Anniversary Mafia Game Thread - The Final Day

[[M] Helo]

Hello every body I just got here so please give me a chance to read this whole thread before you place your vote.

Also for the record, I stomp the hell out of anyone who says "let's vote for X for being annoying". Always have, always will. That trout is worse than the inactive fetish.

It is ok Nonstick I would not have voted for you any way.

You can't be looking at the meta or even basing judgments on it unless you're scum.

A MILLION DEL MURDERS!

What about two?

[[M] Helo]

Ok I have read everything but it is time for me to go to bed so goodnight.

[[M] Helo]

Ok I am awake now and I will type up a long post so please give me a few hours to get it posted as I must have my good friend and editor Jiro look over it first.

[[M] Helo]

It seems like Nonstick is a good player and has already found the scums and they are Blank and that guy Faris. So now we can spend the rest of the day planning the after-mafia buffet.

But let us make sure we do not become the snakes to his snake charming ways. As the philosopher Samuel L. Adams once said "There are too many mother smurfing snakes in this mother smurfing game".

So I will turn my attention to that onion kid Refia.

I still don't know who to go after, so I'll keep my vote on Penelo. It seems as good a vote as any outside the people who popped in once or twice then vanished.

But I thought Penelo was one of those people who did pop up and vanish. So why put your vote on her?

Of everyone so far, you seem the scummiest Rydia. But my reasoning is weak, it's only because of that weak cop role dropping idea. I really can't use that to justify a vote on the second sexiest girl around here.

I will help you with this game because you mention that you did not know who to go after in your post above. You should go after the person who seems the scummiest. You are welcome for the tip.

Well I'm going to go to sleep, so I'll switch my vote.
##Unvote: Panelo
##Vote: Wakka
Only because he doesn't understand the beauty of my Rydia.

That is odd that you vote for the person who questions the person who you think is scummiest.

And finally the worst thing of all I have read in this forum:

Quina is still oddly suspicious. Maybe we hurt it's feeling talking about how ugly and disgusting it is.

This makes me truly sad.

I will now open the floor for discussion.

[[M] Helo]

Thank you for the lively and entertaining discussion following my posts. Based on this I think I will place my vote on that guy Faris and trust that charmer Nonstick for now. I will not repeat his posts through the quote button but I agree with that train of thought for now. I still do not trust that onion kid how ever.

I will also mention that I believe my good friend Wedgie's role claim. It is odd that Serah did not get the report but there are various explanations for this some of which result in Serah turning red.

It is also odd that Delguna did not protect himself on Night 1. A veteran player with only Day 1 spam to snack on would not have a lot of cause to protect some one other than himself. So what happened?

##Vote: Faris

[[M] Gaius]

Quina, it's quite possible that Laguna protecting himself may not have been allowed (up to the game's moderator whether a role can target self or not; just because it's been done one way in the past doesn't mean it has to be done that way all the time).

I read the part where Rydia thought I was scum because of my oh-so-obvious cop "roleclaim" and the fact that I'm still alive. And I lol'd. Everyone gets information on day 2 in the form of the flips from the d1 lynch and the n1 kill; that info plus people's reactions is what I was going to attempt to use to scumhunt.

Then some other stuff happened in the thread and I'm tired. Can't consider myself able to read it currently, I have sleep to attend to.

[[M] Joe - Army Dad]

If they didn't pick Psy, are you saying, Psy is... is...

WE'RE ALL DOOMED!

Quick let's lynch him!

I would, I so want to type in that name.. but first:

What?!?! Laguna is dead?!?! You have some explaining to do now, don't you, Serah! You think I'm going to sit idly by when the doctor comes up dead after you received a special investigative report!?!?! I was willing to blow myself up to protect the world from Shinra, and I'm willing to risk my life on the line to expose you! What have you to say for yourself, Mafia scum!!!

##Vote: Serah

Wow.. that just reeks of scum. This came out of nowhere.

And seriously? You are either the WORST investigator ever, or a stupid mafia scapegoat, or both.

Yes... both.

##unvote

##vote: Wedge

[[M] Helo]

Hey Kain
use your brain
from Wedgie's claim
what would he gain?

[[M] Helo]

Quina, it's quite possible that Laguna protecting himself may not have been allowed (up to the game's moderator whether a role can target self or not; just because it's been done one way in the past doesn't mean it has to be done that way all the time).

That thought did not cross my mind Sean so thank you for it. Unfortunately it now pushed out an old thought and I think it was my favorite cookie recipe...

In most games a Doctor can protect themself but sometimes they can not. I guess we will not be able to figure out what happened on this day.

[[M] Greg - Hot Dad]

Well of course it would be you.

Also in regards to Wedge's claim... what does Wedge have to gain if he is town or mafia? What was the actual point in it? As far as I understand it's this: Serah receives a report on Laguna, Laguna dies, Serah is scum. Or, and here's a wacky tobacky thought... coincidence? You'd at least try to gather more evidence and have a report on Serah sent to somebody tonight if you felt that way before exposing what is potentially a ridiculously powerful role. I mean, the whole point of this role is that it's a Cop who doesn't even need to claim. Hell, it's an omni-Cop if it can detect people's roles too. So why claim, based on something that can easily be explained as a coincidence, when there is no more Doctor to protect you?

I don't know why you're all so quick to buy this. What if Wedge isn't scum but isn't telling the truth either...? Regardless, we don't have enough information to work on to make the judgment call here. I'm not for lynching him, but I'm not going to swallow this roleclaim just like that either.

[[M] Joe - Army Dad]

Hey Kain
use your brain
from Wedgie's claim
what would he gain?

Credibility, or so it would probably seem to him. Any real investigator would never out himself like that, especially on day 2. And I'm more likely to believe Serah than the crazy guy roleclaiming on day 2.

However, I've seen this plenty of times in newbie players playing mafia goons and the lack of experience, plus lack of direction causes them to do something this stupid. The only redeeming thing about it is that usually even the newbies aren't THAT stupid. But I'll keep my vote on him until I see something more scummy.

And congratulations, you're on my list now. I'll keep an eye (and spear) on you.

[[M] Greg - Hot Dad]

How does one get onto your list, Kain? And what sort of benefits are there?

[[M] Joe - Army Dad]

Health care, dental, 4 days off a month and a spear induced blood enema every day.

[[M] Felix]

Well of course it would be you.

Also in regards to Wedge's claim... what does Wedge have to gain if he is town or mafia? What was the actual point in it? As far as I understand it's this: Serah receives a report on Laguna, Laguna dies, Serah is scum. Or, and here's a wacky tobacky thought... coincidence? You'd at least try to gather more evidence and have a report on Serah sent to somebody tonight if you felt that way before exposing what is potentially a ridiculously powerful role. I mean, the whole point of this role is that it's a Cop who doesn't even need to claim. Hell, it's an omni-Cop if it can detect people's roles too. So why claim, based on something that can easily be explained as a coincidence, when there is no more Doctor to protect you?

I don't know why you're all so quick to buy this. What if Wedge isn't scum but isn't telling the truth either...? Regardless, we don't have enough information to work on to make the judgment call here. I'm not for lynching him, but I'm not going to swallow this roleclaim just like that either.

Noctis, I am for believing it because if he is mafia, he now needs to make up a report, every. night. There is no way he is going to be able to keep that up.

[[M] Joe - Army Dad]

Yeah, no, he couldn't. You're not allowed to PM anyone in a mafia game. So unless it was in his role he wouldn't be able to send anything.

And even if it was his role, what kind of idiot jumps to the conclusions he did? And so openly? Such reports are not given in the night phase, but when the day has started again, so the mafia could never use a report like that on night one.