EoFF Mafia XXVIII Game Thread - Banquet of the Voyager Witches

[FFNut]

Which is also why I reacted the way I did too. Just annoyed more than anything that something outside the thread was used to lynch me and toss Bobby under the bus too. I have no doubt she is pained too with a role claim nailing two targets.

[Fynn]

I've watched some mognets as well, but can we please not bring that into the table? It ruins the immersion of the game. Not once did Pumpkin mention those mognet messages so you really didn't have to bring it up

[FFNut]

It was brought to me. It is why I didn't bring it up too, but it is funny that it is Bobby and I that are witches, and she brought up to Karifean that we were mognetting each other.

[Fynn]

Where did she bring that up!

[FFNut]

I had that information Mognetted to me. That is the base of her searches.

[FFNut]

I found out two days ago and kept it out BTW. However it is odd those are her claims, and she is leading a lynch mob on it.

[Fynn]

Even if it was mognetted, it should not be brought up here because it casts everything in a different light and I'm sure not in a way Karifean intended

[The Summoner of Leviathan]

Sorry if you took my point the wrong way Formy it was more to Fynn and just everyone's lack of worry regarding a Pained. You can't say if someone was a Pained they lay low and then say that Pumpkin was laying low so she isn't. Seemed weird to me.

[The Summoner of Leviathan]

Rush is over.

#worstemployeeever

[Formalhaut]

You shouldn't have brought it up, but I don't think there's any harm done. People talk to each other outside the game, how scandelous. Hell, me and Mr.Carny live together. I think we can trust another to play the game fairly.

I will say though that I see no evidence of Pumpkin having any knowledge of these messages, so it is very strange you bring it up in the first place.

[Fynn]

Pumpkin didn't use the mognetting as reasoning for her targetting you - she used actual arguments based on what you're saying within the thread to point out flaws in your reasoning and behavior. If anything, you bringing the mognets up here proves more than anything that you don't have a clear conscience, since it looks like you're trying to fall back on something that shouldn't even be a part of the game in order to justify Pumpkin opting to vote for you.

I know for a fact that Pumpkin isn't the Pained because I got the information on who the Pained is through my night skill. Of course I can't reveal who they are for obvious reasons, but I also find it interesting how TSoL keeps pushing that idea even though it's based on pretty flimsy reasoning. In light of what Nutty revealed, I'd say that;s all pretty damning.

[The Summoner of Leviathan]

There might be a loophole in there. Pained is only active if we know their identity/ability. So if we know what player is Pained but not their identity would it activate? This is more to Karifean. Also, what if there's more than one Pained?

You just now say you know who it is so before that other than you saying she wasn't I had no more proof than that. You simply said you didn't think she was and was adamant which made me think you knew more. I pushed, you revealed you did. I say it worked well, didn't it?

[Fynn]

Except now I'll probably die tonight

[Pumpkin]

Wow, okay. This is feeling kind of personal attacky.

I mognetted Karifean YESTERDAY (not two days ago) saying I did see a lot of mognet activity and I was worried I hate cheated or something because it did raise suspicions. Karifean assured me that the witches communicate via discord chat and not via mognet, which made me feel better because otherwise I would have felt like an accidental cheater and bowed out because I didn't want to find out information outside of the thread. If I was just trying to be sneakysneaky I wouldn't have talked to Karifean about it at all.

I also was not trying to look for that, I often check the who is online to check forum activity, which I started doing long before this game.

When I was suspicious because I saw mognetting not ONCE did I bring that up in thread as a way to try and turn on you guys and I have provided considerable amounts of evidence as to why I believe you guys are the witches that had zero to do with any mognet messaging. So dismissing my whole arguments on that basis is pretty insulting, frankly, when I could have just like... not communicated with Karifean and tried to do the right thing and just tried to turn people against you some other way.

But hey, thanks for that

[Scruffington]

To be fair if I had seen someone mognetting who was playing in the game, I would assume they are likely mafia.

Obviously you're not just going to come out and say 'I saw x mognetting, they're mafia." You would come up with reasons aside from this to justify leading a lynch against them.

I do have a solution to this problem for future games.