It was so unmemorable to me when I first played it that I was moderately confused when I saw people gushing over it on this very forum a few months after playing the game. "Oh, you mean that thing I had to do to get Setzer?" I've always felt cheated that I was robbed of some magical emotional gaming moment, because I simply did not get it!

I've even seen the opera performed live and while it's neat, I still don't get the love this scene gets. As far as emotion goes, Edgar's coin toss, Locke and Rachel or anything with Cyan's guilt and loneliness are all much more powerful to me.