Dynasty Warriors Game Thread: Mafia XX GAME OVER Mafia cockblock the Cult

[[M] Walter - Smart Dad]

Indeed. Especially when Zhao had been outed as lying poorly about the cop thing. So maybe he was trying, not very well, to defend a comrade?

Were they comrades? I mean, I thought the joker role was a third party role? Neither town or mafia.

It is but he did a good enough job at jumbling everyone thoughts awry. And you would think Mafia would want someone like this around to get in the way. Or maybe they knew someone had Diao Chan's ability and they wanted to keep him above water long enough for her to use it so they could, in turn get rid of 2 town sided folk?

[[M] Jeff - Single Dad]

Indeed. Especially when Zhao had been outed as lying poorly about the cop thing. So maybe he was trying, not very well, to defend a comrade?

Were they comrades? I mean, I thought the joker role was a third party role? Neither town or mafia.

We confirmed last night that Zhao was scum. He is dead.

[[M] Gaius]

The question I want answered is why did Yue Ying not wait to vote until she, Zhen Ji and I had a chance to really analyze the situation. Why did she vote for Jiang Wei, a common peasant, when the only thing he was guilty of was having a broken monitor?

I put forth my reasons for voting Jiang Wei, and also said that I felt confident from the way Meng Huo carries himself (being quite a frequent poster in relation to Jiang) that he isn't scum.

There were also other people active who could've voted for Meng Huo to even up the ledger. SSX and Lu Meng come to mind, though I'm sure there were others too.

[[M] Elize]

Indeed. Especially when Zhao had been outed as lying poorly about the cop thing. So maybe he was trying, not very well, to defend a comrade?

Were they comrades? I mean, I thought the joker role was a third party role? Neither town or mafia.

We confirmed last night that Zhao was scum. He is dead.

Whoops... heh looked back and you're right. So the confusion that involves him being a third party is now gone. That makes things easier.

[[M] Elize]

Indeed. Especially when Zhao had been outed as lying poorly about the cop thing. So maybe he was trying, not very well, to defend a comrade?

Were they comrades? I mean, I thought the joker role was a third party role? Neither town or mafia.

We confirmed last night that Zhao was scum. He is dead.

I could've swore I just posted but... it's not there. okay copy&paste time

Heh... I looked back and re-read and you're right, he wasn't a third party member. Well that helps with the confusion a bit.

[[M] Elize]

Oh it did.... smurf it. HC can you delete the first post?

[[M] Gaius]

Should be alright as it is. What's one more post in a 26 page mafia thread? xD

[[M] Jeff - Single Dad]

The question I want answered is why did Yue Ying not wait to vote until she, Zhen Ji and I had a chance to really analyze the situation. Why did she vote for Jiang Wei, a common peasant, when the only thing he was guilty of was having a broken monitor?

I put forth my reasons for voting Jiang Wei, and also said that I felt confident from the way Meng Huo carries himself (being quite a frequent poster in relation to Jiang) that he isn't scum.

There were also other people active who could've voted for Meng Huo to even up the ledger. SSX and Lu Meng come to mind, though I'm sure there were others too.

I had voted and if I changed my vote, Meng Huo would have been lynched. Double votes, remember.

[[M] Walter - Smart Dad]

The question I want answered is why did Yue Ying not wait to vote until she, Zhen Ji and I had a chance to really analyze the situation. Why did she vote for Jiang Wei, a common peasant, when the only thing he was guilty of was having a broken monitor?

I put forth my reasons for voting Jiang Wei, and also said that I felt confident from the way Meng Huo carries himself (being quite a frequent poster in relation to Jiang) that he isn't scum.

There were also other people active who could've voted for Meng Huo to even up the ledger. SSX and Lu Meng come to mind, though I'm sure there were others too.

I was going to vote but by the time I could the thread was closed That's what i get for walking away for 5 minutes xD

[[M] Gaius]

I had voted and if I changed my vote, Meng Huo would have been lynched. Double votes, remember.

My bad. Of course

[[M] Helo]

Well well well! This looks like it is going to be an entertaining day indeed. I fully anticipate I shall be stroking my magnificent beard gleefully during the entire day.

I had been thinking long and hard about how I was going to play this, but seeing as plenty of you seem so intent on making fools of yourselves, I think I shall go big right off the bat!

First of all, I would like to clarify that Lord Lu Meng is indeed correct, the concubine roleclaim was nothing but a joke in order for me to have a little fun with the game. I actually wanted to post it at the end of the first day when all the random roleclaims were happening, but Zhuge Liang closed the thread as I was in the process of writing it. Seemed too much fun to not go with it on day 2, though. There's nothing to that angle.

Secondly, I do find it both amusing and telling that all of you so far attempting to question my credibilty are doing it with extremely select posts and pieces of posts that you can twist to look bad, and totally ignore other, much more informative posts. That being said, suck on this:

I am the cop. Or, if you want the title given to me in my role PM, Scout. I am able to investigate one player each night and get a PM back that says whether they are innocent or guilty. I'm sure you'd all just get very confused and angry if I were to leave it at that, and, seeing as you all so far seem to be so intent on leaving out my own contributions to the game that don't help you paint me as scum, let me give you all a little recap!

First of all, I think you will find that from the moment Zhao Yun claimed cop, I was the only player who consistently refused to even give his idea any sort of credibility. I did not accept the theory that he was an Insane or Paranoid cop. I flat out stated in a later post that he was not any kind of cop. I knew this from the moment he posted his claim because as I have already said, *I* am the cop and my role PM was Scout. Given that all previous revealed roles had a DW flavour, this was pretty much a clear indication that he was not to me.

Want more reasoning? Night 1, I investigated Cao Cao, and he turned up innocent. Go back and check, and you'll note that I was not one of the players who decided to waste a vote on him on day 2, before or after his governor claim. I knew he was innocent already. As I have already stated, I merely wanted to give him the benefit of the doubt, because there were a couple of joke roleclaims on the first day, and I wanted to see what he would do. Instead of saying "yes I was joking", he tried to pull what he did, and that's when I knew. And again, I challenge any of you to go back and find any post I have made trying to defend him other than me waiting to see if he was joking or not. It does not exist. I posted before anyone else that he was either scum or a jester. And I, unlike the rest, had actual evidence backing up my claims, which i've now provided.

And just to heat things up a little more, on night 2, I investigated Xiahou Dun. He's guilty as sin. Don't believe me?

##vote Xiahou Dun. And that is final, I will not change it from this point on.

For now, that's all I'm going to say. Enjoy yourselves, and remember, beardjobs are on special offer! Get them while I'm still alive.

[[M] Elize]

So for the reasons I stated earlier... I think ima go after Guan Yu until he gives a valid reason for me to NOT vote for him.

##vote: [M] Guan Yu

[[M] Elize]

Whoa... okay one second, leme read this post first
unvote: guan yu

[[M] Gaius]

I was going to vote but by the time I could the thread was closed That's what i get for walking away for 5 minutes xD

Walking away when the we all knew the day was coming to an end? Zhuge was telling us 4 minutes remaining, 2 minutes, 10 minute extension. You were here the whole time through that. And you're away from the computer for the 2 minutes in between Sun Ce asking you to vote Meng Huo and Zhuge ending the day?

[[M] Gaius]

oh hey Guan Yu posted. pause bitch fight.