As much as I dislike The Order, I do think you're very limited in the amount of criticism you can really give without having played the game. I make racing games for a living, and there are so many people who look at videos and say "the physics look terrible". Well, they're physics. How it looks is inconsequential, it's all about how it feels. So yeah, you can look at half of The Order's content via Youtube, but you're missing out on the other half. Imagine somebody criticising a book who only read every other page.