EoFF Mafia XXVIII Game Thread - Banquet of the Voyager Witches

[Scruffington]

Thanks for hosting Karifean. Sorry that the game didn't turn out as well as I'd have liked. My role was extremely hard with 3 people having truths that directly linked to me.

I wanted to keep things interesting even after Nutty exposed TSoL, but apparently he would rather throw me under the bus to give himself another day in the game.

[The Summoner of Leviathan]

Well okay then

I'm convinced Pumpkin isn't lying since her truth aligns well with mine and there would literally be no point to the Cynic if that statement wasn't true. And since Scruff came out as a Cynic anyway, there's no doubt that he'll come up as such in the game anyway.

The only thing I'm worried about at this point is whether the rest of the thing Bobby said are true. Sure, we'll know after Scruff is lynched by seeing if the game has ended or not, but what if he had some ability he's not telling us about that might allow him to turn this around before we get to lynch him on day 4 should the game not end with the Cynic's death?

The only missing truth was Nutty's and that was about being two Pained. Unless Pumpkin is a Pained, then once Scruff is gone, we win. If Scruff is right, then you get rid of me.

I admitted to my ability and told you what it can do and offered it. You have until the end of the night to decide if you want to meet my terms. If not, then I assume you will all lynch me tomorrow and I will keep whatever I find out to myself.

I mean unless Scruff wants to share his ability with the rest of us and he can offer a better deal. Because if I am the only obstacle to your victory as he is claiming, then why doesn't he share his ability?

See, I get what you mean and I sure as hell find your reasoning way more convincing than Scruff's, but why do you use your ability as leverage? You have the upper hand, Scruff will probably get lynched tomorrow, and that should be the end of the game if you're telling the truth. So why don't you just use your ability to benefit us all even if we can't all give you a guarantee that you won't be lynched tomorrow?

Because I am human and spiteful (in the normal sense not in the game terms) and tired. I wouldn't have actually done it (probably?). Just everyone kinda ignored it so yeah was putting it out there aggressively.

Scruff, as the Witch of the Truth I was never on your side. If I wasn't putting you under the bus now, I would have done it eventually. I was next after Nutty, so my only leverage was the Cynic. Hey, if my win condition didn't involve you dying then I would have acted differently.

[Fynn]

Except it makes sense for him to do it if his actual goal is to sabotage the other witches


When you think about it, it does make sense that there be an actual opposite of the cynic


Even if Bobby's lying, we can still get him the next day, so it kind of goes without saying that Scruff should be lynched on the next day. But I can't help but still be kind of suspicious because of all that holding his ability hostage thing

[The Summoner of Leviathan]

Like I said, I was being a petty human. I can't be a witch all of the time

Honestly, I will share my ability. Not like I can nightkill. *twiddle thumbs*

[Fynn]

You know what would make this game REALLY interesting right now?

If I outed the Pained

[Pumpkin]

You know what would make this game REALLY interesting right now?

If I outed the Pained

OH MY GOSH

[The Summoner of Leviathan]

There is more than one. Plus by you knowing who they are and outing them you just line them up for lynching. Plus there is a second one somewhere. There are two.

I wonder if Karifean has something else up his sleeve that we didn't know about?

[Scruffington]

Because I am human and spiteful (in the normal sense not in the game terms) and tired. I wouldn't have actually done it (probably?). Just everyone kinda ignored it so yeah was putting it out there aggressively.

Scruff, as the Witch of the Truth I was never on your side. If I wasn't putting you under the bus now, I would have done it eventually. I was next after Nutty, so my only leverage was the Cynic. Hey, if my win condition didn't involve you dying then I would have acted differently.

Except you're not doing it because of your win condition now.

You're doing it because Nutty outed you and you were next on the chopping block. You're going to die either way, you just decided that you were going to expose me in order to keep yourself alive for one more day.

Well congrats dude. You're going to live for another day. And just like how Nutty revealed mafia (which is poor form), you've done the exact same thing to me.

Thanks.

[Pumpkin]

Yeah I don't feel like having a lynch line. I would feel bad if I had to kill off half of the group

[The Summoner of Leviathan]

Yeah I don't feel like having a lynch line. I would feel bad if I had to kill off half of the group

Yeah it would just be awkward then.

[The Summoner of Leviathan]

FYI there is like 11 hours before the night is done. So who do you want my skill to be used on?

[Fynn]

I personally don't think it really matters at this point

[The Summoner of Leviathan]

I'm bad at math, I forgot the day ended early.

Come in Fynn, not you too!

There are a bunch of unknown abilities in play and Formy, Carby, and Laddy haven't said boo!

[Fynn]

I'm just saying that if the game will end on the next day, it really doesn't matter who you use your ability on. So I say just go for whoever you're most curious about and let's get the night over with

[The Summoner of Leviathan]

But a deal is a deal. We haven't seen from Formy, Carny, or Laddy yet.

I wonder if it is my night ability that is holding off the next day?