Well that was all very incriminating.
##Unvote: Moaning Myrtle
##Vote: Severus Snape
Well that was all very incriminating.
##Unvote: Moaning Myrtle
##Vote: Severus Snape
Luna: Actually, I gave Dudders role second. I did them in the order I got them. I actually had a whole host of Puns lined up, but I decided against it.
I guess I'm just remembering wrong, then.
More puns would be more awesome.
Severus Snape (3): Rubeus Hagrid, Remus Lupin, Luna Lovegood,Moaning Myrtle
Mr. Filch (3): Moaning Myrtle, Peter Pettigrew, Voldemort
Moaning Myrtle (0):Luna Lovegood
Voldemort (0):Albus Dumbledore,Moaning Myrtle
Rubeus Hagrid (0):Mr. Filch,Voldemort,Moaning Myrtle
1 hour and 19 minutes.
Harry: It's 3 for Filch as well. Voldy voted for him.
Snape voters, I implore you to vote for Filch instead. Why? Because he obviously has a role that is valuable to the mafia. That is why it was suggested that "no one kill him because he'd just kill you if you target him." Pettigrew as "Jester" is fishy as well. "Don't kill him, he'd win."
He would have thrown a townie in with the results in case things went wrong, probably. If we're so certain he's mafia, why don't we go after him first? It doesn't make any sense not to.
Luna: Well wouldn't that Townie be Pettigrew, seeing as how he isn't a Jester, because he said so?
Hm, how did I lose that? Oh well, fixed.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Severus Snape
hehehehehehehehehehehehehehehehe.
a 3-3 tie with 64 minutes to go!
Yeah, could be. But this is a possible scenario if you really are mafia:
You DID get Filch's result night two. From Ron, the Mafia Cop. Ron died as a result, and one of the kills didn't go off like it was supposed to, or the other killing faction aimed at Ron. You sacrificed your Godfather to gain the town's trust, and then said you got Filch's result night three, after the cop was already dead. So when Filch dies, you look innocent.
...or Filch is mafia.
...or there's something that kept you alive and you're telling the truth.
ANYTHING could have happened. But if the town is so certain you're lying scum, then they should lynch you first is what I think.
Personally, I can't think of any reason why you would still be alive.
Majority is 6 right?
Yes, but seeing as Snape and Filch aren't voting, for obvious reasons, we can't get that, even when you and Dobby vote.
Dumbledore: Yep.
They can't just not vote though.
I've done it countless times.
It has happened before. Plus, voting without reason would just damn them once and for all.
But voting for Myrtle I would tolerate. xD
Not voting could, too :p
Vote filch not Snape! :bigsmile:
I'm not going to Vote for Filch because he's innocent. I'm not going to do what others do and go, nice knowing you, *Vote self*. That just leaves a random vote which seems pointless.
I don't appreciate the sarcasm Remus. :(
That was sarcasm?
More like making fun of Myrtle's awful play... but sure... sarcasm.
He keeps making smarky remarks about me. :(
Do you mean smarmy?Is smarky a word?
Its 1337 speak for smarmy and sarcky
Well, you make it so easy.
I'm just going to ignore it then.
Sarcky?
...so now we wait...until someone else comes along and breaks the tie...:eep:
It'll have to happen eventually.
I dunno, I'm exhausted. xDQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Harry Potter
Literally gonna collapse soon.
Oh gods sake.
##Unvote: Filch
##Vote: Snape
Is there a slap emoticon?
I'm still not certain what to think... but I do know that even if Snape is right, the Mafia now knows that Filch is the Gun Owner and will not target him... so:
##Vote: Filch
Why?
Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Voldemort
http://img167.imageshack.us/img167/2...1fdf143pn5.gif
Because I lynched Snape?
moved post to next page.
Oops.
##Unvote: Snape
##Vote: Filch
I'll post it again, new page and such.
Dobby: Wouldn't the mafia especially want to target Filch? They can't nightkill him.
If there is a chance I'm wrong, I want the one that can't die to live.
Mr. Filch (4): Dobby, Peter Pettigrew, Voldemort, Moaning Myrtle
Severus Snape (3): Rubeus Hagrid, Remus Lupin, Luna Lovegood,Moaning Myrtle
Moaning Myrtle (0):Luna Lovegood
Voldemort (0):Albus Dumbledore,Moaning Myrtle
Rubeus Hagrid (0):Mr. Filch,Voldemort,Moaning Myrtle
with 35 minutes remaining.
Lupin:
I suppose that would be true... but I am still a bit confused as to how Snape would know Filch was the Gun Owner if he didn't actually investigate him... and Filch just kinda goes along with it, no questions asked... If Snape did actually investigate him, by all rights, he should be dead... As I have stated before, I'm fairly confused at the moment, but I am still trying to think things through...
How much longer?
Gotta go, good luck!
I'm just warning that if we lynch Filch, the mafia would almost certainly kill Snape, while they wouldn't be able to do it the other way around.
Assuming Snape spoke the truth(worst case scenario).
Snape is my highest suspect at this point. If Filch and Peter are also mafia, then they would be on the same mafia team. But that's a lot more mafia for one team, with so many mafia already dead. I think at least one of them won't be mafia (most likely Peter, but also possibly Filch), which is why lynching Snape is the much better choice at this point. Either way, they definitely need to still be considered.
But what about the second? Well, they could either all be dead (which is possible), or there's another one or two still out there. I'm not as sure of anything on this point, but possible suspects I have for the second mafia:
-Myrtle (wouldn't that be funny)
-Remus (he was defensive of Dudley at first, but did vote for him at the end when it was obvious Dudley was going to be lynched. He also supported me way more quickly than the rest of you people when I pointed to Snape, which either means he's smarter than you all and understood my theory quicker, or he wants the other mafia team eliminated. A bit thin at this point, but something to consider)
I don't really have enough on Dumbledore to say either way.
But first, Snape needs to be lynched. The rest of the above thinking is pretty moot until then.
No, because you can't make a stable vote. :pQuote:
Originally Posted by [M] Moaning Myrtle
I keep getting swayed. xD
I suggest that whatever we do, that there is a larger gap than two. If we have 5-3, Filch and Snape could, at the last minute, make it a tie and we'd have no lynch.
I don't understand. Is there something about "lynching Filch to test Snape makes no sense" that I'm missing? If Snape's lying, HE needs to be lynched. Filch doesn't actually prove anything.
Mafia won't kill Filch though, so we need to lynch him.
I'm voting Filch because they're trying to protect him, so I suspect he has a role valuable to the mafia. Same with Pettigrew. Their "roles" are "Don't kill us, you need us alive to win."Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Rubeus Hagrid
And yes Hagrid, I am smart. :)
Also, I had come to the same conclusion, but didn't want to risk saying it, with good cause, seeing the votes you got.
Lupin: Even if we made it a tie it would go to a tie-breaker.
Do ya'll think mafia mason is a possibility?
...Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Moaning Myrtle
How does that make ANY sense at all? If Snape's mafia, he's not really at risk either! And if killing Filch doesn't necessarily prove anything about Snape, then WHY would you guys try to lynch him in order to test Snape's claim? Jesus.
This town is really stupid. :( It's only by the grace of the mafia killing each other that we still have a chance.
Lupin:
Ah... I see your reasoning. I suppose it DOES make sense. The Mafia wouldn't be able to night kill Filch if he really is the gun owner... however they could easily go after Snape... Everyone already suspects both of being Mafia... if we can confirm that Snape is Mafia, we can then turn to those that he was 'investigating'...
##Unvote
##Vote: Snape
Your stupid for not understanding simple statements.
Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Rubeus Hagrid...Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Moaning Myrtle
How does that make ANY sense at all? If Snape's mafia, he's not really at risk either! And if killing Filch doesn't necessarily prove anything about Snape, then WHY would you guys try to lynch him in order to test Snape's claim? Jesus.
This town is really stupid. *shakes head* It's only by the grace of the mafia killing each other that we still have a chance.
There is also TWO mafia.
I can't believe I'm reading that either.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Rubeus Hagrid...Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Moaning Myrtle
How does that make ANY sense at all? If Snape's mafia, he's not really at risk either!
This town is really stupid. *shakes head* It's only by the grace of the mafia killing each other that we still have a chance.
If Filch really is a paranoid gun owner, Snape was right(I don't see how though, except foul play), we were wrong, and he would be a townie.
God, are you really that stupid?
Don't take a highhorse Remus, You don't constitute as clever at all.
'Sides I'm tired and going to bed now.
No offense, but that's an understatement. <3Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Rubeus Hagrid
Also, please don't flame each other.
That's just assuming Snape is Mafia, which we can't be 100% sure of until his role is revealed by Harry.
Sorry, emo-god. I got a little fed up with DD.
Won't happen again.
Whoa...way too many posts when I was typing that one. What I mean is we're just assuming Filch is mafia because we think Snape is. If we're going to lynch them both, we should make sure Snape IS mafia.
Harry's right.
Okay, but I want an agreement that either Pettigrew or Filch is being lynched tomorrow if Snape is mafia.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Luna Lovegood
##Unvote: Filch
##Vote: Snape
Can anyone think of any possible reason for Snape being alive still? That is the one thing that's making me vote him.
Severus Snape (5): Rubeus Hagrid, Remus Lupin, Luna Lovegood, Dobby, Voldemort,Moaning Myrtle
Mr. Filch (2): Peter Pettigrew, Moaning Myrtle,Dobby,Voldemort
Moaning Myrtle (0):Luna Lovegood
Voldemort (0):Albus Dumbledore,Moaning Myrtle
Rubeus Hagrid (0):Mr. Filch,Voldemort,Moaning Myrtle
16 minutes.
And I know why Snape's alive.
Because he knows how to brew the hangover cure? xD
I also know why I'm still alive.
Then tell us o_o
I'm pretty sure we're asking for trouble if we let Filch live. He probably has some nasty ability that will turn the tide for the mafia. There is a reason Snape protected him. I'm sure Snape thought about us seeing through his plans and that he would still be a target.
At least we know he's not a paranoid killer since Snape would be dead by now if he was.
I still suspect Snape so I'm fine if you guys want to go with him, I just think this is a big mistake if we don't take Filch out now. That's why I'll keep my vote.
I promised HP I wouldn't say.
If Harry mentiones it, I'd suggest you tell it before the time is up.
I said I promised him I wouldn't say.
10 minutes!
And all I said was that I know why Snape's still alive. That doesn't say anything about anything.
Calm down Snivellus, I can't read what you post while I'm writing.
@town: Mass turn to Filch?
Exactly, which is why he needs to go first. Then we actually have something to go on. If Filch is lynched, either way we're not really sure.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Luna Lovegood
Better do it quickly.
That's what I wanted. :(Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Remus Lupin
Not sure now. Get a few people to and maybe I'll change.
I'm gonna laugh at all of you who voted for me. I'll do it know though. HAHA!!!
You guys are so lucky I planned ahead and wrote up death scenes for both Snape and Filch. However, if you switch to someone else that will be fine I will just be sad. :(
Quick! Everyone change to Harry! :rolleyes2 Let that little rat-boy write his own death-scene!Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Harry Potter
You can't vote for me dammit >:O
You're so not my best friend anymore.
It's starting to freak me out a little, do you guys mind if I switch to Filch?
Snape will still get it, but I don't really want to die at some weird role.
:(Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Harry Potter
2 minutes. If you're gonna do it, do it. smurfing do it and never look back.
Hahahahahahahahaha!!! All of my posts will contain a laugh. The laugh is directed at everyone voting for me and Filch.
But not Pettigrew?
Oh thank god, I was worried.
I thought you had some weird role. But now I see both of your names, I'm fine.
Congrats everyone... you have successfully managed to turn poor Dobby's brain to mush. I can't even think right now. So many people proving their logic, so many people saying they are wrong, and I can not think straight enough to pick anything useful out of any of it... X_o
Is anyone voting for Pettigrew?
"Let's go bother Snape!"
"I am Snape, the Potions Master slash Record Keeper. And I woke up crying and I don't know why."
"Record Keeper? What is that? That's an original role! YOU MUST BE SCUM!"
"No, let me explain."
"No, let's hang him!"
"Yaaaaaaaay!"
"Wait. I can teach you how to bottle fame, brew glory, and even put a stopper in death."
"I have a better idea. Let's hang him!"
And so they did.
"I liked the part where he stopped moving."
But alas. Severus Snape was a Record Keeper, played by f f freak. Thanks for playing!
Night 5 begins now. It will go for hopefully less than 12 hours, not nearly as many night actions to get now than there were before. Those of you that have them, get them in! Let's get this over with. I'm going for a run and then eating dinner.
Severus Snape (5): Rubeus Hagrid, Remus Lupin, Luna Lovegood, Dobby, Voldemort,Moaning Myrtle
Mr. Filch (2): Peter Pettigrew, Moaning Myrtle,Dobby,Voldemort
Moaning Myrtle (0):Luna Lovegood
Voldemort (0):Albus Dumbledore,Moaning Myrtle
Rubeus Hagrid (0):Mr. Filch,Voldemort,Moaning Myrtle
Final votecount.
"Smurf you, I hate this role, and this life. Go ahead and kill me. Just see what happens."
And Peter Pettigrew forced a gun into his assailant's hand and came close to just pulling the trigger for them.
Peter Pettigrew was a Jester, played very unenthusiastically by Del Murder and Miriel. You'll get a role that you like more if you play again next game, I promise!
Day 6 begins now. Last for ~24 hours. With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch. Anything else I'm forgetting? No? Okay then!
I can't believe two experienced players couldn't bring themselves to actually post like their role. :mad2:
It was one of the main reasons I voted for Snape.
God, this game is so screwed up.
One piece of good news, it seems that there is only one mafia faction left.
I guess Filch is in the clear now. At least it wasn't completely not worth it to lynch Snape. I mean, that was a better decision than Peter.
Harry Potter and the Pure-Blood Jester?
Works for me.
Thank god we didn't lynch Filch. We at least have one confirmed townie that can't die.
Who's all still alive?
Albus Dumbledore
Dobby
Mr. Filch
Rubeus Hagrid
Luna Lovegood
Moaning Myrtle
Remus Lupin
Voldemort
Thanks Harold I can use that for a suspicion list. :aimkiss:
Everyone on that list is a suspect of mine.
Well, I ditched the idea of compiling a suspicion list for myself, because I'm really only suspicious of Myrtle.
OK, my partner... is new. Don't blame them
Snape was suspicious, wonderful qwerty or ron made a statement he did something amazing. I thought qwerty was more awesome than he was and thought maybe snape was just revealing what ron found. But if my partner payed attention at all to how snape reacted they wouldn't have pressed so hard. I'm sorry. We were wrong. But it was suspicious how his investigations fit so perfectly.
I told them to roleclaim yesterday alas they did not. You may not believe us, and I'm claiming now because well it's about time. Plus I mean 4/5 WOO I'm like so totally awesome at being this role.
I'm the Cop.
Don't get all OMG another cop role claim. Seriously go look at my posts please. It's freaking obvious.
Night One: Hagrid - innocent
NIght Two: Ron - Guilty
Night Three: Hermione - Guilty
NIght Four( the night I was gone -.-): Voldemort - Innocent
Night Five: Remus - Guilty
I investigated myself cause well, no one is suspicious on day one and had to check sanity!
Ron, oh come on he was so suspicious.
Same as ron I actually had hermy for night two then changed at the last minute to ron
Ask my partner.... he thought voldy was suspicious?
And well remus, as my partner did say he was trying to bring up that dudders wasn't suspicious and then once it seemed there was no hope, he hopped on the bandwagon. Then this past day he agreed with me really quickly. My partner things they were smart and that remus was just listening to reason. Meh whutever.
You can check my posts.
Day three, I said in public. "I think Ron is Guilty." And I kept my vote on him.
Day four I was arguing with neville a lot because I knew he couldn't be a cop. Cho didn't add up. Why would I argue so much about the cop issue eh? Also so many of my posts were directed at the cop issues. I had hermy as guilty voted and kept it. Once I outed hermy she kept bring up that I was suspicious after that. Once I said something about her she didn't like it but before that, she didn't really mention me.
Day four well I honestly can't say what my partner was thinking -.-
Day five well as I said, the snape thing WAS fishy. I wish my partner had investigated remus the night before but whutever.
And so now, you may not believe me but i'm gonna go a head and
##Vote: Remus
I implore you to vote for remus... in time though. Don't waste this day by a speed lynch. If you even believe me that is.
Albus Dumbledore - ????
Dobby - ????
Mr. Filch - paranoid gun owner
Rubeus Hagrid - cop
Luna Lovegood - seems pretty much like a townie
Moaning Myrtle - annoying
Remus Lupin - guilty
Voldemort - innocent
That's all we have left. We may be at the end of the mafia or there is someone else left. If there is I say find them. You can lynch me if you want, but I am telling the truth.
Also you all know who I am now xD Also I'm most likely dead tonight cause of this.
Oh that's just perfect, I back you up and the moment the heat would be on you, you roleclaim like this.
This game truly sucks now.
Does anyone truly believe we have 6 cops in one game?
So you knew at the Neville/Cho debacle about two mafia, and you didn't speak up? You just happily waited until they were both lynched and all the way until the endgame where you could use it on me?
Sounds legitimate to me, so I'll join you on your Remus suspicion, but I won't vote yet. I think if you don't get killed tonight, then you should definitely check out Myrtle. Myrtle seems more of a threat than Dobby, Luna, and myself.
Well, I didn't see your post Remus before I made mine. It feels nice to turn the tables onto you this time. I've been waiting to say this:
Explain yourself d00d.
Even if you aren't suspicious, I think an explanation from you would benefit us on finding the remaining scum.
I did speak up about it. I didn't know he was a lyncher but I knew he wasn't a cop. If I had pressed it, since you all bandwagoned that cho was "mafia" you think I really could have said more and not got lynched myself? You all followed paul like sheep.... again.
Albus. Don't just follow me if you doubt me though people. Look at Remus for yourselves.
Explain what? I've never behaved like scum in the least!
I've never sided with known scum, all you guys have is his roleclaim and you're eating it up like puppies.
No wonder Neville got away with it. You just post cop, use hindsight, saying that you found lot's of scum to back it up, and Bam!
Everybody turns away from you and onto me.
Wow! I never knew I was everyone! Why are you so defensive towards me? I came to you in a kind and civilized manner and I don't think "I think an explanation from you would benefit us on finding the remaining scum." Would've intimidated you so much if you're town.
And what do you mean "turns away from you?"
I meant Hagrid, but more in a general sense.
Anyone could've claimed cop, even though it's been done 5 times or so, and you are all eating it up, completely forgetting anything you might've had against Hagrid.
Last day there were 3 votes against Hagrid, not me.
Well, you still didn't respond to the "I think an explanation from you would benefit us on finding the remaining scum." and I've never been suspicious of Hagrid. But that also doesn't mean I'm not suspicious of her. Hagrid's "roleclaim" gave me a new insight on who can and cannot be scum.
You're making this too easy for me to just vote for you.
What do I need to explain? Ask me a question, then I can answer it.
I don't even think I ever had done something that needed explaining.
If you want me to comment on Hagrid, I already did. Snape had a roleclaim that was nearly proven, and we still didn't believe it.
Now Hagrid comes out with a roleclaim where the only proof is, "Because I voted for mafia", and you all buy it like that.
Well, I voted for Ron too, and Dudley, and possibly hermione as well(I'll go check).
Why would I do this if I was scum?
After Snape's death, I think Filch is pretty much a confirmed townie. Today my vote goes to Myrtle. Really this time. I'm not letting something else distract me again.
Firstly, because of how she acted before she started being "serious" and secondly, because of yesterday.
As of this post, you aren't even the tiniest suspicious that Pettigrew, Filch, and Snape are mafia. Totally clear. Not the slightest bit scummy. Voldy and Hagrid on the other hand, are WAY up there on your list.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Moaning Myrtle
Then a sudden change of heart.Quote:
Crap, sorry Voldemort I really am, I just read the beginning and you and Tonks are totally Tandem.
Forgive me? sorry I rushed to conclusion, your officially off my suspect list.
As for you Hagrid, I don't know if I should believe you or not...
....and then....WTF....now Filch is scum? Well Snape was a Record Keeper. Still think he was lying about Filch?Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Moaning Myrtle
Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Moaning Myrtle
You're awfully sure about it.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Moaning Myrtle
REALLY sure.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Moaning Myrtle
...:laugh:Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Moaning MyrtleI'm trying hard because I want to prove the roleclaims earlier have no correlation with my real role, or my intentions for the game result.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Severus Snape
Opposing the godfather by no means makes you innocent. In fact Snape himself was the one who told us who the godfather was, and you were one of many that wanted to lynch him.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Moaning Myrtle
Why Filch and not Snape, I have to ask?Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Moaning Myrtle
~~~~
...and now there's Hagrid's roleclaim o_o
...okay, I think I believe it. We have yet to actually see a genuine cop on the town's side and I don't see anyone else claiming to be one. So I think we can vote Remus.
What do you have to say Remus? What are your thoughts on Myrtle?
All I can say is that either Snape explained his role very poorly to us (with the "randomly target for investigation each night" thing), or Denmark screwed up the role description, because that being on Snape's list of roles was basically what evidence I had against him (that and he could have easily been on Ron's mafia team and knew the other Godfather). Either way, basically all of you agreed with me that it needed looking into, as everyone voted either Snape or Filch.
My partner and I were suspicious of Remus for a while (in fact, I said he was "smart" for agreeing with me last round solely so he would not kill us during the night. Hey, at least that plan worked!). I tried to quickly drop his name as suspicious at the end in case we did die and you looked back at who we (my partner and I) were suspicious of.
I investigated Voldemort... well, because it was late, I was tired, and he was on my suspicious list from the day before due to how he was acting. Once I actually thought it through, I was kicking myself. I did not investigate Snape because I felt there was easily enough to demonstrate why we should lynch him... which, apparently there was.
Notice how I mentioned Voldemort as suspicious (after Hermione) the day before I investigated him, and then after that didn't mention him at all. His investigation had cleared him.
Notice how we also didn't change our vote from Hermione even though it was obvious the town was going to and should lynch Dudley after Snape's roleclaim. This was so that if we died, you guys could look back and see who we had investigated.
Yeah, Remus is guilty. THIS one, I'm certain about. :p
Actually, I must say, I'm shocked it hasn't been blatantly obvious to people that we were the cop for the past two days now. I fully expected to be killed the night after we voted for Hermione, and every day since then has been a surprise blessing.
This is what I say, I can't say much else when someone claims cop and everyone believes him.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Remus Lupin
The only other possibility I can think of is me being a Miller.
Besides, after calculating, there is only one mafia left.
Anyone might think this is Hagrid? He could just as well be a mafia cop, going against Townies now that the other mafia faction is dead.
And yeah, I know that sounds lame, but what else am I supposed to think? That random townies start roleclaiming and pointing at people?
Well if we had no other option but a speed lynch you'd be the main suspect. I just wanted you to get yourself out of the hot zone.
Well, I can start shouting and acting like Myrtle, but I don't get how this can happen myself.
If what Hagrid is saying is true, which I believe is about an 80%, then how in the hell can I be a Vanilla Townie?
Well, I'm off to bed.
But seeing that even though nobody here ever suspected me of scum(except of course, Hagrid), you all love to jump on bandwagons, I'll probably be lynched before I wake up. Try not to, though.
Try and remember last day before any rash descisions. I thought that case was bulletproof as well.
Good night.
I'd never thought I'd be dead before Myrtle, guess the world's a strange place.
I want to hear what Dobby thinks S:
Personally, I'm not incredibly sure what to think... Myrtle seems to just kinda... go along with a lot of stuff. I'm kinda wondering why she was so eager for us to lynch Filch... I mean, she'd been saying the whole time that if we lynched Pettigrew, we lose, so it seemed like she believed Snape on that one... Here's a few things that make me suspect her:
-If she is Mafia, it would make perfect sense that she would want to lynch Filch, that way she didn't have to target him and risk killing herself.
-If Snape died in the night phase, it would be perfectly explainable as 'oh, he had a power role and the Mafia wanted him out of the way.'
I'm not too certain why the Mafia went after Pettigrew, though... we weren't really planning to lynch him, so there was no way for him to win...
As to Hagrid, I'm not certain what to think... he could be lying or he could be telling the truth. I DO know that Hagrid was saying Hermione was suspicious long before we found out that she was Mafia... so that lends a bit of credibility to his claim.
I haven't really seen Lupin say anything suspicious... mostly, he's been kinda keen on lynching Myrtle... but then again, with everything I've seen, I can kinda understand why...
Basically, I am pretty much at a loss. As of right now, I am most suspicious of Myrtle...
Prepare for a long post.
This is a normal response to the when the record keeper role was claimed. This didn't cause supision.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Remus Lupin
You were previously wanting myrtle killed based on annoyingness. But it's the right thing to do about dudders, you say. You were just stating that myrtle is annoying and can't be trusted when myrtle was the one who was suspicious. You really think we would have listened that much to DD?Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Remus Lupin
You go back to myrtle. It's your chance to save dudders. You will bandwagon with the town if they want dudders but you know, you just think myrtle is just plain annoying and needs to be out. Even if someone is annoying it doesn't mean they aren't still town. If you HAVE played much then you'll know that DD is just plain annoying. We learn to ignore him, I know I have.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Remus Lupin
Yes I agree with this even now. You all SHOULDN'T just believe me.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Remus LupinThis is a very bad reason to lynch someone. If we did that anytime anyone roleclaimed, everyone would've been dead by now.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Buckbeak
Remember Cho?
Remember the fact that we actually haven't lynched a Mafia yet?
All the Mafia kills are to be given to the Vig or serial killer.
You make another mention that you want dudders to try and save himself and you wont lynch him unless he slips up.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Remus LupinThen vote for him because of that reason, not an uncomfirmed roleclaim. But that is a very slippery road to go on.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Buckbeak
He hasn't helped the town, but he also hasn't worked against it.
That said, I want a real defence this time Dudders. I know I won't change my vote today unless he really slips up, but this is all for tomorrows lynch in my eyes.
He was just being careful. We had a shrink you never know. Look at the list of roles we've had so far. It wasn't so shocking that it COULD have been insane.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Remus Lupin
Again, myrtle is annoying we should lynch. Oh yeah i'll go with dudders is you guys need me too but I wont look at it myself even though I'm taking time to look at myrtle :/ Why not pay attention to Dudley when you can pay attention to others. He was one of the main suspects.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Remus LupinIt's not only being annoying. It's actively working against the town's ability to discuss and observe. I cannot question someone if 15 posts of her come between it. I need my mind at it's clearest with all these roleclaims.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Rubeus Hagrid
But as I said before, I will go with the town on this one. If you all want Dudley, I will go for Dudley.
Then we have you back tracking that myrtle has been better when not long before you were focusing so much attention on them.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Remus Lupin
You also finally start mentioning that dudley is suspicious to you. And a few loose reasons why. Dudders is going down so jump off the boat and join the life raft with the townies!
This is just what I saw that day. It seemed that dudley and Remus were on the same team. Dudley the Godfather and Remus a goon or other mafia role. From all the mafia games I've ever been apart of this seems to be prevalent when a mafia member is underfire. Just like other games they did a similar tactic. Remus tried to protect Dudley at first by dismissing all the claims against him. However, at the very end when it would make no difference, Remus switched his vote and voted for Dudley, likely only to avoid future suspicion.
(SPOILER)I seriously printed out the two days I missed. I think 5 pages on 50 post per page but it was like 53 when printed. I was killing trees. I had to replace my black ink and was complaining about not being able to find it xD You're hilighted pink fyi Remus :3 thought it fit you :D if anyone else wants to know. I used 4 colors, pink, light blue, dark blue and green. It's the only ones I could find xD Now that I think about it... I think the couch ate them D:
Well, we're cornered and right now, I don't think worrying about Hagrid's role claim is going to help us, because if it's true then they're going to be gone tomorrow.
We can at least try and use the information we have. I haven't seen a roleclaim with that kind of information so I'm almost positive it's legitimate. The only real suspicious aspect I see is the fact that there isn't a Snape investigation even though her role was trivial for quite some time. Well, whatever Snape is gone now anyway.
I say we lynch Myrtle and settle this once and for all and lets see if we can get any more information from the night actions tomorrow.
While I'm not trying to say you're guilty, I just find it suspicious that you release your investigative results about me the day after I had to out myself because of Myrtle... :mad:Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Rubeus Hagrid
But, I AM innocent, and the fact that you said that shows you have some legitimacy to your statement. And I was rather irritated with how Remus handled the Severus situation.
Right now, I'd have no problem voting Remus, but I'm going to hold out for more info.
I disagree. Actually, I'm starting to get the vibe that Myrtle is a townie who just can't play. I have however, been suspicious of you.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Albus Dumbledore
Myrtle's been bandwagoning though...
DAMN THIS GAME! QUITE MAKING ME CONTRADICT MYSELF!! :mad2:
Well so far Myrtle's existence is deterring us from finding the mafia. If they aren't good at helping the town I'm OK with that, but if Myrtle is town and is making us extremely suspicious then they need to be wiped.
Well, that is a true thing to say. I for my part would rather get rid of Myrtle instead of Remus although there is very good reason to believe Hagrids claim as Lupin urged the town to lynch me because this would have been the one way to get rid of me.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Albus Dumbledore
In other posts it was just the other way round, don´t know what to believe right now, but I just came home after a hard nights work and I´m setting off to bed before jumping to any conclusions or votes.
And damn you Luna for quoting all these lines from Myrtles crusade against me yesterday. I was so excited about doing this ;)
Remus Lupin (1): Rubeus Hagrid
17 hours and 39 minutes remain. I'm out of this thread.
Quick! Let's speed lynch out of spite! :rolleyes2Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Harry Potter
Hey, I've been doing my best to help and if you guys don't like my efforts then lynch another town and waste all your efforts.
##Lynch: Remus Lupin
I've been waiting to to that since the start.
P.S: Filch isn't a paranoid gun owner still, I'm certain I just wish you guys would believe me. :(
I'd like to point out there is still a possibility that Voldemort is a mafia Mason.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] VoldemortI disagree. Actually, I'm starting to get the vibe that Myrtle is a townie who just can't play. I have however, been suspicious of you.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Albus Dumbledore
Myrtle's been bandwagoning though...
DAMN THIS GAME! QUITE MAKING ME CONTRADICT MYSELF!! :mad2:
I can't believe I'm still alive. Very well Hagrid, time for some answers
Yes, I did focus on Myrtle on that day. I can't remember for certain, but I believe that Dudley was accused first by Myrtle herself, and I believed that it was a diversion, as so many before.
Dudley hadn't actually posted much at all, so my opinion on him was limited to none. I didn't mind voting for him, but I wanted to vote for Myrtle. She was annoying me to no end.
Then in the end, Myrtle said she would stop, posted in a normal fashion for about 5 or 6 posts, and therefore I said that she had been behaving a little better.
I felt no need to lynch her anymore. It wasn't until after she started to get serious that I started to notice scummy behaviour. Then came the roleclaim of Snape, everyone decided to kill Dudley, and so did I.
That isn't true, Filch, and you know it. I was against Lynching you for exactly this reason.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Mr. Filch
I will go find the many posts now. And I don't like the fact that you make up facts so that I seem like scum. :mad:
Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Remus Lupin
Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Remus Lupin
I've always acted with the town's best interest in mind. The only time I was acting selfishly, as Hagrid pointed out, was when I wanted to lynch Myrtle with all my heart.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Remus LupinI can't believe I'm reading that either.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Rubeus Hagrid...Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Moaning Myrtle
How does that make ANY sense at all? If Snape's mafia, he's not really at risk either!
This town is really stupid. *shakes head* It's only by the grace of the mafia killing each other that we still have a chance.
If Filch really is a paranoid gun owner, Snape was right(I don't see how though, except foul play), we were wrong, and he would be a townie.
I never knew you all had such a poor opinion of me. :mad:
You´re right I must have messed things up with yours and Myrtle´s posts. Sorry for that, but it was six in the morning and I was just going to bed after work ;)
And as I also said I am still for lynching Myrtle rather than you although Rubeus claim is not unthinkable.
And there lies my problem. I actually BELIEVE him.
I've been wrecking my brain trying to figure out why he would roleclaim it, but I can't actually think of a reason. If he were mafia, would he really sacrifice himself(the last mafia) to kill off one townie?
They owuld lose then anyway, as you all would lynch him the next day. It doesn't seem logical. And he doesn't seem to be insane. So how did I get a guilty reading? >.<
The only think I could think of is Miller, hardly a far stretch in this game, but wouldn't I have been told I was the Miller?
If last day was bad, this day is frying my brain.
No, its not really necessary that you have been told to be the Miller which is a theory that ist just as believeable as Haggers claim.
At such a late time in the game maybe Hagrid thought it was time to let us know his investigations because it would be a loss not to know any of his results before he dies. With also many Mafia dead it is thinkable that there´s a chance of just one ore two remaining and Rubeus is acting really selfless.
Hmmm, maybe, but I don't really think that Hagrid is lying here. It just doesn't fit.
Although the timing seems a little off, and the chances weren't that much in his favor of actually getting a guilty, I still think that Hagrid's claim is true.
Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Mr. Filch
Your such an alliance seeker its pathetic, first its Snape you cowered behind, and now he's gone so to avoid confrontation you ally with Lupin after he starts making small comments towards you.
Your all talk as well, go ahead vote me, I still don't believe your a paranoid gun owner and your just using the story so you don't get targeted.
I thought I'd bring this to peoples attention as well, just Luna conveniently siding with Sirius who was mafia.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Luna Lovegood
Why do you call it cowering behind Snape. I had enough reason to believe and defend him. More than all of you and since I not you was proved right to do so I do not think that this is an arguement you can come up with against me.
##vote: Myrtle
I have no problem in voting on you :mad2: Do you not (as a townie which of course you are) think it could be that Remus is a Miller? It is possible for me to believe so because he is right in saying that yesterday he urged the town to lynch Snape instead of me to further prove his claim. If the paranoid gun owner would have been killed during the day the mafia would have no problem in killing Snape in the night so why do it this way?
And instead of accusing people for seeking alliance or something you might as well bring in some reasoning.
I brought in reasoning, I gave you my opinion and now your throwing a fit and voting for me.
I'm not gonna lower myself by voting for you, you have little understanding about the space between Answering back, and throwing a fit.
And if you are Paranoid Vig why has there been a consistent 2 kills a night instead of the odd 3?
Also the chance of him being a Miller is small, your just really gullible.
I don't get you, Myrtle. Here is me on the chopping block, and you decide to go after Filch and Luna with no actual reason?
Doesn't even make any sense. If you'd want to change focus on someone, I would've been perfect for it.
This game is now actually hurting my head.
Because Filch is just being ridiculous.
And Filch would only kill if he's being targeted.
Snape targeted him.
Also Filch isn't being reasonable, I just think he is a mafia, full stop.
I'm going to be gone for a little while.
Myrtle has slipped up several times now, to be referenced by earlier posts, and that of Luna.
Plus, I don't like the way she keeps targeting Filch. He is pretty much confirmed now, and I don't see why suspision should even be on him. Even yesterday against all logic you kept saying that.
Therefore my vote seems evident.
##vote: Myrtle
Why is Myrtle trying to incriminate everyone?
Good one Remus, go with Filch. <_<
I'm sticking with my vote, and Voldy I'm just pointing out possibilities.
Remus Lupin (2): Rubeus Hagrid, Moaning Myrtle
Moaning Myrtle (2): Mr. Filch, Remus Lupin
6 votes to lynch, 5 hours 52 minutes remaining.
So, when its revealed I'm a vanilla townie, will you guys lynch Remus?
Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Albus Dumbledore
Albus: you've already said you believe that I am the cop. You even argued with Remus a bit, and said you believed me that he is, in fact, guilty. But now you're pushing Myrtle. Why? Why go after someone who's admittedly being stupid and dumb instead of someone who, if you believe my role, must almost certainly be mafia? And why the sudden switch away from Remus onto Myrtle?
To everyone: Remus's insistence that there is only "one last" mafia member left makes me believe there is almost certainly more. I had been thinking 1-2 more (and those two would have been Snape and Filch, but now that's out). Either way, there's apparently only one faction left (and they decided to do us a favor by killing the Jester last night).
Look back at my posts and my votings. My partner already laid everything on on why Remus is suspicious. We said that Ron and Hermione were suspicious the day after we're claiming that we investigated them, and were even the only votes (which should have raised some eyebrows). I also mentioned Voldemort as suspicious the day before I investigated him, and never after that. Everything we've done supports me being the cop. And if you accept that, the only decision for a town-supporter to make is to lynch the scum that the cop points out. Isn't that my job, after all?
This thread is dead looks like I'll need to do something controversial to revive it.
I am the super awesome Godfather with Mason powers.
Now lets discuss. :bigsmile:
Hagrid posted seconds apart. xD
I'll probably be voting Remus, Hagz, but I want to wait until it's closer to deadline.
The thing is, I don't think I can stand having Myrtle here for one more day, and just because I said that doesn't mean I've made my final decision--I haven't voted for anyone yet. It's just something to think about.
I like to keep an open mind. Yes, Sirius was mafia, but as far as I knew it was possible, and I wanted to believe that he was a townie.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Moaning MyrtleI thought I'd bring this to peoples attention as well, just Luna conveniently siding with Sirius who was mafia.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Luna Lovegood
It looks like today my vote is going to someone else YET AGAIN, but rest assured, you're next :D!
People have been saying that for the past 3 days, and I always narrowly survive.
If only you guys got the message that a vote for me, is a vote for a townie.
You are doing the absolute worst job of convincing us. All you're doing is screaming "I'm a townie, I'm a townie!" until you're blue in the face :eep:
I'm not screaming, but its hard to convince someone your a townie. :)
Just because you're a townie doesn't mean your not helping us lose with your preposterous playing style.
I'm actually contributing, it's just I'm contributing by throwing loads of facts in for you guys to decipher.
I have to convince people I'm a townie while a suggested cop has me pegged guilty.
Do you know how frustrating it is? But you don't hear me screaming and roleclaiming like an idiot.
I'm trying to figure out the truth, or whatever is closest to it. Saying the same thing over and over again doesn't help.
You call what happened yesterday facts? You're still saying that Filch isn't a PGO, how can you not believe that after what happened to Snape?Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Moaning Myrtle
I'm not screaming, I'm being quite calm actually.
I haven't got the energy to rebute that, lynch me if you want. *yawn*
3 hours and 2 minutes left! The 4 of you who haven't voted should get on that. That's Albus, Dobby, Luna, and Voldemort.
Sorry Remus, but I don't believe you. Tomorrow it's Myrtle's turn.
##Vote: Remus Lupin
Does Remus have a brother Romulus?
##Vote: Remus
Don't blame you, I suppose. Even I believe that Hagrid is a cop.
I suppose I'm a Miller. What a suckie role that is.
Miller can't be as exciting as Vanilla Townie I'm sure of it.
I hope Remus is mafia, I wanna live. :cry:
Well, it sucks for me. I've been playing this game, thinking I'd at least be seen as a townie by the half a dozen cops that are in it.
And Myrtle, no matter what happens, I doubt you'd survive next round.
Well, that was fast. xD
Remus Lupin (4): Rubeus Hagrid, Moaning Myrtle, Luna Lovegood, Voldemort
Moaning Myrtle (2): Mr. Filch, Remus Lupin
I'll log back into HP and get you your flavor text and death scene, you speed-lynchers.
That was majority? Wow, I thought it was 5. xD
I'll admit it, you played a good game though, yesterday you were last on my list. :)Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Remus Lupin
Didn't you just say it took six to lynch?
He sure did.
You said majority was 6 on page 31! ( 50 posts per page. )
I leave for a few minutes to do something and you all decide to pull a majority lynch... brilliant. I suppose I'd still vote Remus in the end...
I think Denmark miscounted or something, Dobby :p
Recruiter!? Uh oh..
o_o
I AM SUPREME FAILURE. It's 5 to lynch.
MY HUMBLEST APOLOGIES. D:
I don't blame you Dobby, I can't actually defend myself, except by the fact that I never did anything without the town's best interest in mind.
Don't delete it Denmark I saw. :(
Seeing as Denmark is Supreme failure, I'll come out.
I suppose I'll say the truth now, I'm in fact a Mafia recruiter. I'm the last of my faction, and there are actually still 2 factions left(1 after I'm dead). Myrtle is in the other faction, and Ron found that out for me. I was roleblocked last night, or Hagrid would not have survived the night.
I've been trying to lynch her ever since, seeing as the other mafia was killing us, and not the town.
My last deed will be to make sure that the other faction doesn't win, Plus, DD plays really awful, he shouldn't be allowed to win as mafia.
So I should just end the day then?
Yep!
If you're a Miller I am punching Denmark in the face.
People who need to be looked at closely tomorrow:
Albus Dumbledore
Dobby
Luna Lovegood
I know Voldemort is innocent (barring some ridiculous mafia role or a replacement Godfather). We can also be fairly sure that Filch is also innocent, considering 3/4 of Snape's list was correct. And I think Myrtle's just playing stupidly.
My observations: Luna and Dumbledore seem to be the most eager to keep the spotlight on Myrtle, siding with someone else only reluctantly. Dobby seems to try to be the most reasonable and not starting anything, only going along with others (perhaps trying to avoid suspicion).
I was thinking Dobby earlier, but Dumbledore today made me more suspicious. So take from all that what you will.
Harryfail.
Thats just lying out of your ass to get me lynched.Quote:
Originally Posted by [M] Remus Lupin
I would've voted Remus anyway... so:
##Vote: Lupin