Page 32 of 71 FirstFirst ... 1222262728293031323334353637384252 ... LastLast
Results 466 to 480 of 1056

Thread: Mindsmurf Mafia - GAME OVER - Town Win - The Triple H gods are the heroes!

  1. #466

    Default

    Those are some really marvellous thoughts about Apollo, Hestia. Good job!

    Do you think he could perhaps really could be a bomb? I say this because of Eros's role, which was Mafia Hurt Locker. The Hurt Locker, of course, being a movie about bomb disposal, so perhaps the two are linked. If Apollo is not actually a bomb, somebody else may very well be. Please tell me what you think!

  2. #467

    Default

    Assuming Apollo is mafia he has knowledge of Eros's role, as you've said, mafia have black and white knowledge of this game. Therefore, Apollo would know there must be a bomb in this game.

  3. #468

    Default

    Hermes, your vote won't count because of the bandwagon effect in place.

  4. #469

    Default

    EDIT: Making a bomb roleclaim easy, convenient, and now that Eros died, "comfirmable".

  5. #470

    Default

    I think Hestia's on the right track there. If there is a bomb, or a bomb-esque role (as Eros's role suggests), then Apollo with his "tick tick" in earlier posts is probably the prime suspect.

  6. #471

    Default

    Hermes that vote on Posiedon will not count unfortunately, because the next vote must be on Apollo. You do raise a very good case against him, and to be honest he is another on my list of scum suspects. I just don't want to go after too many at once because then votes against them are too spread out and they can have an easier time throwing a townie in the line of fire at the last minute.

    Nyx is trying to worm her way out of suspicion. The reason why I blame her for lynching Persephone is that nobody seriously was giving a thought about her until after she made the Persephone saved Hades post.

    Why make a case against somebody and vote to lynch them if you don't want to? (Other than the forced bandwagons today of course) Watch out everyone, because Nyx is going to try everything to get an innocent townie to take the fall for her.

  7. #472

    Default

    Alright now if Hermes votes Posieden it will be a good vote.

    Recent vote history is

    Nyx
    Apollo
    Apollo

  8. #473

    Default

    Actually I missed/misread that post of Hestia's about the possibility Apollo is mafia. That could be true too. I'm not sure if I'd be willing to take a gamble and be the last vote on him though, if he is the bomb.

  9. #474

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by [M] Hygieia View Post
    Hermes that vote on Posiedon will not count unfortunately, because the next vote must be on Apollo. You do raise a very good case against him, and to be honest he is another on my list of scum suspects. I just don't want to go after too many at once because then votes against them are too spread out and they can have an easier time throwing a townie in the line of fire at the last minute.
    All candidates should always be considered. Even in a day like this, we should try to get everyone's votes where they want them. To nail it down to two or three suspects because we "have to" is to blind us from the mafia.

    Quote Originally Posted by [M] Hygieia View Post
    Nyx is trying to worm her way out of suspicion. The reason why I blame her for lynching Persephone is that nobody seriously was giving a thought about her until after she made the Persephone saved Hades post.
    Then it's our fault for listening to her.

    Quote Originally Posted by [M] Hygieia View Post
    Why make a case against somebody and vote to lynch them if you don't want to? (Other than the forced bandwagons today of course) Watch out everyone, because Nyx is going to try everything to get an innocent townie to take the fall for her.
    This point is already addressed.

    Quote Originally Posted by Nyx
    Obviously a vote for someone says you think they should be lynched, but I was in no way suggesting everyone should jump on and crusade for her immediate death. Just in case anyone took that incorrectly. I don't want to be arguing over semantics when we can argue over things of substance.
    Nyx cannot be placed for sole blame for yesterday. Especially not when I see many mafia candidates having voted for our doctor.

  10. #475

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by [M] Hygieia View Post
    Why make a case against somebody and vote to lynch them if you don't want to?
    Why do you vote for people? Because you think they're scummy, right? Same reason I voted for Persephone.

    I didn't 'make a case' against Persephone, I merely gave my justification. I still find it rich that you give me sole blame when there are six other people who contributed to her death. But no, don't blame them. They were swayed by my oh-so-compelling evidence. I don't know why you're gunning for me in particular, but it doesn't well with me.

  11. #476

    Default

    ##unvote
    ##vote Poseidon


    Thanks, friends! I was confused about the voting system and thought that the bandwagon effect had been cancelled out. I am glad you've got my back.

  12. #477

    Default

    No more biker gang? Can I still keep my bike? It's so quick.

    And the bandwagon effect is in play again, correct? I'm confused.

  13. #478

    Default

    Laaaaaame! I just spent a fortune on that Ducati and now you say the gang is done!?

    Anyways, what alignment is the bomb role? Can it be either or? I would assume that in this case it would be town aligned because of Eros' role as a mafia member. Why would mafia need a 'hurtlocker' if the bomb was mafia as well? For now I'm going to operate under the assumption that Apollo is town and, if he actually is a bomb, is just kind of a booby trap for mafia. I could be totally wrong in that though, I'm not a very seasoned Mafia player.

    Also, Hygieia, you're acting really strange. Your megapush for Nyx and Apollo is kind of unnerving to me.

    And Hermes what's with your change in attitude? Blink twice if you've been replaced with a pod person.

  14. #479

    Default

    Whoops sorry about that. Didn't realize I'd posted the my first thoughts.

  15. #480

    Default

    I haven't got anything useful to add to the discussion, so I'm going to hit the hay. Take care all.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •