Anniversary Mafia Game Thread - The Final Day

[[M] Mike - Funny Dad]

Also Stiltz: If you want to call me a diptrout for failing to check who besides Faris wanted me to save Cid, fair enough, but if you get to call me a diptrout for calling Spy "typically a mafia-aligned role" when the only role list I had that wasn't blocked called it verbatim "typically a mafia-aligned role," then I get to call you a horse-feltcher for that ridiculous pom-pom on your head.

[[M] Mike - Funny Dad]

Do you think you were being played? That would make Faris scum.

Agreed that if I was played (and as a first-time player I'd be an obvious person to try to fool) that would make Faris scum, but I don't buy Setzer's evasion.

[[M] D'Anna]

Hmm. I'll think on this some more. I may switch my vote to Relm before the day is out. Rikku's scum accusation from Refia has me curious, but it may be able to wait until we have more information (if Rikku ever posts. Sigh.).

I don't think Rikku's coming. Voting out a complete inactive won't hurt us as bad, but Rikku painted a big target on herself on Day 1 and I wouldn't expect a mafia to do that.

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

As guilty as I look because of my inability to handle this role, which according to the mafia wiki is called an amnesiac cop, doesn't mean I am, and if you lynch me you are going to find this out tonight. I would like to contribute more than my ineffectual ability especially if this is my last day to play but sadly, I'm quite befuddled. I've been thinking a lot about Faris' tracking myself, obviously from earlier post when I was trying to fit the no results piece of the puzzle with the bulletproof townie being night killed piece. However, I can't really see the Mafia sacrificing their poisoner when it gives them the opportunity to take two townies out every other night, so if Faris was scum why would she sell out her partner? I know that scum will sometimes sell out one of their own to keep town off their trail, but why one that allowed you the ability to take out more townies? It doesn't make sense to me at all.

Also I need to get rid of my self vote:

##Vote: [M] Setzer

You ask why the mafia hasn't taken me out yet but I think the answer is pretty obvious: Why waste a night kill on me when you can point out my ineffectualness as a reason for town to lynch me?

[[M] D'Anna]

Any reason for Setzer other than self-preservation?

You say the Mafia Wiki calls it Amnesiac Cop. But what do you call it?

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

Why are you asking me to be very specific about what my role is called? You did this to Yuffie yesterday too and she's dead now. In the very first Mafia game I played there was serial killer role that allowed that player to kill anyone who divulged their specific role name. This condition on killing could explain away why there was only 1 kill on nights 1 and 3 seeing as nobody divulged there roles on day 1 and day 3 was spent mourning Quina. I am not going to let you save me from the lynch, only to kill me tonight:

##Unvote: Setzer
##Vote: Biggs

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

Damn it:

##Unvote: [M] Setzer
##Vote: [M] Biggs

[[M] Mike - Funny Dad]

All of the other votes have gone through without the [M] tags....why the correction?

[[M] Al - Biker Dad]

That is an interesting theory Wedge. Did Yuffie definitely reveal her role title yesterday?

And so I do not forget,

##Unvote
##Vote: Relm

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

I tend to be anal about stupid crap like that, it's a personality flaw, not a role character flaw. Yes she did, she not only stated what her role was she posted verbatim what her role pm was.

[[M] Walter - Smart Dad]

I don't think she outright claimed her role, but she did claim to have done several actions. She claimed to have killed Laguna, or at least that's what I've read, target several others in the other nights, though I'm not what she said who and what she did, I would have to look back to check, but I'm way too lazy to do that at the moment.

[[M] Dave – Stepdad]

I am only wasting your time if you are looking for more abilities. The rifle really was via Vincent. The other abilities, two, were the Stakeout which involved a description of a cereal box badge and caution tape from a store, and the Investigate which was trash-rooting. I didn't want to admit I've ran out of extra actions because I would have preferred the mafia to worry. I am the Jack of all trades.

Here is the post.

[[M] Al - Biker Dad]

Yes she did, she not only stated what her role was she posted verbatim what her role pm was.

Ah yes, I remember now. Right at the end of the day, that's where the worry of the modkill came from. And then also that post you just quoted.

It is an interesting thought, but Faris roleclaimed and she managed to make it through numerous days. Why did she survive?

[[M] D'Anna]

I ask people for the name because usually you can deduce if they are lying based on the name and the other roles that have been revealed. I was not even aware that in a past mafia game the SK needed people to divulge the full name of the role before he could kill them. That's a tough job. How would a moderator even keep track of that?

Yuffie was being wishy washy about her role which is why I pressed her further for the name. Sometimes I can spot a phony baloney role name given the details about what actions they took.

[[M] Walter - Smart Dad]

I am only wasting your time if you are looking for more abilities. The rifle really was via Vincent. The other abilities, two, were the Stakeout which involved a description of a cereal box badge and caution tape from a store, and the Investigate which was trash-rooting. I didn't want to admit I've ran out of extra actions because I would have preferred the mafia to worry. I am the Jack of all trades.

Here is the post.

Yikes, I must have missed that, since it wasn't color coded or bolded. Sorry~