Mafia XV Game Thread -- GAME OVER - TOWN WIN! (That's just Peachy!)

[[M] Mom – Host]

Do you mean Red Apple?

Players left:

[M] Pear
[M] Peach
[M] Red Apple
[M] Kiwi
[M] Plum

[[M] D'Anna]

err yeah sorry!

##Unvote

##Vote: Red Apple

[[M] Mom – Host]

[[M] Helo]

I know it. I will explain later if need be, but I know it. We have our last Mafia folks, and don't forget I told you.

##vote: Pear

[[M] Anise]

Pear - Suspicious, but possibly not mafia. Pear hasn't contributed a noteworthy post at all. Just comes in and votes without much of a reason much like Grape did a few times which makes it seem like Pear doesn't actually care at all. He might be a third party player or just lazy. I wouldn't rule out the third party thing, but nothing from Pear's voting pattern other than the completely random voting style and lay low behavior rings mafia to me.

Peach - If Peach wasn't in such cahoots with Red Apple, I'd say that Peach wasn't that suspicious. Sure Peach acts crazy, but as you've seen many of the people do. I do believe the "stupid posts" game Peach is playing is all for show either to protect their real EoFF identity or distract other people for the wrong reasons. My hunch is that's it's both. Although Peach has contributed what could be considered noteworthy posts; notice how every single one of Peach's votes and posts incriminate innocent people. Peach claims he's helping by posting something substantial, but I assure you this is all a part of his game. Peach has also voted quite a few times, the exact same way Red Apple has and has even defended Red Apple much like their scum pal Blueberry did. If there wasn't such a strange connection between the two and Peach's voting pattern weren't so bad I'd just say Peach was just bad as this game. zthe whole "look at me I'm stupid lemme post random crap" are just a facade to make it appear that way probably. Also seemed to know about the brothers thing before other people, hmmm.

Red Apple - Has consistently voted to lynch innocents since day 1. He also loves to make pro-towners look bad and usually succeeded at it, but not anymore. Blueberry isn't here to protect you!

Plum: Proven to be the Governor so on my innocent list.

[[M] Anise]

##Vote: Red Apple

[[M] Helo]

Pear did not only come in with a bandwagon vote, Pear came in with a bandwagon majority lynch vote. In fact Pear has been consistently weak since the start of the game when it comes to hard evidence and reasoning.

[[M] Anise]

It's most likely 3 town against 2 mafia. So if we screw today up we are most likely toast. So think my dear sweet Plum. And think closely.

[[M] Helo]

I'm thinking very closely. I was the only one right about Orange yesterday, and it was a perfect opportunity for a Mafia to end the day fast, putting them so close to victory. I have read through all of Pears' posts and none of them have anything that make me think Town, just excuses for her laidback persona and lackluster activity. I am town and Peach is town. There can only be one more town member and it is not Pear.

In fact, if Pear is Mafia then I can also hedge my bets you are as well. It's perfect really, the two Mafians voting for Red Apple who can be easily lynched. I'm trying to make connections between Red Apple and somebody else and I can find nobody. Process of elimination dictates to me that Pear is Mafia and so are you.

I'm sure naturally Red Apple will agree with me. After his vote it's up to Peach - do you go with pear and Kiwi or Plum and Red Apple.

This is what I believe.

[[M] Helo]

You've nailed yourself down really haven't you? You've proven that Red Apple can have no connection to you two, which just solidifies my Pear+Kiwi theory even more. You even said yourself there are two Mafia. Is it Peach and Red Apple? Would Peach behave as he has been if he were Mafia? This is why Kiwi and Pear is so much more believable.

[[M] Anise]

*facepalm*

[[M] Helo]

Fantastic counter argument.

[[M] Anise]

If this game has proven anything it has proven that you have not been thinking closely enough. Have you not noticed that every time Red Apple votes for something Peach joins in and vice versa? I'm not saying that Pear is not suspicious. His behavior definitely is, but there seems to be more of a connection with those two for some reason. If you can some how convince me Pear is more suspicious than Red Apple I will give you kudos, but if you don't town will lose because you will lynch off someone who is not Red Apple and town will lose.

[[M] Anise]

I think out of the group Pear, Peach, and Red Apple are mafia. But if I had to choose it would be Red Apple and Peach as most likely mafia because of consistently similar voting patterns and defense of each other. Red Apple is the safer out of the pair to choose as being scum.

[[M] Helo]

If this game has proven anything it has proven that you have not been thinking closely enough. Have you not noticed that every time Red Apple votes for something Peach joins in and vice versa? I'm not saying that Pear is not suspicious. His behavior definitely is, but there seems to be more of a connection with those two for some reason. If you can some how convince me Pear is more suspicious than Red Apple I will give you kudos, but if you don't town will lose because you will lynch off someone who is not Red Apple and town will lose.

This voting argument of yours extends to Pear as well. Yesterday Pear creates a majority, today Pear comes in with a Red Apple vote completely without explanation, which is promptly followed by you. The difference is we all know today could be the last day, and the behavior on the part of Pear is poor. Coincidental that you come in and vote Red Apple with explanation? No. It's likely you agreed on Red Apple as an easy target so you got rid of Grape paving the way for another easy lynch.