Internet issues are infectious, apparently.
Anyway:
Fairy Fencer F: I'm going to stick with the archers for this one and go for Karin, and I find her being the public face of poor social skill "KILL" girl to be funny, for some reason.
Final Fantasy IX: While I cannot stand his tail, I'll go for Zidane. I've yet to play this game yet, but I don't know, I can't help but think Quina would drive me nuts. There's comic, then there's just goofy!
Fire Emblem Awakening: Frederick seems like the dashing knight type that I'm normally quite fond of, so I'll go for him. Ricken looks like a child, really.