? I don't even know what the crap this role is but it seemed to go completely unnoticed.

[[M] Jeff - Single Dad]

Indeed. Especially when Zhao had been outed as lying poorly about the cop thing. So maybe he was trying, not very well, to defend a comrade?

[[M] Jeff - Single Dad]

That role was designed to be a joke I think. He was pretending to be a prostitute so he could make filthy jokes.

[[M] Joe - Army Dad]

The question I want answered is why did Yue Ying not wait to vote until she, Zhen Ji and I had a chance to really analyze the situation. Why did she vote for Jiang Wei, a common peasant, when the only thing he was guilty of was having a broken monitor?

[[M] Walter - Smart Dad]

I mean... He could just be played by a newbie? Or he's just really nice. The way I see it is why would someone roleclaim cop if they weren't? To get people to believe they knew who was scum without being pegged as scum themselves. But Zhao was scum. It would be a stupid this to joke about, espically if it came to surface that you were not a cop. So if you thought someone was joking about roleclaiming cop wouldn't you also be suspicious about said person, unless you also wanted other to NOT be suspisious? That's just how I see it.

[[M] Elize]

Hence the pink...

[[M] Walter - Smart Dad]

Indeed. Especially when Zhao had been outed as lying poorly about the cop thing. So maybe he was trying, not very well, to defend a comrade?

With this and what I just said...

##Vote: Guan Yu

[[M] Walter - Smart Dad]

He may not be guilty but I want to start the fire under his ass to get him to try to defend himself. See what he says and make more deduction about him.

[[M] Joe - Army Dad]

Indeed. Especially when Zhao had been outed as lying poorly about the cop thing. So maybe he was trying, not very well, to defend a comrade?

Were they comrades? I mean, I thought the joker role was a third party role? Neither town or mafia.

[[M] Elize]

Indeed. Especially when Zhao had been outed as lying poorly about the cop thing. So maybe he was trying, not very well, to defend a comrade?

Were they comrades? I mean, I thought the joker role was a third party role? Neither town or mafia.

I believe it is, that makes things a tad more complicated. I doubt they were comrades to be honest. Considering Zhao was 3rd party it could easily mean that Guan Yu was just being nice... Is it possible that he knew he was a jester and was trying to keep him from winning?