So I was writing up an answer to Dee's question and ended up just writing a whole list of my current reads. I'd appreciate if others shared their thoughts, and please, don't hesitate to point out flaws in my reasoning. We're getting to the point where I'd rather people did not let off-base reasoning go through unchecked.

Aaron
Conduct: Scum
Evidence: (Town)

I'm aware this is some of my bias but I really don't like people getting hung up on players like Roslin and Caprica. Being assertive without having much to back it up is not an indicator of Mafia, and in fact, that is an argument I've seen scum make time and time again. Also, the way he jumped into the Roslin lynch today just after Felix did felt like opportunism (or maybe even planned between them). I do give him some credit in evidence though, for publicly accusing Athena in late Day 1. Though if there actually are two scumteams that actually doesn't mean a whole lot.

Felix
Conduct: Scum (possibly just busy Town)
Evidence: Neutral

Seems to me like most of what Felix is doing is casting doubt on the information we have rather than trying to use it for reasoning, which would be a little unproductive as town. Also his attempt at implying that Roslin might have more information than she's letting on was the same thing Athena did Day 1. Also, this may be due to time issues, but he hasn't really involved himself in major discussions much. Still, I'm hesitant to accuse him over this, since I could also see him just being a Town too busy to play more actively.

Dee
Conduct: Town
Evidence: Scum

As I've previously stated, the way Dee defended herself - not by making a desperate move but by inviting discourse and encouraging actually thinking about how to proceed later on - felt pretty towny to me. Slightly offset by how deeply she focused on a mistake of mine, but eh, I can easily see a Town doing that. Though the argument that if she were innocent the Mafia shouldn't have had much of a reason to target Roslin is not one without its merits, either.

Adama
Conduct: Town
Evidence: Neutral

Adama's been playing a relatively normal Town game so far, as far as I'm concerned. Involved in the happenings, with some convictions, but willing to be proven wrong. I do know Roslin had some suspicions about him though I didn't quite follow, could you explain that a bit more Roslin, or is it already obsolete? As for evidence, not really anything swinging it either way really, except that since he's been more or less siding with Dee on Day 2, if she's scum he likely is her partner.

Roslin
Conduct: Town
Evidence: Town

Nothing so far in Roslin's conduct has actually made me think she's scum. She's been aggressively pulling people out of their comfort zones and getting as much information circling as possible. People like to say that's what Mafia do to confuse things, but really in my experience it's more often the other way round, especially in EoFF games so far - Mafia are usually not the ones aggressively leading the charge. And it's also just gonna get you investigated and tracked to hell and back and yet nobody has come forward with a Guilty on her. Also of course gets Town evidence by virtue of being protected by Tigh in a night with no Town deaths.

Tigh
Conduct: Neutral
Evidence: TOWN

Not much to say on conduct since he's been pretty quiet overall, on the first two days at least. Staying out of major confrontations reads more on the scummy side but the posts he did make read more towny, so it kinda cancels out. But in the end it's all offset by the fact that, well, he's the uncontested doc right now. Is there really anything else to say?

Helo
Conduct: N/A
Evidence: N/A

Speaks for itself, I think...

So yeah, that's what I got so far. My biggest suspicions are Aaron and Felix right now. If you guys are willing on giving up this stalemate and voting off one of these two I'd be delighted. If not, well, then I'll just have to resolve Overtime once we get to it.

##Vote: Aaron