Solution to Grand Mafia Puzzle:
Hebe - Town for reasons stated
Hemera - Town for willing to throw herself on the bomb
Hades - Town. Tried to trade shots with me on Day 1, very stupid thing for a mafia player to do, especially an experienced one. Was willing to throw self on bomb.
Thus this leaves:
Nyx, Hestia, Tyche
Hestia and Tyche are not mafia together. It would be very stupid for mafia members to smurf each other over in such a situation.
Therefore, one of them has to be mafia with Nyx.
We should lynch Tyche. If he is telling the truth, he can save himself, no harm done, and Hebe can whack Hestia.
##vote: Nyx
##vote: Tyche
B-but Governors can't prevent their own lynches!
However, I do agree about Nyx.
##Vote: Nyx
I agree perfectly. I prepped myself up a bit. Tyche's roleclaim is sorta believable, because SOMEONE has to be the other mason. However, nothing's said that the mason couldn't recruit mafia! Also, Nyx has yet to roleclaim, she could still roleclaim mason but by this point deciding between the two would be WIFOM. Killing both would be the best solution.
If Hebe tries to kill me right now, I will not die.
Then Hestia, that will prove your roleclaim.
##vote: Tyche
##vote: Nyx
Nyx is now majority
1 more vote for tyche and he is too
I believe we can survive a night with one death. Who else agrees?
I don't know by what rules Del is playing. Some governors can prevent their own lynch. I remember qwerty doing it once. If not, whoops, but you died for the town!
I do think Tyche is the other mason. Whether governor mason or mafia mason is yet to be decided.
Nyx is obviously the Godfather, if there is one.
Obvious. I need theories on if we think there are actually 2 or 1 mafia.
At present, I am working under the belief that there are 5 town, 2 mafia.
Worst case scenario:
Nyx town, Tyche town, can't prevent own lynch.
3 town, 2 mafia.
Mafia or Hebe kills town tonight; Hestia's protection misses targets, my own little ability does not pay off.
So yes, they can win, but they need a smurfload to go right for them.