Why is is unfeasible that there is more than one Vanilla Town? Going by what Karifean has said in the OP, there are two Mafia. That leaves 7 town-aligned folk. I wouldn't be surprised at the revelation that more than one of them don't have a role. But why does that surprise you?
This is the second time though, AK, that you have casually jumped on a bandwagon. Yesterday your reasoning was for the lulz, and today your reasoning doesn't make sense. Interesting.
I am personally pretty convinced that AK is either a roleblocker, which is a Chaos-aligned role, or a tracker, which could go either way.
So:
Shauna - 4/5 (FFNut, Fynn, Formalhaut, Aerith's Knight)
Scruffington - 0/5 (Aerith's Knight)
Freya - 0/5 (Aerith's Knight)
Did I miss anyone?
Right, to recap what we learned about Night One, I'll steal Scruffy's post, with the amendments about AK being Faris included. Not much else has been discussed up to this point, so hopefully we can glean more information before the day is out. As long as no jerks come in and throw a final vote on me to end the day prematurely.
Noctis (Fynn) did not appear to perform an action.
Seifer (qwertysaur) watched someone Kefka (Formalhaut).
Garnet (Scruffington) did not appear to perform an action.
Cid (Fox) watched someone Kefka (Formalhaut).
Kefka (Formalhaut) did not appear to perform an action.
Lenna (FFNut) did not appear to perform an action.
Shadow (Shauna) did not appear to perform an action.
Faris (Aerith's Knight) watched someone (Fynn).
??? (Freya) protected Lenna, Faris or Garnet.
Lenna, Faris or Garnet killed Seifer.
This information unfortunately makes it easy for a potential roleblocker to ruin everyone's night. But this is what we have.
As an aside, does each person only get one action per night? For example, would a roleblocker be able to role block as well as choosing a person to kill? I mean, it doesn't specify in the role list that a roleblocker can kill, so if a roleblocker's cohort were to be taken out, do they even have the ability to kill another player in the night phase?
So by that logic, should we treat Faris being described as an androgynous person first as a red herring?
What do you mean?
If we assume Faris is the killer - the killer who is most definitely described as a girl - we'd have to ignore the fact that she was described as an androgynous individual (with "they/them" pronouns and everything), or assume that the game master purposefully used two descriptors for one character just to confuse us.
I don't quite follow why Shauna has 4 votes here. There are way more suspicious people IMO. And I feel like stopping the murderer should be a high priority for obvious reasons. To that end...
##Vote: FFNut
Ah, right. I understand. I just put down all the claimed females there - I personally do not think Faris did a killing, but it led me to my thought experiment above, so I decided to leave it until we get an answer. If we get an answer.Originally Posted by Fynn
I also don't think they did the killing, as from my understanding of the rules that isn't really a possibility. But yeah, we need Karifean to confirm that.
Every player may only have one role.
So even if Faris is potentially Chaos-aligned, they are not the killer since they already used their ability to watch me.
So if that player's role does not include killin', then they are unable to kill?
Right, my day at work is almost over. I don't know whether I'll be home for the end of the day, because I'm away out this evening.
##Vote: FFNut
soz bud you're shady as heck
Shauna - 4/5 (FFNut, Fynn, Formalhaut, Aerith's Knight)
FFNut - 2/5 (Fox, Shauna)
Scruffington - 0/5 (Aerith's Knight)
Freya - 0/5 (Aerith's Knight)
Posting Permissions
