Mafia - Game Over!

[DK]

You're so hung up on your own argument that you're not bothering to think outside the box. There are plenty of reasons for people to be voting against Maxx Power and not for me, and plenty of reasons for them to not want to explain themselves. To quote myself again;

Maybe they know something you don't. :}

And besides, the only thing you've come up for a "case" against me is voting pattern, which is flimsy at best. :}

[I Took the Red Pill]

Actually it's anything but flimsy.

Everyone in the mafia knows who everyone else in the mafia is. Citizens don't know jack about who the other citizens are.

So explain to me, why after you voted for Maxx Power, Manus and Resha suddenly, and directly after you changed their votes to match yours. "O WEL I TINK DANS INNOCENT". Yeah, my ass. You told them via either PM or instant messenger to change their votes you two-faced scum. If they had any common sense they would've waited a few posts to change their votes.

People don't just have epiphanies like that. "HOLY CHRIST MAXX POWER IS SUSPICIOUS CHANGE VOTE NOW PLOX." It doesn't work like that.

[Faris]

I'm sure if it were the other way around you'd all be saying pretty much the same thing.

[DK]

Also, I really don't buy this "vote changing being suspicious" thing. The first person who changed a vote changed their vote to me anyway! It became quickly apparent that this was going to be a two horse race between me and Maxx Power, one that looks as if it could go straight down to the wire. What does anyone have to gain from leaving a vote for someone not in the picture in a situation like that? Absolutely nothing. One of the two of us is going to die, and people have changed their votes to who they are more suspicious of, nothing more or less than that.

lern2readnub

[Radje]

Voting for someone who isn't in the picture has been done every round until this one, so why do you suddenly consider it ever so pointless now that you need to explain your way out of a bend DK?

[I Took the Red Pill]

What does anyone have to gain from leaving a vote for someone not in the picture in a situation like that?

Oh, I don't know, maybe if they're unsure of what either person is, and they don't want to vote for someone on, as you say, "flimsy" grounds? No, that's impossible, right?

Still waiting to see anything linking Maxx to anything suspicious by the way.

[Radje]

I'm sure if it were the other way around you'd all be saying pretty much the same thing.

Of course they would. If everyone had only voted for DK because they realised Maxx Power was in danger then i'd be suspicious of them too. They didn't, though. People voted for DK from their own steam, many people who had already publicly said they were suspicious of him in earlier rounds or even voted against him. This round it is a huge group of people who had never mentioned a tiny qualm against Maxx who are suddenly jumping to vote against him.

[Freya]

It'd divide votes if someone did so. It's possible that that one vote could mean doom for someone. It could be a 8-8 tie but then somone had decided to go for somone else. Then the on left would be dead.

[DK]

Voting for someone who isn't in the picture has been done every round until this one, so why do you suddenly consider it ever so pointless now that you need to explain your way out of a bend DK?

There are easy reasons for this, but I ain't saying them now. But you'll find out if you A.) think about it or B.) wait until this day is done and it comes out in the open anyway.

You're all assuming the game has stayed the same from the start and what people know now is the same thing they knew from the start. :}

[Radje]

It'd divide votes if someone did so. It's possible that that one vote could mean doom for someone. It could be a 8-8 tie but then somone had decided to go for somone else. Then the on left would be dead.

Yes but people have done that before in every round. Not voting for the people/ person everyone else is simply because they aren't sure, or aren't convinced enough to vote for either of them.

[The Summoner of Leviathan]

I guess we will all have to wait and see who will be lynched and what will be revealed. Eh?

[Captain Maxx Power]

In my defense I will say that I have been working to help the citizen side through my analysis. I've tried to make sure I didn't say or do anything that might appear "mafiaish" so far. While I don't want to shoot myself in the foot, the guys are probably right about the whole situation with votes being ganged up on me. Seriously, let's not lose another citizen.

[Freya]

It'd divide votes if someone did so. It's possible that that one vote could mean doom for someone. It could be a 8-8 tie but then somone had decided to go for somone else. Then the on left would be dead.

Yes but people have done that before in every round. Not voting for the people/ person everyone else is simply because they aren't sure, or aren't convinced enough to vote for either of them.

I'm Just saying that everyone is about convinced it's maxx or DK. So most votes will go to them, one that doesn't can ruin it for both sides. I don't think Neither would want that, at least I don't think they would, unless they have some scheme.

[Faris]

Of course they would. If everyone had only voted for DK because they realised Maxx Power was in danger then i'd be suspicious of them too. They didn't, though. People voted for DK from their own steam, many people who had already publicly said they were suspicious of him in earlier rounds or even voted against him. This round it is a huge group of people who had never mentioned a tiny qualm against Maxx who are suddenly jumping to vote against him.

Yeah, and in mafia you can vote whoever the heck you want. If other people want to vote for them, that's fine. I realize that I am the first person to vote Maxx in this. I could change my vote, but I have made a personal note not to make changes in my votes. It's just a coincidence that everyone else started to vote for him. Yes, by now we should be getting suspicious of other people. Heck, this big argument can make anyone taking part look suspicious.

[Shauna]

Okay. I vote DK. =[

[levian]ok[/levian]