EoFF Mafia XXVIII Game Thread - Banquet of the Voyager Witches

[Pumpkin]

Okay this might be my mafia newbness, but is the Cynic a typical mafia role? Because if not, the next two purple statements about the Cynic really seem reliant on my truth being revealed first to fully understand. Or maybe that was the point because ~teamwork~ or something. It's just that mine is all like "There's this person called the cynic and this is what they do" and the other two seem much more to be based on the assumption that we know what it is already. Just like the alchemist and the town idiot both have description as to what those things are.

[Mr. Carnelian]

All these new roles are a Karifean thing, I'm fairly certain.

[Formalhaut]

Okay this might be my mafia newbness, but is the Cynic a typical mafia role? Because if not, the next two purple statements about the Cynic really seem reliant on my truth being revealed first to fully understand. Or maybe that was the point because ~teamwork~ or something. It's just that mine is all like "There's this person called the cynic and this is what they do" and the other two seem much more to be based on the assumption that we know what it is already. Just like the alchemist and the town idiot both have description as to what those things are.

Far from being a newb, you raise a very valid point. The other two Purple Statements seem entirely dependant on the existance of your Purple Statement which explains the role in more detail than the other two Statements, which read more as additions.

It is something to consider, that's for sure.

[Mr. Carnelian]

This is only the second game in which I've played for more than an hour, so don't rely on me as a source of info, though.

[Formalhaut]

The Cynic seems based on the Traitor role, which is an established role in Mafia, though I've never seen it before in EoFF Mafia, where games tend to be more generic. Which isn't a bad thing, it is just you don't see the more exotic roles on EoFF.

[Fynn]

I don't see why we should expect TSoL to be modkilled, we don't know for sure that it's false.

We don't. At least, I never saw anyone accuse him, but I may have missed something


I only mentioned modkilling in the context of Carny because I assume he lied about the three rewriting roles. Only witches and the cynic (supposedly) can lie about their statements as per the rules of the game we know so far. Of course, he could be some other role that can lie or we may actually have three rewrites, but if neither were the case, he would be modkilled for lying even though he can't lie.

[Fynn]

Okay, okay, here we go. Correct me if I got your vote wrong.

FFNut voted for.. Huckleberry Quin
Mr. Carnelian voted for… Fynn
Fynn voted for… Mr. Carnelian
Formy voted for… TSOLy
Pumpkin voted for… No lynch
Scruffington voted for… No lynch

No lynch has 2 votes.
Quin, Carny, Fynn and TSOL all have 1 vote each.

LIes, I voted for TSOL

[Pumpkin]

Oh okay, you assumed he lied so figured he should be modkilled or is a witch or cynic then, correct?

Sorry I thought you said TSoL when you said Carny, my bad

[Formalhaut]

Ugh, should I just do all future vote counts in future? I mean, that's what I usually do in games to keep things organised, and this game absolutely needs organisation to get anywhere.

[FFNut]

Ya I am not on the 3 re-write roles being true. That to me makes no scence at all. Especially looking over the rolls.

[Fynn]

It's kind of weird, though, since not once did I vote Mr Carny

[Mr. Carnelian]

It's kind of weird, though, since not once did I vote Mr Carny

Sorry, my mistake. Corrected version to follow.

[Pumpkin]

I believe Carny's truth. I don't know if that clears him though because witches can still truth it up in here

[Mr. Carnelian]

FFNut voted for.. Huckleberry Quin
Mr. Carnelian voted for… Fynn
Fynn voted for… TSOL
Formy voted for… TSOL
Pumpkin voted for… No lynch
Scruffington voted for… No lynch

No lynch has 2 votes.
TSOL has 2 voted.
Quin, Fynn and TSOL all have 1 vote each.

[Mr. Carnelian]

Unless... wait, you're not yanking my chain, are you Fynn?